Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • May 29, 1869
  • Page 9
  • CORRESPONDENCE.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, May 29, 1869: Page 9

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, May 29, 1869
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. ← Page 3 of 3
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Notes And Queries.

peris , and sklaiteris to proceid togidder befoir thame , under ane baner and pegane , separat fra the saids smythtis , and producit ane stotitut maid threupon , of the dayt the xiij day Junii , the yeir of G-od m v" xxxiij yen ' s : And the baillies decernit and ordaint the last statitut to be observyt ancl keiitunder the

p , panes contenit in the same , becaus thai all wer present , and consentit therto , and ohlist thame to obserf the same , becaus that all wer present , and consentit therto , and oblist thame to obserf the same , as the said statitut proportis at lyntht : And the saidis wryehtis , masoniscowperisand sldayteris protestit

, , that quhat the baillies dois or decernis this day , anent the ordor forsaid , mak na dirogacioune to the forsaid statitut first maid , producit be thame in judgement , hot that thai may haf thair aid prevelege observit , and for remeid of law , quhen tyme and place requiris ; and Alexander Kemptdek . of the

, yne baxieris , allegit inlykwyiss , that thai ar put by thair rowme and ordour vsit obefor , and protestit sicklyk , that quhat be done this yeir be the baillies , anent the said ardor , hurt thame nocht in tvm cumyn . " *—W . P . B .

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

The ' Editor is not responsible for the opinions expressed hy Correspondents

BEO . MELVILLE'S DISCOYEBIES .

10 THE EDITOK OS THE ' * EJIEEirASOJJS' ATAGAZEJE AND MASONIC JtlKItOK . Dear Sir and Brother , —The readers of "Martin Chuzzlewit" will remember Charles Slyme , Esquire , and his iriend , Mr . Montague Tigg . Tlie former used to talk mysteriously while his friend Tigg kept expatiating upon the wondrous genius of the great

Slyme . Bro . Melville and Bro . Crawford appear to he anxious to emulate Slyme and Tigg . Bro . Melville writes in " mystic characters , " while Bro . Crawford plays his fiddle to the tune of " See the Conquering Hero Comes . " i \ ow , Mr . Editor , I am one of the " Priestly Masons " whom Bro . Melville keeps

denouncing , and I want to know what I have done to merit such abuse . Since I was " admitted to the light , " I have quietly sought to do my duty , and I have been something of a working Craftsman ; now , however , I find myself condemned because I cannot pretend , with the ordinary common sense with which

nature bas endowed me , to understand Bro . Melville ' s boasted "discoveries . " I have consulted several eminent brethren , and they tell me that , in their opinion , Bro . M . is writing "bosh . " I am also decidedly averse to being called a M-ir / a-Mason , being constitutionally unfitted for the frigid zone .

he goes on , tramp , tramp , all the day , and when even comes he only reaches the point from whence he began—no progress , but a simple trudge , trudge , in the same everlasting circle . As an extant instance in point , I might refer to a certain writer who , as I perceive by an American Masonic magazine , is still hammering away in the guid auld style and using the " Grand General Masonic Assembl" held at York in 926 as an anvil !

y * At p ; ige 320 of the Magazine for October 26 th , 1867 , Bro . Hughan refers to the Aberdeen Lodge , and , inter alia , says it is " referred to in the Council Register from the beginning of the 16 th century ; " but , as the extract at page 308 shows " the masownys of the luge" are alluded to even in the loth century .

I have always looked upon Ereemasonry as St . John ' s epistle to the world , " Love one another ; ' * and I really cannot give up this idea—the noblest that has ever fired the enthusiasm of mankind , ic . order to fall down and worship Bro . Melville ' s mysti cism , which seems most likely to secure popularity

among inmates of those national institutions which are visited hy Her Majesty ' s Lunacy Commissioners . Tours fraternally , CHEISTOPHEE J . CAELETOX Dublin , May 16 th , 1869 .

TO THE EDITOK OE THE EEEEJIASOHS' HAGAZIXE AITD 3 rASOi"IC HIKItOB Dear Sir and Brother , —I read with much pleasure in your impression of the 8 th inst ., the communications of "Ees non Verba , " "P . M ., " and others ., respecting Bro . Melville ' s papers . It is quite gratifying to see that the Craft will not consent to

accept the teachings of one who seems especially ignorant of the very foundation on which he ( by means of his fertile and extremely pliable imagina tion ) bases the theories of his arguments in last week ' s paper—I mean the Hebrew . The few words that ho has presumed to use ( pp . 362 & 365 ) are so full of

errors , both in spelling and rendering , that anyone with the most superficial knowledge of the language must at once detect Bro . Melville ' s ignorance on tho subject . The foundation so shaky , what hopes ear . we have of the structure ?

Let me humbly advise all modern Masons to rest satisfied with modern Masonry ; if they only act up to its principles , they will become quite as happy and as well informed in respect to Masonic secrets ; . ; though they were to study and believe in Bro . Melville and his mysteries . Tours fraternally , W . M . 254 .

[ We beg to refer our correspondent to errata ai the bottom of col . 2 , p . 384 . —ED . E . M . ] TO ITS ? . EEITOE OP THE EEEEtfASO ^' s' MAGAZINE A : n > MASONIC IiriCEO .- ' Dear Sir and Brother , —At last I have a tangibh opponent in the person of Bro . W . P . Bucban . i

regret to say he is not over courteous in his language and he writes as though I had personally offended him . Strange , he should be so angry as to consider it necessary " to touch me up a lit . " What an elegau i expression ! " Bro . Buehan says I have a silly custom —a pretended anxiety lest I should unwittingly

disclose any sacred or important "point ; " and , as n Mason , he begs to express his disgust at this preteu tion , as ho considers it a poor , transparent , and unmanly attempt at imposition . Oh ! When I was a i < Entering Apprentice , I was taught to be cautious and solemnly pledged not to divulge any point < - ¦•

points . Bro . Buehan , no doubt , did the same . T' - use an elegant word—hosli . Bro . Buehan , the poini are beyond the scope of ordinary Masons , and , Bro , Buehan , you cannot divulge the Masonic point ; : because you never had them entrusted to you ! > admit I am a " cloudy moon" shining upon coal . What a lovely allegory ! And , as Bro . Buehan say .-I have not heat enough to get up a " temporary bit ot a sparkle . " True , oh ! brother ; cloudy moon as

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1869-05-29, Page 9” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 15 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_29051869/page/9/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
BROTHER CLABON'S PROPOSED ALTERATIONS IN THE BOOK OF CONSTITUTIONS AFFECTING THE FUND OF BENEVOLENCE. Article 1
FREEMASONRY IN PORTUGAL. Article 5
KNIGHTS OF THE BATH. Article 6
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 7
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 9
PRACTICAL MASONIC CHARITY. Article 10
BRO. DNALXO'S ARTICLE "FREEMASONRY AND CHRISTIANITY." Article 11
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 11
METROPOLITAN. Article 11
PROVINCIAL. Article 13
IRELAND. Article 19
MASONIC LIFEBOAT FUND. Article 19
Poetry. Article 19
LIST OF LODGE, &c., MEETINGS FOR WEEK ENDING 5TH JUNE, 1869. Article 20
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

3 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

4 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

4 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

2 Articles
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Notes And Queries.

peris , and sklaiteris to proceid togidder befoir thame , under ane baner and pegane , separat fra the saids smythtis , and producit ane stotitut maid threupon , of the dayt the xiij day Junii , the yeir of G-od m v" xxxiij yen ' s : And the baillies decernit and ordaint the last statitut to be observyt ancl keiitunder the

p , panes contenit in the same , becaus thai all wer present , and consentit therto , and ohlist thame to obserf the same , becaus that all wer present , and consentit therto , and oblist thame to obserf the same , as the said statitut proportis at lyntht : And the saidis wryehtis , masoniscowperisand sldayteris protestit

, , that quhat the baillies dois or decernis this day , anent the ordor forsaid , mak na dirogacioune to the forsaid statitut first maid , producit be thame in judgement , hot that thai may haf thair aid prevelege observit , and for remeid of law , quhen tyme and place requiris ; and Alexander Kemptdek . of the

, yne baxieris , allegit inlykwyiss , that thai ar put by thair rowme and ordour vsit obefor , and protestit sicklyk , that quhat be done this yeir be the baillies , anent the said ardor , hurt thame nocht in tvm cumyn . " *—W . P . B .

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

The ' Editor is not responsible for the opinions expressed hy Correspondents

BEO . MELVILLE'S DISCOYEBIES .

10 THE EDITOK OS THE ' * EJIEEirASOJJS' ATAGAZEJE AND MASONIC JtlKItOK . Dear Sir and Brother , —The readers of "Martin Chuzzlewit" will remember Charles Slyme , Esquire , and his iriend , Mr . Montague Tigg . Tlie former used to talk mysteriously while his friend Tigg kept expatiating upon the wondrous genius of the great

Slyme . Bro . Melville and Bro . Crawford appear to he anxious to emulate Slyme and Tigg . Bro . Melville writes in " mystic characters , " while Bro . Crawford plays his fiddle to the tune of " See the Conquering Hero Comes . " i \ ow , Mr . Editor , I am one of the " Priestly Masons " whom Bro . Melville keeps

denouncing , and I want to know what I have done to merit such abuse . Since I was " admitted to the light , " I have quietly sought to do my duty , and I have been something of a working Craftsman ; now , however , I find myself condemned because I cannot pretend , with the ordinary common sense with which

nature bas endowed me , to understand Bro . Melville ' s boasted "discoveries . " I have consulted several eminent brethren , and they tell me that , in their opinion , Bro . M . is writing "bosh . " I am also decidedly averse to being called a M-ir / a-Mason , being constitutionally unfitted for the frigid zone .

he goes on , tramp , tramp , all the day , and when even comes he only reaches the point from whence he began—no progress , but a simple trudge , trudge , in the same everlasting circle . As an extant instance in point , I might refer to a certain writer who , as I perceive by an American Masonic magazine , is still hammering away in the guid auld style and using the " Grand General Masonic Assembl" held at York in 926 as an anvil !

y * At p ; ige 320 of the Magazine for October 26 th , 1867 , Bro . Hughan refers to the Aberdeen Lodge , and , inter alia , says it is " referred to in the Council Register from the beginning of the 16 th century ; " but , as the extract at page 308 shows " the masownys of the luge" are alluded to even in the loth century .

I have always looked upon Ereemasonry as St . John ' s epistle to the world , " Love one another ; ' * and I really cannot give up this idea—the noblest that has ever fired the enthusiasm of mankind , ic . order to fall down and worship Bro . Melville ' s mysti cism , which seems most likely to secure popularity

among inmates of those national institutions which are visited hy Her Majesty ' s Lunacy Commissioners . Tours fraternally , CHEISTOPHEE J . CAELETOX Dublin , May 16 th , 1869 .

TO THE EDITOK OE THE EEEEJIASOHS' HAGAZIXE AITD 3 rASOi"IC HIKItOB Dear Sir and Brother , —I read with much pleasure in your impression of the 8 th inst ., the communications of "Ees non Verba , " "P . M ., " and others ., respecting Bro . Melville ' s papers . It is quite gratifying to see that the Craft will not consent to

accept the teachings of one who seems especially ignorant of the very foundation on which he ( by means of his fertile and extremely pliable imagina tion ) bases the theories of his arguments in last week ' s paper—I mean the Hebrew . The few words that ho has presumed to use ( pp . 362 & 365 ) are so full of

errors , both in spelling and rendering , that anyone with the most superficial knowledge of the language must at once detect Bro . Melville ' s ignorance on tho subject . The foundation so shaky , what hopes ear . we have of the structure ?

Let me humbly advise all modern Masons to rest satisfied with modern Masonry ; if they only act up to its principles , they will become quite as happy and as well informed in respect to Masonic secrets ; . ; though they were to study and believe in Bro . Melville and his mysteries . Tours fraternally , W . M . 254 .

[ We beg to refer our correspondent to errata ai the bottom of col . 2 , p . 384 . —ED . E . M . ] TO ITS ? . EEITOE OP THE EEEEtfASO ^' s' MAGAZINE A : n > MASONIC IiriCEO .- ' Dear Sir and Brother , —At last I have a tangibh opponent in the person of Bro . W . P . Bucban . i

regret to say he is not over courteous in his language and he writes as though I had personally offended him . Strange , he should be so angry as to consider it necessary " to touch me up a lit . " What an elegau i expression ! " Bro . Buehan says I have a silly custom —a pretended anxiety lest I should unwittingly

disclose any sacred or important "point ; " and , as n Mason , he begs to express his disgust at this preteu tion , as ho considers it a poor , transparent , and unmanly attempt at imposition . Oh ! When I was a i < Entering Apprentice , I was taught to be cautious and solemnly pledged not to divulge any point < - ¦•

points . Bro . Buehan , no doubt , did the same . T' - use an elegant word—hosli . Bro . Buehan , the poini are beyond the scope of ordinary Masons , and , Bro , Buehan , you cannot divulge the Masonic point ; : because you never had them entrusted to you ! > admit I am a " cloudy moon" shining upon coal . What a lovely allegory ! And , as Bro . Buehan say .-I have not heat enough to get up a " temporary bit ot a sparkle . " True , oh ! brother ; cloudy moon as

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 8
  • You're on page9
  • 10
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy