Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Masonic Observer
  • June 20, 1858
  • Page 5
  • Ar00502
Current:

The Masonic Observer, June 20, 1858: Page 5

  • Back to The Masonic Observer, June 20, 1858
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ar00502

IF there , is one subject more than another about which persons now-a-days seem to have somewhat taken leave of their senses , it is the subject of education , Daring psychologists might with reason divide mankind at the present time into one of the two classes of teacher and teachee , lecturer and lecturee , examiner or examinee , We are not going to assert that education is a bad thing

per se ; but we do not , at the same time , shrink from saying , that We entertain great and grave doubts , not unmingled with apprehension , with respect to the results to be expected from the present rage for what is styled education . All history shows us that an unnatural strain in one direction ever produces , as a

consequence ) an equally unnatural strain in the other . The austere and stern rule of the Puritans bore fruit in the shape of present hypocrisy and wild licentiousness after the Restoration , The proselytising energy of the second James led to his own expulsion from his throne , and the establishment of the reformed part of the Catholic

Church more firmly than ever in this country . What if the present education mania produces nothing but a superficial smattering now , " with the promise of the legacy of a permanent lowering of the intellectual power

of the nation in the next generation ? There was an old gentleman who lived rather more than two thousand j'ears ago in an out of the way corner of Europe—for quoting whom , we suppose we owe some apology , as he labored under the double misfortune of having played his part so very much in the world ' s infancy , and of having written in Greek ; and now-a-days ( so

great is our desire for education !) historical memory , much like legal memory , does not go farther back than the middle ages , and the study-Of Greek and Latin authors is looked upon as a harmless folly—well , this old gentleman , who , although he lived two thousand years ago , and was not an Englishman , still was a man of some little sense ,

in conversing with his friend Theaetetus , assumed that he agreed to the truth of the axiom , that "it was surely better to get through a little well , than a great deal insufficiently . " At present , along with the ancients themselves , we seem to have done away with all their wisdom ; and Sociates' maxim has been replaced b

y another , equally brief , but far more questionable as to its working;— " It is better to know a little of everything , than a great deal of one particular subject . " This is the principle on which we decry the training of the old Universities in order to extol that of their London

rival . This is the principle on which we , in short , teach everybody everything . This is the principle on which it is proposed to . enlarge the education of the girls in our Royal Freemasons' School for Female children , by the addition of Music and French . In the case before us , indeed , we are disposed to think from what is disclosed in the reportthat perhapsif the princile of strict

, , p selection be rigidly adhered to , no great harm may accrue , but on the contrary , good . It would be absurd in the extreme to think of giving accomplishments to those whose vocation in life is to be that of domestic servants , of which class seven are mentioned in the report out of fifty-two . It may be

questionable again , what would be the effect of giving them , or , at all events , Music to needlewomen , milliners , shop-assistants , and dress-makers , of whom twelve are mentioned out of the same total of fifty-two . It is not unreasonable , and indeed may be advisable , to give these accomplishments to those pupils "the position in life of whose parents is or has been such as to warrant the expectation

that a proficiency in them will prove a benefit to them . " If judicious care and strictness of selection be rigidly adhered to—and it might possibly be desirable to make music dependent on a slight extra payment by the pupil —if those pupils and those only whose abilities seem such as to justify the . expectation that they will succeed in

life as governesses , companions , and teachers , be permitted to participate in the advantages now proposed to be added to the work of the school , no great harm will be done . On the contrary , good may be expected to result from the innovation . But if this spirit of selection is neglected or relaxed , let the committee see to it , lest , in

over-educating the daughters of our Brethren for their due position in life , they render them discontented and unhappy , and drive them to seek other and more questionable modes of livelihood , than those for which nature had better qualified them , and for which they should have been educated ..

Ar00501

THE EXECUTIVE have experienced two signal defeats , upon two questions both of which compromised their position as the supposed leaders of G . L ., within the last fortni ght . And if the present system of backstairs influence is adhered to , they may . expect several more in the course of the next year .

Any one who noticed the feeling of G . L . on Wednesday last ; the cheers with which every allusion to the subject was received ; the childish ebullition of temper exhibited by Bro . HAVERS , in his impertinent observation to Bro . PORTAL upon the question of the provincial returns ; must have seen that the vote upon Bro . FARNEIELB '

salary was as much a vote of want of confidence in the G . M . ' s advisers , as it was one expressive of satisfaction with the services of a faithful Officer of the Craft ; and that it was so felt by the Brethren in question . The secret and sinister influence exercised oyer the G . M . by irresponsible men , who hold in their hands the

whole power of the Throne ; the tricks and dodges resorted to by the Executive to prevent a fair issue boing arrived at upon any ( to them ) disagreeable question ; the entire want of sympathy between the rulers of the Craft in London , and the great mass of intelligent and independent Masons throughout the Country all these

; points , as they influenced the vote arrived at upon Wednesday , so are they the causes of a widely spreading dissatisfaction , upon the result of which no thoughtful person can look without anxiety .

Ar00500

CAPE OF GOOD HOPE . —The foundation stone of a library and museum was laid in the government gardens , Cape Town , on the 23 rd March , by his Excellency , Sir George Grey , assisted by the various Masonic bodies in the towiu ^

“The Masonic Observer: 1858-06-20, Page 5” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 24 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mob/issues/mob_20061858/page/5/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 2
Untitled Article 2
Untitled Article 3
Untitled Article 4
Untitled Article 5
Untitled Article 5
Untitled Article 5
GRAND LODGE. Article 6
GRAND LODGE OF EMERGENCY. Article 10
Untitled Article 11
Colonial. Article 12
PROPOSED ARTICLES OF UNION BETWEEN THE GRAND LODGES ' OF CANADA. Article 15
Masonic Charities. Article 16
BOYS' SCHOOL. Article 19
FREEMASONS' BENEVOLENT INSTITUTION. Article 19
MALE ANNUITANTS. Article 19
STATEMENT OF RECEIPTS FROM LODGES, AND SALARIES PAID FROM THE YEAR 1839 TO 1857, BOTH INCLUSIVE. Article 19
Untitled Article 19
Correspondence. Article 20
The Provinces. Article 20
Untitled Article 20
Untitled Ad 20
Untitled Ad 20
Untitled Ad 20
Untitled Article 20
Untitled Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

2 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

2 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

6 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

8 Articles
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ar00502

IF there , is one subject more than another about which persons now-a-days seem to have somewhat taken leave of their senses , it is the subject of education , Daring psychologists might with reason divide mankind at the present time into one of the two classes of teacher and teachee , lecturer and lecturee , examiner or examinee , We are not going to assert that education is a bad thing

per se ; but we do not , at the same time , shrink from saying , that We entertain great and grave doubts , not unmingled with apprehension , with respect to the results to be expected from the present rage for what is styled education . All history shows us that an unnatural strain in one direction ever produces , as a

consequence ) an equally unnatural strain in the other . The austere and stern rule of the Puritans bore fruit in the shape of present hypocrisy and wild licentiousness after the Restoration , The proselytising energy of the second James led to his own expulsion from his throne , and the establishment of the reformed part of the Catholic

Church more firmly than ever in this country . What if the present education mania produces nothing but a superficial smattering now , " with the promise of the legacy of a permanent lowering of the intellectual power

of the nation in the next generation ? There was an old gentleman who lived rather more than two thousand j'ears ago in an out of the way corner of Europe—for quoting whom , we suppose we owe some apology , as he labored under the double misfortune of having played his part so very much in the world ' s infancy , and of having written in Greek ; and now-a-days ( so

great is our desire for education !) historical memory , much like legal memory , does not go farther back than the middle ages , and the study-Of Greek and Latin authors is looked upon as a harmless folly—well , this old gentleman , who , although he lived two thousand years ago , and was not an Englishman , still was a man of some little sense ,

in conversing with his friend Theaetetus , assumed that he agreed to the truth of the axiom , that "it was surely better to get through a little well , than a great deal insufficiently . " At present , along with the ancients themselves , we seem to have done away with all their wisdom ; and Sociates' maxim has been replaced b

y another , equally brief , but far more questionable as to its working;— " It is better to know a little of everything , than a great deal of one particular subject . " This is the principle on which we decry the training of the old Universities in order to extol that of their London

rival . This is the principle on which we , in short , teach everybody everything . This is the principle on which it is proposed to . enlarge the education of the girls in our Royal Freemasons' School for Female children , by the addition of Music and French . In the case before us , indeed , we are disposed to think from what is disclosed in the reportthat perhapsif the princile of strict

, , p selection be rigidly adhered to , no great harm may accrue , but on the contrary , good . It would be absurd in the extreme to think of giving accomplishments to those whose vocation in life is to be that of domestic servants , of which class seven are mentioned in the report out of fifty-two . It may be

questionable again , what would be the effect of giving them , or , at all events , Music to needlewomen , milliners , shop-assistants , and dress-makers , of whom twelve are mentioned out of the same total of fifty-two . It is not unreasonable , and indeed may be advisable , to give these accomplishments to those pupils "the position in life of whose parents is or has been such as to warrant the expectation

that a proficiency in them will prove a benefit to them . " If judicious care and strictness of selection be rigidly adhered to—and it might possibly be desirable to make music dependent on a slight extra payment by the pupil —if those pupils and those only whose abilities seem such as to justify the . expectation that they will succeed in

life as governesses , companions , and teachers , be permitted to participate in the advantages now proposed to be added to the work of the school , no great harm will be done . On the contrary , good may be expected to result from the innovation . But if this spirit of selection is neglected or relaxed , let the committee see to it , lest , in

over-educating the daughters of our Brethren for their due position in life , they render them discontented and unhappy , and drive them to seek other and more questionable modes of livelihood , than those for which nature had better qualified them , and for which they should have been educated ..

Ar00501

THE EXECUTIVE have experienced two signal defeats , upon two questions both of which compromised their position as the supposed leaders of G . L ., within the last fortni ght . And if the present system of backstairs influence is adhered to , they may . expect several more in the course of the next year .

Any one who noticed the feeling of G . L . on Wednesday last ; the cheers with which every allusion to the subject was received ; the childish ebullition of temper exhibited by Bro . HAVERS , in his impertinent observation to Bro . PORTAL upon the question of the provincial returns ; must have seen that the vote upon Bro . FARNEIELB '

salary was as much a vote of want of confidence in the G . M . ' s advisers , as it was one expressive of satisfaction with the services of a faithful Officer of the Craft ; and that it was so felt by the Brethren in question . The secret and sinister influence exercised oyer the G . M . by irresponsible men , who hold in their hands the

whole power of the Throne ; the tricks and dodges resorted to by the Executive to prevent a fair issue boing arrived at upon any ( to them ) disagreeable question ; the entire want of sympathy between the rulers of the Craft in London , and the great mass of intelligent and independent Masons throughout the Country all these

; points , as they influenced the vote arrived at upon Wednesday , so are they the causes of a widely spreading dissatisfaction , upon the result of which no thoughtful person can look without anxiety .

Ar00500

CAPE OF GOOD HOPE . —The foundation stone of a library and museum was laid in the government gardens , Cape Town , on the 23 rd March , by his Excellency , Sir George Grey , assisted by the various Masonic bodies in the towiu ^

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 4
  • You're on page5
  • 6
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy