Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Masonic Observer
  • Sept. 20, 1858
  • Page 6
Current:

The Masonic Observer, Sept. 20, 1858: Page 6

  • Back to The Masonic Observer, Sept. 20, 1858
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article Untitled ← Page 2 of 2
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 2 →
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ar00600

which it governs . Believing as we do that such a condition of things is pregnant with ill , we shall feel it our duty constantly to protest against its continuance . Heedless of what is said as to " ulterior designs , " we announce our main object to be to secure practical efficiency to our councils and administration ; and our remonstrances will continue to be urged , no matter how unpalatable they may prove to those in high places .

Ar00601

THE art of cooking has not died with poor Mr . Alexis Soyer . The culinary mantle has descended in all its magic might to the purveyors of the authorized minutes of Grand Lodge proceedings ; and we invite those Brethren who assisted at the last meetings to give its due meed of praise to the talent which so admirably

evinces its capability to cook a report . With the " Salaries Debate" fresh in our recollection , we are amazed at the audacity of the studied mutilation which seeks to convey to those absent on that night an erroneous impression of what actually occurred . Not intending to recapitulate all the pros and cons of

that debate , we should fail in our dut y did we not call attention to its most notorious incident , respecting which the crisp blue pages before us are ominously but disgracefully silent . The Board of General Purposes in June last with the G . REGISTRAR , as its President had formed a decided opinionand embodied in then- report a strong

, recommendation , that no increase should be made in any of the salaries in the Grand Secretary ' s department . Such opinion they might have every right to arrive at , nor would we ascribe to them any motive but that of a disinterested economy . Be that as it may , from the

effect of this sweeping clause it was the wish of many ( whom a subsequent division has shown to be a considerable majority ) to except Bro . PARNFIELD , whose long and able sendees appeared to them worthy of some recognition ; and Bro . BEADON ( no authority of yesterday on points of order ) placed himself in the van as their spokesman .

But a debate ensued as to the precise time when an increase to Bro . FARNFJELD ' salary might in order be moved ; and it was ruled , after several contradictory opinions , that it might come on as an amendment on the motion for the adoption of the report . Now it would be imagined by those unacquanted with the di plomacy

of our officials , that such adoption would have been moved as a matter of course b y the President of the Board . So straightforward a procedure is scorned by those who habitually sacrifice public convenience to the tactics of party manceuvre . One by one Bro . ROXBURGH moved the adoption of the more uninteresting hs

paragrap of the report , while he refused to brethren who had come up from all parts of the country to support Bro . BEADON , an opportunity of recording their opinion on the subject of the salaries .

So far then , matters were at a dead-lock . The wellwishers to Bro . FARNFIELD were insulted and snubbed and hushed , while the G . REGISTRAR beamed triumphant in a halo of self-stultification , having succeeded in forming a resolution , which he had not courage to suggest that G . L . should adopt . And by this blaze of triumph the Editor of the authorized minutes seems to

have been so dazzled that he saw no further . He has indeed a confused notion that " several Brethren took part in the discussion , " but he notices not that Bro . GREEN , to rescue G . L . from the slough of absurdity in which they were prostrate , asked a simple and pertinent questionviz : whether it be not " competent for any

, member of G . L . to move the adoption of any portion of the report ? " He tramples into oblivion the dictum of the M . W . G . M . who replied that it was competent . He thinks it unworthy of mention that by Bros . GREEN and PORTAL accordingly such motion was made

and seconded , and that the G . REGISTRAR declined , to submit himself to the ruling of the M . W . G . M . How Bro . STEBBING told that Brother that he had failed to do his duty , and denounced , amid the cheers of the hall , the whisper along the D ais which whispered away the privileges of the Craft ; iiow he protested against

such tyranny over the country members ; all this is a matter of record , but we seek it in vain in the authorized minutes . Who is responsible for that publication ? Why are the most important portions of debate suppressed ? Here we join issue with that Editor . We accuse him of wilfully suppressing what he feels to be damaging to the powers that be . Let the Craft at large

give judgment between us and this ministerial brochure , and decide how far a mirror of our proceedings is trustworthy , which either distorts the images it jwofesses to reflect , or glosses over the deformities which disgrace our Masonic rule . Not that it is hard to trace the point and intention of

this emasculated system of reporting . That shews itself pretty plainly in the prodigality of type accorded to the reply upon Bro . STEBBING delivered after mature consideration in the Especial G . L . Fourteen days after utterance of the accusation ( which accusation strikes too home on somebody to find a place in the publication

before us ) the reply of the M . W . G . M . is prominently paraded ; but this rather sets one fancying what position a journal would hold , which , professing to report an important trial , should slur over the opening day ' s proceedings , and begin with the exordium of the counsel for the defence .

However having arrived at facility of suppression we may expect our Editor shortly to aspire to interpolation and invention . Familiarity with the scissors will breed contempt for simple dull fact . It will be but one more step in the art of Ooolcing . Let us have a spice of romance infused into the mess ; already the menial trammels of reporting are spurned , and opinions are introduced and interwoven with recital . Communications from brethren of note in Canada are stigmatized as irrelevant , ( Page 6 of this

“The Masonic Observer: 1858-09-20, Page 6” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 24 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mob/issues/mob_20091858/page/6/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 2
Untitled Article 3
Untitled Article 4
Untitled Article 5
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Article 7
GRAND LODGE. Article 7
The Colonies. Article 10
Untitled Article 11
Untitled Article 11
Untitled Article 14
UNION IN NEW YORK. Article 14
NEW BRUNSWICK. Article 14
NEW ZEALAND. Article 15
AUSTRALIA.-VICTORIA. Article 15
Mark Masonry. Article 16
Masonic Charities. Article 17
The Provinces. Article 19
Untitled Article 22
Correspondence. Article 23
Untitled Article 24
Untitled Article 24
Untitled Ad 24
Untitled Ad 24
Untitled Ad 24
Untitled Ad 24
Untitled Article 24
Untitled Article 24
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

4 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

3 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

2 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

2 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

2 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

1 Article
Page 21

Page 21

1 Article
Page 22

Page 22

2 Articles
Page 23

Page 23

1 Article
Page 24

Page 24

9 Articles
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ar00600

which it governs . Believing as we do that such a condition of things is pregnant with ill , we shall feel it our duty constantly to protest against its continuance . Heedless of what is said as to " ulterior designs , " we announce our main object to be to secure practical efficiency to our councils and administration ; and our remonstrances will continue to be urged , no matter how unpalatable they may prove to those in high places .

Ar00601

THE art of cooking has not died with poor Mr . Alexis Soyer . The culinary mantle has descended in all its magic might to the purveyors of the authorized minutes of Grand Lodge proceedings ; and we invite those Brethren who assisted at the last meetings to give its due meed of praise to the talent which so admirably

evinces its capability to cook a report . With the " Salaries Debate" fresh in our recollection , we are amazed at the audacity of the studied mutilation which seeks to convey to those absent on that night an erroneous impression of what actually occurred . Not intending to recapitulate all the pros and cons of

that debate , we should fail in our dut y did we not call attention to its most notorious incident , respecting which the crisp blue pages before us are ominously but disgracefully silent . The Board of General Purposes in June last with the G . REGISTRAR , as its President had formed a decided opinionand embodied in then- report a strong

, recommendation , that no increase should be made in any of the salaries in the Grand Secretary ' s department . Such opinion they might have every right to arrive at , nor would we ascribe to them any motive but that of a disinterested economy . Be that as it may , from the

effect of this sweeping clause it was the wish of many ( whom a subsequent division has shown to be a considerable majority ) to except Bro . PARNFIELD , whose long and able sendees appeared to them worthy of some recognition ; and Bro . BEADON ( no authority of yesterday on points of order ) placed himself in the van as their spokesman .

But a debate ensued as to the precise time when an increase to Bro . FARNFJELD ' salary might in order be moved ; and it was ruled , after several contradictory opinions , that it might come on as an amendment on the motion for the adoption of the report . Now it would be imagined by those unacquanted with the di plomacy

of our officials , that such adoption would have been moved as a matter of course b y the President of the Board . So straightforward a procedure is scorned by those who habitually sacrifice public convenience to the tactics of party manceuvre . One by one Bro . ROXBURGH moved the adoption of the more uninteresting hs

paragrap of the report , while he refused to brethren who had come up from all parts of the country to support Bro . BEADON , an opportunity of recording their opinion on the subject of the salaries .

So far then , matters were at a dead-lock . The wellwishers to Bro . FARNFIELD were insulted and snubbed and hushed , while the G . REGISTRAR beamed triumphant in a halo of self-stultification , having succeeded in forming a resolution , which he had not courage to suggest that G . L . should adopt . And by this blaze of triumph the Editor of the authorized minutes seems to

have been so dazzled that he saw no further . He has indeed a confused notion that " several Brethren took part in the discussion , " but he notices not that Bro . GREEN , to rescue G . L . from the slough of absurdity in which they were prostrate , asked a simple and pertinent questionviz : whether it be not " competent for any

, member of G . L . to move the adoption of any portion of the report ? " He tramples into oblivion the dictum of the M . W . G . M . who replied that it was competent . He thinks it unworthy of mention that by Bros . GREEN and PORTAL accordingly such motion was made

and seconded , and that the G . REGISTRAR declined , to submit himself to the ruling of the M . W . G . M . How Bro . STEBBING told that Brother that he had failed to do his duty , and denounced , amid the cheers of the hall , the whisper along the D ais which whispered away the privileges of the Craft ; iiow he protested against

such tyranny over the country members ; all this is a matter of record , but we seek it in vain in the authorized minutes . Who is responsible for that publication ? Why are the most important portions of debate suppressed ? Here we join issue with that Editor . We accuse him of wilfully suppressing what he feels to be damaging to the powers that be . Let the Craft at large

give judgment between us and this ministerial brochure , and decide how far a mirror of our proceedings is trustworthy , which either distorts the images it jwofesses to reflect , or glosses over the deformities which disgrace our Masonic rule . Not that it is hard to trace the point and intention of

this emasculated system of reporting . That shews itself pretty plainly in the prodigality of type accorded to the reply upon Bro . STEBBING delivered after mature consideration in the Especial G . L . Fourteen days after utterance of the accusation ( which accusation strikes too home on somebody to find a place in the publication

before us ) the reply of the M . W . G . M . is prominently paraded ; but this rather sets one fancying what position a journal would hold , which , professing to report an important trial , should slur over the opening day ' s proceedings , and begin with the exordium of the counsel for the defence .

However having arrived at facility of suppression we may expect our Editor shortly to aspire to interpolation and invention . Familiarity with the scissors will breed contempt for simple dull fact . It will be but one more step in the art of Ooolcing . Let us have a spice of romance infused into the mess ; already the menial trammels of reporting are spurned , and opinions are introduced and interwoven with recital . Communications from brethren of note in Canada are stigmatized as irrelevant , ( Page 6 of this

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 5
  • You're on page6
  • 7
  • 24
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy