Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Masonic Observer
  • March 20, 1859
  • Page 12
Current:

The Masonic Observer, March 20, 1859: Page 12

  • Back to The Masonic Observer, March 20, 1859
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article Colonial. ← Page 2 of 4 →
Page 12

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Colonial.

" 5 . —Constitution of the Grand Chapter of Canada . " I sent you a printed copy of the proceedings , which , I hope , reached you . They would make you quite an fait , on the subject of our Union , but one of the articles of that Union is so emphatic that I am induced to subscribe it at full length . It declares ( after the preamble)—"' It is resolved ;—That an impartial review of all the

eventful circumstances attending its organization—its priority—its subsequent important proceedings , —and its recognition by a portion of the British Empire , and by a very large proportion of the Grand Lodges of the United States of America , —demonstrates that the Grand Lodge of Canada , organized on the 10 th October , 1855 , and known and recognized as

aforesaid , by the style and title of The Grand Lodge of Ancient Free and Accepted Masons of Canada , should be acknowledged by the entire Canadian Craft , and should be , and is hereby declared to be , the Grand Lodge of the Fraternity , in and THROUGHOUT CANADA . ' " As a Rider to the foregoing , the last resolution provides for the future enrolment of all Provincial Grand and Private Lodges not then in alliance with us . If you will refer to the

list of officers ( page 69 ) , you will perceive that they are taken from all parts of Canada . " I think what I have sent will be of use to you . It is a matter of sincere regret that the Grand Master appointed any successor to Bro . Harington , at Quebec , for the Grand Lodge of Canada was even then too solidly established to be ignored . "In conclusion , I cannot too seriously assure you , that

the Grand Lodge of Canada is very anxious to be in full communion with the Grand Lodge of England . We have lost none of our Masonic and true Brotherly affection and regard ; but we must be consistent , and an implied acceptance , even of the present proffer of recognition , would be , in effect , stultifying ourselves . We may continue to recognize such few Lodges as are now existing in Canada , and desirous

of preserving their allegiance to the Grand Lodge of England , but the powers of Provincial Grand Masters must cease , for no new Lodges can or will be tolerated , other than such as may be established by the Grand Lodge of Canada . The latter Body can communicate on equal terms with the Grand Lodge of England alone . The Provincial Grand Masters ( and through them the Provincial Grand Lodges ) , are not supreme , but subject to extinction at the pleasure of the M . W . Grand Master . "

TASMANIA . The Freemasons' Magazine gives the following narrative of the proceedings which have taken place subsequent to the decision of Grand Lodge to uphold Bro . Ewing in his authority , and to reject the appeal of the Hobart Town brethren to be taken from under the jurisdiction of the Provincial Grand Master of Tasmania . It appears that upon this decision reaching Hobart Town , Bro . Charles Toby , the Worshiful Master of No . 781 called a meeting of the Lodgeto

p , , consider what course should be taken . This meeting was held on the 3 rd of June , and the following resolutions carried by a majority of twenty-eight to five : — ' ¦ That this Lodge , in obedience to the decision of the Most Worshipful Grand Master , conveyed in the letter of the Grand Secretary , dated 11 th March last , recognises the appointment of the Rev . E . K . Ewing , as Provincial Grand Master , and begs to be reinstated in its Masonic functions . " On the following day Bro . Toby addressed a letter to Bro . Ewing , communicating the result of the and that he would immediatel

meeting , expressing a hope " y restore the Lodge to its Masonic functions , and also legalize the proceedings while working , pending the decision of Grand Lodge . " This letter remained unanswered for eight days , when the Uight Worshipful Provincial Grand Master apologised for the delay , on the ground of " excess of occupation , " and proceeded to say" The submission of the Brethren to the command of the Most Worshipful the Grand Master , has given me , as liis representative in the province , much satisfaction , and I may accept it as a well

intended pledge of a harmony that you , and the Brethren of No . 781 , will endeavour to maintain among the Craft in Tasmania . " I am glad that so many of the Brethren present were agreed as to the course adopted ; and in taking the requisite steps for restoring matters to a proper footing , I will thank you to furnish me with a list of the names of the brethren who voted for the minute you have sent me , and the names of the five who voted against . I shall then lose no time in having the necessary documents made out . " I beg to statehoweverthat I have not the to legalise the

, , power proceedings of the Lodge which took place during the period of suspension . To give them effect , they must be done over again , if required , so soon as the Lodge is at work . Such meeting or meetings of the Brethren , as were held at the request of the Grand Lodge , or my own , with a view to the settlement of differences , are , upon that request legal , and form part of the records of No . 781 ; but beyond this , all business transactions , from the time of suspension sustained by Grand Lodge , is in itself wrong . You will , I am sure , therefore

perceive that I cannot make right what both the Constitution and the Grand Lodge pronounce wrong . When the necessary documents are completed , I shall be happy to visit Hobart Town . " To this Bro . Toby replied on the following day , stating that he had no record of the brethren voting against the resolution—four of them having immediately retired from the room on being placed in a minority ; and praying that as the Lodge had been suspended en masseso miht it be restored to its functions en masseAlthough

, g . this communication was dated on the 12 th of June , no reply was received until the 5 th of August , a period of nearly two months , and then only on the receipt of a " refresher" —as our legal brethren would say—from Bro . Toby , calling his attention to the length of time which had intervened since he wrote to him ; and here it would seem that Bro . Ewing , looking at the importance of the question under consideration , had placed himself in the wrong , did we not bear in mind that he was in a measure forced to be cautiousowing

, to the position in which he was placed , and the eagerness with which every word and act was seized upon by some of the brethren to his prejudice . In the letter of August 5 th , Bro . Ewing stated that he had come to the conclusion , " that it would be unwarrantable and uninasonic , " to restore the Lodge en masse , and " that each member must himself renew his allegiance ere he can hope for the benefit of release . " Here there can be no doubt that the Provincial Grand

Master was right , as Bro . Wilkinson , with one or two others , had placed themselves in distinct opposition to his authority , and declared that , rather than place themselves under the control of the Provincial Grand Lodge , they would retire altogether from Freemasonry . With the letter of the 5 th of August was also sent a form of petition , for the Brethren who wished to be restored to their Masonic functions to sign . This Bro . Toby immediately did , and proceeded to obtain the signatures of other brothers , determining , however , not to present it until he received information of the Grand Lodge of England

having confirmed the decision come to in March . This information appears to have reached the colony on the 19 th of October ; and on the same day the petition was forwarded to Bro . Ewing—Bro . Toby remarking that many of the brethren had had no opportunity of signing it , owing to their absence from the colony . On the 26 th , Bro . Ewing acknowledged the receipt of the petition , and an accompanying letter , putting however ( as he says , with the advice of his Board of General Purposes ) what we must be allowed to desi the absurd

gnate following questions : — " 1 st . Has any communication , memorial , or letter , bearing directly or indirectly on the subject-matter in dispute between the E . W . the Prov . G . M ., and No . 781 , or on the K . VV . the Prov . G . M . personally , been sent to the Grand Secretary , or to any member of Grand Lodge , by No . 781 , either by or through its W . M ., board of P . Ms ., Secretary , or any other officer or any member signing the petition ? " 2 nd . In the Hobart Town Daily Mercury , of 26 th August , an article from Masonic at the

a journal * was reprinted request of a large number of the Craft . Has any member signing the petition , acted , or been interested , directly or indirectly , in seeking or causing tho publication in the Mercury of the said article ? " 3 rd . In the Ilobart Town Daily Mercury , of 7 th September , Bro . Wilkinson caused to be printed a letter sent officially from the Secretary of Hope , No . 901 , to the Secretary of No . 781 , containing a part of the ceremonial of Lodge working ; and which letter , of course , was the records of Lod 781 will inform

preserved among ge No . : you me by whose authority , and by what means , that letter became available to Bro . Wilkinson , and whether any member signing the petition was concerned , either directly or indirectly , by act or knowledge , in the publication by Bro . Wilkinson , of the letter of Bro . A . Learmouth , Secretary of Hope , No . 901 ?" This communication was considered at a meeting of the Brethren * The Freemasons' Magazine .

“The Masonic Observer: 1859-03-20, Page 12” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 15 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mob/issues/mob_20031859/page/12/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 2
Untitled Article 3
Untitled Article 3
UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND. Article 4
THE GRAND LODGE PROPERTY. Article 10
AUSTRALIA. Article 11
Colonial. Article 11
Mark Masonry. Article 14
Masonic Charities. Article 15
Provincial. Article 15
ADDRESS Article 18
REPLY. Article 18
GRAND LODGE CLUB. Article 19
THE FREEMASONS' MAGAZINE AND THE EXECUTIVE. Article 19
LODGE OF BENEVOLENCE. Article 19
Correspondence. Article 20
Untitled Ad 20
Untitled Article 20
Untitled Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

3 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

3 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

3 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

4 Articles
Page 12

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Colonial.

" 5 . —Constitution of the Grand Chapter of Canada . " I sent you a printed copy of the proceedings , which , I hope , reached you . They would make you quite an fait , on the subject of our Union , but one of the articles of that Union is so emphatic that I am induced to subscribe it at full length . It declares ( after the preamble)—"' It is resolved ;—That an impartial review of all the

eventful circumstances attending its organization—its priority—its subsequent important proceedings , —and its recognition by a portion of the British Empire , and by a very large proportion of the Grand Lodges of the United States of America , —demonstrates that the Grand Lodge of Canada , organized on the 10 th October , 1855 , and known and recognized as

aforesaid , by the style and title of The Grand Lodge of Ancient Free and Accepted Masons of Canada , should be acknowledged by the entire Canadian Craft , and should be , and is hereby declared to be , the Grand Lodge of the Fraternity , in and THROUGHOUT CANADA . ' " As a Rider to the foregoing , the last resolution provides for the future enrolment of all Provincial Grand and Private Lodges not then in alliance with us . If you will refer to the

list of officers ( page 69 ) , you will perceive that they are taken from all parts of Canada . " I think what I have sent will be of use to you . It is a matter of sincere regret that the Grand Master appointed any successor to Bro . Harington , at Quebec , for the Grand Lodge of Canada was even then too solidly established to be ignored . "In conclusion , I cannot too seriously assure you , that

the Grand Lodge of Canada is very anxious to be in full communion with the Grand Lodge of England . We have lost none of our Masonic and true Brotherly affection and regard ; but we must be consistent , and an implied acceptance , even of the present proffer of recognition , would be , in effect , stultifying ourselves . We may continue to recognize such few Lodges as are now existing in Canada , and desirous

of preserving their allegiance to the Grand Lodge of England , but the powers of Provincial Grand Masters must cease , for no new Lodges can or will be tolerated , other than such as may be established by the Grand Lodge of Canada . The latter Body can communicate on equal terms with the Grand Lodge of England alone . The Provincial Grand Masters ( and through them the Provincial Grand Lodges ) , are not supreme , but subject to extinction at the pleasure of the M . W . Grand Master . "

TASMANIA . The Freemasons' Magazine gives the following narrative of the proceedings which have taken place subsequent to the decision of Grand Lodge to uphold Bro . Ewing in his authority , and to reject the appeal of the Hobart Town brethren to be taken from under the jurisdiction of the Provincial Grand Master of Tasmania . It appears that upon this decision reaching Hobart Town , Bro . Charles Toby , the Worshiful Master of No . 781 called a meeting of the Lodgeto

p , , consider what course should be taken . This meeting was held on the 3 rd of June , and the following resolutions carried by a majority of twenty-eight to five : — ' ¦ That this Lodge , in obedience to the decision of the Most Worshipful Grand Master , conveyed in the letter of the Grand Secretary , dated 11 th March last , recognises the appointment of the Rev . E . K . Ewing , as Provincial Grand Master , and begs to be reinstated in its Masonic functions . " On the following day Bro . Toby addressed a letter to Bro . Ewing , communicating the result of the and that he would immediatel

meeting , expressing a hope " y restore the Lodge to its Masonic functions , and also legalize the proceedings while working , pending the decision of Grand Lodge . " This letter remained unanswered for eight days , when the Uight Worshipful Provincial Grand Master apologised for the delay , on the ground of " excess of occupation , " and proceeded to say" The submission of the Brethren to the command of the Most Worshipful the Grand Master , has given me , as liis representative in the province , much satisfaction , and I may accept it as a well

intended pledge of a harmony that you , and the Brethren of No . 781 , will endeavour to maintain among the Craft in Tasmania . " I am glad that so many of the Brethren present were agreed as to the course adopted ; and in taking the requisite steps for restoring matters to a proper footing , I will thank you to furnish me with a list of the names of the brethren who voted for the minute you have sent me , and the names of the five who voted against . I shall then lose no time in having the necessary documents made out . " I beg to statehoweverthat I have not the to legalise the

, , power proceedings of the Lodge which took place during the period of suspension . To give them effect , they must be done over again , if required , so soon as the Lodge is at work . Such meeting or meetings of the Brethren , as were held at the request of the Grand Lodge , or my own , with a view to the settlement of differences , are , upon that request legal , and form part of the records of No . 781 ; but beyond this , all business transactions , from the time of suspension sustained by Grand Lodge , is in itself wrong . You will , I am sure , therefore

perceive that I cannot make right what both the Constitution and the Grand Lodge pronounce wrong . When the necessary documents are completed , I shall be happy to visit Hobart Town . " To this Bro . Toby replied on the following day , stating that he had no record of the brethren voting against the resolution—four of them having immediately retired from the room on being placed in a minority ; and praying that as the Lodge had been suspended en masseso miht it be restored to its functions en masseAlthough

, g . this communication was dated on the 12 th of June , no reply was received until the 5 th of August , a period of nearly two months , and then only on the receipt of a " refresher" —as our legal brethren would say—from Bro . Toby , calling his attention to the length of time which had intervened since he wrote to him ; and here it would seem that Bro . Ewing , looking at the importance of the question under consideration , had placed himself in the wrong , did we not bear in mind that he was in a measure forced to be cautiousowing

, to the position in which he was placed , and the eagerness with which every word and act was seized upon by some of the brethren to his prejudice . In the letter of August 5 th , Bro . Ewing stated that he had come to the conclusion , " that it would be unwarrantable and uninasonic , " to restore the Lodge en masse , and " that each member must himself renew his allegiance ere he can hope for the benefit of release . " Here there can be no doubt that the Provincial Grand

Master was right , as Bro . Wilkinson , with one or two others , had placed themselves in distinct opposition to his authority , and declared that , rather than place themselves under the control of the Provincial Grand Lodge , they would retire altogether from Freemasonry . With the letter of the 5 th of August was also sent a form of petition , for the Brethren who wished to be restored to their Masonic functions to sign . This Bro . Toby immediately did , and proceeded to obtain the signatures of other brothers , determining , however , not to present it until he received information of the Grand Lodge of England

having confirmed the decision come to in March . This information appears to have reached the colony on the 19 th of October ; and on the same day the petition was forwarded to Bro . Ewing—Bro . Toby remarking that many of the brethren had had no opportunity of signing it , owing to their absence from the colony . On the 26 th , Bro . Ewing acknowledged the receipt of the petition , and an accompanying letter , putting however ( as he says , with the advice of his Board of General Purposes ) what we must be allowed to desi the absurd

gnate following questions : — " 1 st . Has any communication , memorial , or letter , bearing directly or indirectly on the subject-matter in dispute between the E . W . the Prov . G . M ., and No . 781 , or on the K . VV . the Prov . G . M . personally , been sent to the Grand Secretary , or to any member of Grand Lodge , by No . 781 , either by or through its W . M ., board of P . Ms ., Secretary , or any other officer or any member signing the petition ? " 2 nd . In the Hobart Town Daily Mercury , of 26 th August , an article from Masonic at the

a journal * was reprinted request of a large number of the Craft . Has any member signing the petition , acted , or been interested , directly or indirectly , in seeking or causing tho publication in the Mercury of the said article ? " 3 rd . In the Ilobart Town Daily Mercury , of 7 th September , Bro . Wilkinson caused to be printed a letter sent officially from the Secretary of Hope , No . 901 , to the Secretary of No . 781 , containing a part of the ceremonial of Lodge working ; and which letter , of course , was the records of Lod 781 will inform

preserved among ge No . : you me by whose authority , and by what means , that letter became available to Bro . Wilkinson , and whether any member signing the petition was concerned , either directly or indirectly , by act or knowledge , in the publication by Bro . Wilkinson , of the letter of Bro . A . Learmouth , Secretary of Hope , No . 901 ?" This communication was considered at a meeting of the Brethren * The Freemasons' Magazine .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 11
  • You're on page12
  • 13
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy