Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • March 29, 1862
  • Page 5
  • NOTES ON LITERATURE, SCIENCE, AND ART.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, March 29, 1862: Page 5

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, March 29, 1862
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. ← Page 4 of 4
    Article MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Page 4 of 4
    Article NOTES ON LITERATURE, SCIENCE, AND ART. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Notes And Queries.

States from which they emigrated , and who brought with them the forms of their own initiation , ancl to ivhich they adhered with the usual amount of prejudice and pertinacity , which all have experienced in such matters , and perhaps have exhibited in our own individual cases . Of these , many hacl been initiated in Lodges ivhich worked the three degrees after ( or under ) the French and Scottish Rites , and in time diffused much of the peculiarities of those Rites into tbe working of Lodges , until

at last , Lodges were found , which worked exclusively as one or the other of those Rites . Indeed , such was the case with Polar Star Lodge ( No . 5 ) , from nearly the first , as to the Scottish Rite ; ancl so with respect to some others , as to the French or Modern Rite . To this , some who thought more of forn * -than of sense , of shadow than of substance , objected , under the then order of things ; the result of which was , the making of a radical change in the regulations of the Grand Lodgeby which

, the three Rites were not only recognised , but the Grand Lodge authorised the issuing to any Lodge requesting and paying for the same , three distinct charters or warrants—one for each of the three Rites , York , Modern , or Scottish—or either of them , as the Lodge may wish ; and at the same time established chambers for the Modern and Scottish Rites in the Grand lodge , that is , committees who should have exclusive control over the affairs peculiar to these Rites , and thus , in effect ,

establishing in this State three distinct Masonries , where , in fact , but one really existed . To this , which we must term foolish distinction , we easily trace all our difficulties and differences , past , present , and future . Hacl the leaders of those days in our Order , but sought after the true principles of Freemasonry , and found , as they would have done , that each so-called Rite was , in effect , but a different name for the same thing ; had they then abolished all distinctive appellations of YorkFrench

, , and Scottish , and substituted in the constitution of the Grand Lodge , and in the warrants it issued , 'Ancient , Free and Accepted . ' for the words , ' York , Scottish , or French ; ' had they * but looked after the substance more , and the shadow less , the reality more than the name , and been less anxious for high sounding titles and distinctions , the troubles of 1848 to 1850 , and of the present time , would never have existed . The slight discrepancies iu the work , which have become more distinct and

irreconcilable by tbe course of 1832 , would have entirely disappeared , aud we should now have in name what is almost a reality- —but one Masonry in the State of Louisiana , and but one Rite—that of Freemasonry . This we tried to effect in 1850 , at the convention in Baton Rouge , in the formation of the late constitution , and which would have been already accomplished , but for the designs of an ambitious , disaffected few ; who , acting upon the prejudices and ignorance of some , by ' representing

to them that nothing was Masonry but Scottish Masonry , and ¦ that this was prohibited by the Grancl Lodge , led to the revolt ¦ of 1850 , and of 1857 . ' " This brings us to another branch of the inquiries made of us , namely : in regard to those so called Superior Bodies , in whose name these revolts have been made . Some time prior to 1830 , certain Masons , who had , in France or elsewhere , received some or all of these higher degreesactingwe know not upon what

, , authority ( nor does it much concern us to know ) , organised a body in New Orleans , known as the Grand Consistory of the 32 nd Degree for the State of Louisiana . This body , if properly organized , claimed authority and control over Lodges of Perfection ( 14 th Degree ) , Councils of Princes of Jerusalem { 16 th Degree ) , Chapter of Rose Croix ( 18 th Degree ) , Councils of Kadosh ( 30 th Degree ) , and all Masons possessing those and the intermediate degrees , from the 4 tli to the 32 nd , inclusive ;

at any rate , clue obedience was given to the Grancl Consistory by all over whom the authority was claimed . There was nothing out of the way in all this ; nor would there ever have been had not certain amibitious men , in some way , obtained the 33 rd , or last degree of the Ancient and Accepted Rite ; ancl , by virtue of that title , attempted to exercise powers which never belonged to that degree , but which was pretended , by virtue of a certain draft of powers ( quite recently discovered to have been forged ) ,

such as the right of making Masons at sight , ancl the right of constituting Symbolic Lodges of the Rite . These powers , exercised and claimed to exist in each and every individual who bad received the 33 rd Degree , we have said was based on a forged document ; yet they were exercised , in part , at least , in this State , some years ago , and , quite frequently , within the last two years . The result of several having received this degree ¦ was the formation , in 1839 , of the Supreme Council of New Orleans , who claimed control over the whole of Masonry in

Masonic Notes And Queries.

Louisiana . Indeed , we know of instances in which , so late as 1844 , it expelled members of the Grand Lodge , and required that body to simply declare the brother expelled merely unreason of his expulsion by this Supreme Council . All this went well , so long as the members of this Supreme Council hacl control of the Grand Lodge , and this they had contrived to possess by the various complicated provisions of the Regulations of 1832 , before alluded to . The tyrannical ancl umnasouic exercise of

power by these rnlers , was the chief , if not the sole cause of revolt in 1847 , and the formation of the Louisiana Grand Lodge , through the intervention of the Grand Lodge of Mississippi . The result we have above intimated in tbe adoption of the constitution of 1850 . It was then that this Supreme Council began to exercise its more than doubtful powers , by the chartering of Lodges and other similar acts of jurisdiction , in conflict with that of the Grand Lodge .

"But , fortunately for us , perhaps , it was discovered that this Supreme Council was illegal and spurious , and had been organized within the immediate jurisdiction of another Supreme Council ( that for the southern jurisdiction ofthe United States , sitting at Charleston , South Carolina ) . This discovery led to the immediate dissolution of the body , aud the union , in 1 S 54 , of its members , ancl all its subordinates , with a Grand Consistory , which had been already legally organized in the State , by the Supreme Council at Charleston . By this proceeding , all the lodges under its control fell tothe ground , ancl subsequently returned to the Grand Lodge ; and thus were all divisions

supposed to be healed . The Supreme Council at Charleston renounced all claim to jurisdiction over the three Symbolic Degrees ; the present Grand Consistory of Louisiana does not dream of any such claim ; and there should be nothing , apparently , to disturb our harmony and quiet . " There were a few disaffected ones , however , who never came back to the Grand Lodge . These claimed to be 33 rds , and , as such , to possess the right to make Masons at sight , and . to

constitute Lodges of the three Symbolic Degrees . They , in defiance of their obligations as 33 rds , if they really are such , next proceeded to form a ¦ " Supreme Council for the Sovereign ancl Independent State of Louisiana , " and have made Masons ( of course clandestine ) , and chartered several lodges ancl higher bodies ( also clandestine ) , of the exact number of which we are ignorant . It is with this body we have to contend , ancl this only . It is this so-called Supreme Council , ivhich neither the

Grancl Orient of France , nor any other Masonic body whatever , has recognised ; and we think ourselves safe in saying , that no body of regular Masons will ever recognise it . Yet , through the ignorance as to the difference—or rather the want of difference—between the several Rites , and the prejudices growing out of race , and made permanent , as it were , by ignorance , a portion of several of our lodges have withdrawn from us , and taken charters from this spurious ancl so-called Supreme Council .

And here we feel the result of admitting ignorant men into our Order—more fully portrayed in another place—and the necessity of a correct knowledge of the true principles of Freemasonry being instilled into the mind of every initiate . "

Notes On Literature, Science, And Art.

NOTES ON LITERATURE , SCIENCE , AND ART .

The first volume of Mr . Elwin ' s edition of the Life , Letters , and Worlcs of Pope is in the press , ancl will , we hear , comprise many facts of high interest never ascertained befoi'e . The Golden Precepts of Prince Albert , selected from his speeches , and printed on toned paper , will he published immediately .

Dr . Goodwin , Dean , of Ely , has a fifth series of Parish Sermons nearly ready . What fabulous numbers , gossips the Literary Gazette , have not been mentioned at dinner-tables and other places conducive to an excess of good nature , as representing the total circulation of tlie admirably conducted ComHll Mcw / craiie—200 , 000 ,

150 , 000 , 100 , 000 , and so on . A hard-working news-agent and magazine dealer , who knows to a nicety what the members of his trade use , and the numbers turned out by the bookbindersivhich body , by the way , cannot very well be ignorant of the quantities that pass through their hands—forwards the follow-

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1862-03-29, Page 5” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 3 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_29031862/page/5/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
MASONIC FACTS. Article 1
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 2
NOTES ON LITERATURE, SCIENCE, AND ART. Article 5
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 6
PORTRAIT OF BRO. CREW. Article 7
THE CHANNEL ISLANDS. Article 7
CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES. Article 8
MASTERS AND WARDENS. Article 8
AGED MASONS' WIVES. Article 8
HELE. Article 8
HIGH PRIESTHOOD. Article 8
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 9
METROPOLITAN. Article 9
PROVINCIAL. Article 10
YORKSHIRE (WEST.) Article 13
CHANNEL ISLANDS. Article 13
SCOTLAND. Article 13
INDIA. Article 13
ROYAL ARCH. Article 16
MARK MASONRY. Article 17
NOTES ON MUSIC AND THE DRAMA. Article 18
THE WEEK. Article 18
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

2 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

6 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

5 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

2 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

2 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

2 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Notes And Queries.

States from which they emigrated , and who brought with them the forms of their own initiation , ancl to ivhich they adhered with the usual amount of prejudice and pertinacity , which all have experienced in such matters , and perhaps have exhibited in our own individual cases . Of these , many hacl been initiated in Lodges ivhich worked the three degrees after ( or under ) the French and Scottish Rites , and in time diffused much of the peculiarities of those Rites into tbe working of Lodges , until

at last , Lodges were found , which worked exclusively as one or the other of those Rites . Indeed , such was the case with Polar Star Lodge ( No . 5 ) , from nearly the first , as to the Scottish Rite ; ancl so with respect to some others , as to the French or Modern Rite . To this , some who thought more of forn * -than of sense , of shadow than of substance , objected , under the then order of things ; the result of which was , the making of a radical change in the regulations of the Grand Lodgeby which

, the three Rites were not only recognised , but the Grand Lodge authorised the issuing to any Lodge requesting and paying for the same , three distinct charters or warrants—one for each of the three Rites , York , Modern , or Scottish—or either of them , as the Lodge may wish ; and at the same time established chambers for the Modern and Scottish Rites in the Grand lodge , that is , committees who should have exclusive control over the affairs peculiar to these Rites , and thus , in effect ,

establishing in this State three distinct Masonries , where , in fact , but one really existed . To this , which we must term foolish distinction , we easily trace all our difficulties and differences , past , present , and future . Hacl the leaders of those days in our Order , but sought after the true principles of Freemasonry , and found , as they would have done , that each so-called Rite was , in effect , but a different name for the same thing ; had they then abolished all distinctive appellations of YorkFrench

, , and Scottish , and substituted in the constitution of the Grand Lodge , and in the warrants it issued , 'Ancient , Free and Accepted . ' for the words , ' York , Scottish , or French ; ' had they * but looked after the substance more , and the shadow less , the reality more than the name , and been less anxious for high sounding titles and distinctions , the troubles of 1848 to 1850 , and of the present time , would never have existed . The slight discrepancies iu the work , which have become more distinct and

irreconcilable by tbe course of 1832 , would have entirely disappeared , aud we should now have in name what is almost a reality- —but one Masonry in the State of Louisiana , and but one Rite—that of Freemasonry . This we tried to effect in 1850 , at the convention in Baton Rouge , in the formation of the late constitution , and which would have been already accomplished , but for the designs of an ambitious , disaffected few ; who , acting upon the prejudices and ignorance of some , by ' representing

to them that nothing was Masonry but Scottish Masonry , and ¦ that this was prohibited by the Grancl Lodge , led to the revolt ¦ of 1850 , and of 1857 . ' " This brings us to another branch of the inquiries made of us , namely : in regard to those so called Superior Bodies , in whose name these revolts have been made . Some time prior to 1830 , certain Masons , who had , in France or elsewhere , received some or all of these higher degreesactingwe know not upon what

, , authority ( nor does it much concern us to know ) , organised a body in New Orleans , known as the Grand Consistory of the 32 nd Degree for the State of Louisiana . This body , if properly organized , claimed authority and control over Lodges of Perfection ( 14 th Degree ) , Councils of Princes of Jerusalem { 16 th Degree ) , Chapter of Rose Croix ( 18 th Degree ) , Councils of Kadosh ( 30 th Degree ) , and all Masons possessing those and the intermediate degrees , from the 4 tli to the 32 nd , inclusive ;

at any rate , clue obedience was given to the Grancl Consistory by all over whom the authority was claimed . There was nothing out of the way in all this ; nor would there ever have been had not certain amibitious men , in some way , obtained the 33 rd , or last degree of the Ancient and Accepted Rite ; ancl , by virtue of that title , attempted to exercise powers which never belonged to that degree , but which was pretended , by virtue of a certain draft of powers ( quite recently discovered to have been forged ) ,

such as the right of making Masons at sight , ancl the right of constituting Symbolic Lodges of the Rite . These powers , exercised and claimed to exist in each and every individual who bad received the 33 rd Degree , we have said was based on a forged document ; yet they were exercised , in part , at least , in this State , some years ago , and , quite frequently , within the last two years . The result of several having received this degree ¦ was the formation , in 1839 , of the Supreme Council of New Orleans , who claimed control over the whole of Masonry in

Masonic Notes And Queries.

Louisiana . Indeed , we know of instances in which , so late as 1844 , it expelled members of the Grand Lodge , and required that body to simply declare the brother expelled merely unreason of his expulsion by this Supreme Council . All this went well , so long as the members of this Supreme Council hacl control of the Grand Lodge , and this they had contrived to possess by the various complicated provisions of the Regulations of 1832 , before alluded to . The tyrannical ancl umnasouic exercise of

power by these rnlers , was the chief , if not the sole cause of revolt in 1847 , and the formation of the Louisiana Grand Lodge , through the intervention of the Grand Lodge of Mississippi . The result we have above intimated in tbe adoption of the constitution of 1850 . It was then that this Supreme Council began to exercise its more than doubtful powers , by the chartering of Lodges and other similar acts of jurisdiction , in conflict with that of the Grand Lodge .

"But , fortunately for us , perhaps , it was discovered that this Supreme Council was illegal and spurious , and had been organized within the immediate jurisdiction of another Supreme Council ( that for the southern jurisdiction ofthe United States , sitting at Charleston , South Carolina ) . This discovery led to the immediate dissolution of the body , aud the union , in 1 S 54 , of its members , ancl all its subordinates , with a Grand Consistory , which had been already legally organized in the State , by the Supreme Council at Charleston . By this proceeding , all the lodges under its control fell tothe ground , ancl subsequently returned to the Grand Lodge ; and thus were all divisions

supposed to be healed . The Supreme Council at Charleston renounced all claim to jurisdiction over the three Symbolic Degrees ; the present Grand Consistory of Louisiana does not dream of any such claim ; and there should be nothing , apparently , to disturb our harmony and quiet . " There were a few disaffected ones , however , who never came back to the Grand Lodge . These claimed to be 33 rds , and , as such , to possess the right to make Masons at sight , and . to

constitute Lodges of the three Symbolic Degrees . They , in defiance of their obligations as 33 rds , if they really are such , next proceeded to form a ¦ " Supreme Council for the Sovereign ancl Independent State of Louisiana , " and have made Masons ( of course clandestine ) , and chartered several lodges ancl higher bodies ( also clandestine ) , of the exact number of which we are ignorant . It is with this body we have to contend , ancl this only . It is this so-called Supreme Council , ivhich neither the

Grancl Orient of France , nor any other Masonic body whatever , has recognised ; and we think ourselves safe in saying , that no body of regular Masons will ever recognise it . Yet , through the ignorance as to the difference—or rather the want of difference—between the several Rites , and the prejudices growing out of race , and made permanent , as it were , by ignorance , a portion of several of our lodges have withdrawn from us , and taken charters from this spurious ancl so-called Supreme Council .

And here we feel the result of admitting ignorant men into our Order—more fully portrayed in another place—and the necessity of a correct knowledge of the true principles of Freemasonry being instilled into the mind of every initiate . "

Notes On Literature, Science, And Art.

NOTES ON LITERATURE , SCIENCE , AND ART .

The first volume of Mr . Elwin ' s edition of the Life , Letters , and Worlcs of Pope is in the press , ancl will , we hear , comprise many facts of high interest never ascertained befoi'e . The Golden Precepts of Prince Albert , selected from his speeches , and printed on toned paper , will he published immediately .

Dr . Goodwin , Dean , of Ely , has a fifth series of Parish Sermons nearly ready . What fabulous numbers , gossips the Literary Gazette , have not been mentioned at dinner-tables and other places conducive to an excess of good nature , as representing the total circulation of tlie admirably conducted ComHll Mcw / craiie—200 , 000 ,

150 , 000 , 100 , 000 , and so on . A hard-working news-agent and magazine dealer , who knows to a nicety what the members of his trade use , and the numbers turned out by the bookbindersivhich body , by the way , cannot very well be ignorant of the quantities that pass through their hands—forwards the follow-

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 4
  • You're on page5
  • 6
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy