Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Feb. 25, 1860
  • Page 11
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Feb. 25, 1860: Page 11

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Feb. 25, 1860
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article Literature. ← Page 4 of 5 →
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Literature.

himself , seems to have destroyed the boom which ran across the mouth of the harbour , but Lord Cochrane's design was completely effected . Thc French were so panicstruck that they ran their vessels nearly all on shore , where the ebb tide left them the next morning with their bottoms so exposed to the shot that they could easily have been rendered unfit to float . In this dilemma Lord Cochrane made signal after signal to the Admiral , ivho was fourteen miles off , that thc enemy was ashore and at his mercy , for , —

"At daylight observing seven of the nearest enemy ' s ships ashore , amongst which was the admiral's ship L'Ocean , and a group of four others lying near her in a most favourable position for attack without the possibility of returning it , at ( 5 a . m . we signalised the admiral to that effect . As the Impcrieuse at this time lay just within range of the batteries on Aix , which had commenced to fire upon us , we weighed , and stood in the direction of the fleet , letting go our anchor as soon as the ship was out of range . At 7 a . m . we signalised again , ' All the enemy's ships , except

two , are on shore ; ' this signal , as well as the former one , being merely acknowledged by the answering pennant ; but , to our surprise , no movement was visible in any part of the fleet indicating an intention to take advantage ofthe success gained . " Reflecting that , from the distance of the British , force , from the stranded enemy ' s ships—viz ., from twelve to fourteen miles , the commander-in-chief could not clearly be acquainted with their helpless condition , I directed the signal to be run up , 'The enemy ' s ships can be

destroyed ; ' this also meeting with the same cool acknowledgment of the answering pennant . " Not knowing what to make ' of such a reply , another signal was hoisted , ' Half the fleet can destroy the enemy . ' This signal was again acknowledged by the answering pennant , the whole fleet still remaining motionless as before . On this I made several telegraph signals , one of which was probably regarded as impertinent—viz ., ' The frigates alone can destroy the enemy' though it was true enoughtheir ships aground

, , being perfectly helpless , to my astonishment , the answering pennant was still the only reply vouchsafed . " Eight and nine o ' clock passed without any indication of movement on the part of the fleet , though the tide was now fast rising , so that any ships sent to the attack of the stranded vessels would have had the flood-tide to go in and the ebb to return , after having accomplished their destruction ; whilst- it was evident that if not attacked , the same floodtide would enable the French ships aground to float and escapewith

, which view some were heaving their guns and stores overboard .. On ascertaining this , I again signalised , ' The enemy is preparing- to heave off ; ' ancl entertaining no doubt that the commander-in-chief would not permit such a catastrophe , the Imperieu . se . dropped her anchor close to the Boyart Shoal , in readiness for any service that might be required . "

Lord Cochrane confident that neither forts , ships , or shoals offered any danger , still Lord Gambier would not venture ; and then in order to force the Admiral , Lord Cochrane adopted a characteristic device which hacl the effect of bringing some of the fleet to his aid , for he remembered Lord Jtulgrave's words , which he says ran in his ears , and they were , " The Admiralty is bent on destroying that fleet before it can get out to the West Indies ;" so lie resolved to put his ship in such a position that she must be either backed by others or lost ,

and"In despair , lest the ships still aground should also effect their escape , at 1 p . m . I ordered the anchor of the Impcrieuse to be hove atrip , ancl thus we drifted stern foremost towards the enemy . I say ' drifted , ' for I clid not venture to make sail , lest the movement might be seen from the flag-ship , and a signal of recall should defeat my purpose of making an attack with the Impcrieuse ; the object of this being to compel the commander-in-chief to send vessels to our assistance , in which case I knew their captains would at once attack the ships which hacl not been

allowed to heave off ancl escape . " Had this means not been resorted to , not a single enemy ' s ship would have been destroyed , for all could have hove off almost without damage , and that , to all appearance , without the slightest attempt at molestation on the part of the British fleet . It was better to risk the frigate , or even my commission , than to suffer such a disgraceful termination to the expectations of the Admiralty , after having driven ashore the enemy ' s fleet ; ancl therefore we drifted bthe wind and tide slowlpast the

y y fortifications on Isle d'Aix , about which the commander-in-chief hacl expressed so many fears in his last letter to the board ; but though they fired at us with every gun that could be brought to bear , the distance was too great to inflict damage . " Proceeding thus till 1 . 30 p . m ., and then suddenly making sail after the nearest of the enemy ' s ves-sels escaping , at 1 . 10 p . m . the signal was run up to the peak of the Impcrieuse , ' Enemy superior to chasing ship , but inferior to the fleet . ' No attention being paid to this signal , at 1 . 45

p . m . I again signalled , ' In want of assistance , ' which was true enough , being in a single frigate , close to several enemy's ships of the line . "As this signal , according to the code then in use , was coupled with the one signifying 'in distress , ' the signal officer on boarcl the flag ship thus interpreted it to the commander-in-chief , a circumstance which will require brief explanation . ' In order to divert ouv attention from the vessels we were pursuiu g these having thrown their guns overboard , the Calcutta , which ' , vas st i

aground , broadside ou , began tiring at us . Before proceeding further it became , therefore , necessary tu attack her , and at 1 ' 50 wo shortened sail and returned the lire . At 2 the lmpcricv . se . came to anchor in five fathoms , and , veering to half a cable , kept fast the spring , firing upon the Calcutta with our broadside , and at the same time upon the Agmlon . and the Yille de Varsorie ivith our forecastle and bow guns , both these ships being aground , stern on , in an opposite direction . " This proceeding—though there could be no doubt of our being jhi

want of assistance , ' seeing that our single frigate , unaided , was engaging three line-of-batt ! e ships—did not look much like being ' in distress , ' as tho signal officer of thc Caledonia had interpreted the signal ; the nature of which could not , however , have deceived the coinniaiiclcr-iu-chief , who must have witnessed the circumstances under which the signal had been made by the Impcrieuse . After engaging the Calcutta for some time , and . simultaneously firing had at th

into the sterns of the two grounded line-of-battle ships , wc leng the satisfaction of observing several ships sent to our assistance—viz ., Emerald , Unicorn , Indefatigable , Valiant . Jierr . nge , Pulluz , and Ai ' jle . On seeing this , the captain ancl crew of the Calcutta abandoned their vessel , of which the boats of the Impcrieuse took possession before the vessels sent to our ' assistance' came down . " So , with the assistance of these additional ships , the work was partially completed which might have been done effectually if

there had been corresponding energy on the part of the admiral . If Lord Cochrane ' s representation of the matter is the true one , he certainly may be excused for the warmth with which he at the time denounced , and still is indignant at , the stupidity and incapacity of his chief . The English government was anxious to make the best of it , and , according to Lord Cochrane , attempted to bribe him off for telling the truth , by the offer of an

independent squadron—to his rejection of which offer he ascribes the ruin of his prospects . Lord Gambier was acquitted by an English courtmartial . But it is to be noted that the hig hest French authorities entirely support Lord Cochrane ' s assertion that nothing but the English admiral ' s inconceivable hesitation saved a relic of the French fleet . "The French admiral was an imbecile , " said Napoleon , " and yours was as bad . " If Cochrane had been supof not onl

ported he would have taken every one the ships . He y could have destroyed them , but he mig ht and would have taken them out . " And " a more competent witness even than Napoleon , Admiral Jurieu de la Graviere , who was present at the action , after describing the " esprit de vertige" wliich had seized the whole French fleet , involving the most heroic in the common weakness , gives his judgment that "to mollesse cle Lord Gambier le courage and le sang fraid de quelques wis de uos qfficiers , preserverent seitls I'escadre Francaisc d ' une mine tolale . "

¦ NOTES ON LITERATURE , SCIENCE , At \ lJ ) ART . LOED MACATJL . VT had fixed , in his own mind , the extreme limit to which time and his vast store of materials would enable him , under favourable circumstances , to carry his history—that is , if wo are to place any reliance in the following statement of the Inverness Advertiser : — " "We have seen a letter to a gentleman from the great historian , dated Holly Lodge , 13 th October , 1 S 58 , in which he says : ' I have long given

up the hope that I shall lie able to bring the history of England down to the time of the Porteons mob . I have , therefore , no motive for investing minutely the circumstances of that affair , ancl I should not wish to engage in an inquiry which , however curious and amusing it might be , must divert me from more useful researches . '" Mr . Thomas Adolphus Trollope ( a brother of the well known novelist , and the author of " A Decade of Italian AVomen , " & e . ) has in prepara - tion a new work entitled " Tha Merchant Princes of Florence . " Jlr .

Trollope has resided in Florence for some years . ""SYe hear , " says the Publishers' Circular , "that JSo . 5 of the Cornhill Magazine will contain an article by Mr . Herman Merivale , under secretary of the colonial department , giving some curious interesting details respecting Lord Macaulay and the Junius controversy ; also an article by Rusk ' ui . Miss Adelaide Procter contributes a lyric poem ; the editor another Roundabout Paper . "

M . Alexandre Dumas has favoured the world with the commencement of a translation of "Au Autobiography of Horace , discovered by M . Dumas iu the Library of the Vatican . " The opening portions tell us all about Horace ' s boyhood , and give a graphic account of his first visit to Rome , ancl his being placed by his father under the care of the terrible pedagogue , plagosus Orbilius . The opinion of the literary world upon Mr . Dumas ' s new production may be guessed from the following extract

from one of the best written papers in Paris : — " Dumas must have exhausted all the imagination with which nature endowed him—must have run short of old books and of all kind assistants—to have resorted to such a profanation of one of the most celebrated names of antiquity , '

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1860-02-25, Page 11” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 4 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_25021860/page/11/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
CLASSICAL THEOLOGY.—VII. Article 1
CURSORY REMARKS ON FREEMASONY.-I. Article 2
MASTERPIECES OF THE ARCHITECTURE OF DIFFERENT NATIONS. Article 3
THE PRINCIPLES OF FREEMASONRY. Article 4
THE YEAR 1860. Article 5
ARCHÆOLOGY. Article 7
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 7
Literature. Article 8
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 13
WEST LANCASHIRE. Article 13
THE BLACKHEATH MEETING OF AUGUST 1858. Article 14
THE GRAND LODGE OF IRELAND. Article 14
INSPECTION OF LODGES. Article 14
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 15
METROPOLITAN. Article 15
PROVINCIAL. Article 16
ROYAL ARCH. Article 17
ANCIENT AND ACCEPTED RITE. Article 17
SCOTLAND. Article 17
GERMANY. Article 18
MASONIC FESTIVITIES. Article 19
Obituary. Article 19
THE WEEK. Article 19
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

2 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

5 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

2 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

2 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

4 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

3 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

5 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Literature.

himself , seems to have destroyed the boom which ran across the mouth of the harbour , but Lord Cochrane's design was completely effected . Thc French were so panicstruck that they ran their vessels nearly all on shore , where the ebb tide left them the next morning with their bottoms so exposed to the shot that they could easily have been rendered unfit to float . In this dilemma Lord Cochrane made signal after signal to the Admiral , ivho was fourteen miles off , that thc enemy was ashore and at his mercy , for , —

"At daylight observing seven of the nearest enemy ' s ships ashore , amongst which was the admiral's ship L'Ocean , and a group of four others lying near her in a most favourable position for attack without the possibility of returning it , at ( 5 a . m . we signalised the admiral to that effect . As the Impcrieuse at this time lay just within range of the batteries on Aix , which had commenced to fire upon us , we weighed , and stood in the direction of the fleet , letting go our anchor as soon as the ship was out of range . At 7 a . m . we signalised again , ' All the enemy's ships , except

two , are on shore ; ' this signal , as well as the former one , being merely acknowledged by the answering pennant ; but , to our surprise , no movement was visible in any part of the fleet indicating an intention to take advantage ofthe success gained . " Reflecting that , from the distance of the British , force , from the stranded enemy ' s ships—viz ., from twelve to fourteen miles , the commander-in-chief could not clearly be acquainted with their helpless condition , I directed the signal to be run up , 'The enemy ' s ships can be

destroyed ; ' this also meeting with the same cool acknowledgment of the answering pennant . " Not knowing what to make ' of such a reply , another signal was hoisted , ' Half the fleet can destroy the enemy . ' This signal was again acknowledged by the answering pennant , the whole fleet still remaining motionless as before . On this I made several telegraph signals , one of which was probably regarded as impertinent—viz ., ' The frigates alone can destroy the enemy' though it was true enoughtheir ships aground

, , being perfectly helpless , to my astonishment , the answering pennant was still the only reply vouchsafed . " Eight and nine o ' clock passed without any indication of movement on the part of the fleet , though the tide was now fast rising , so that any ships sent to the attack of the stranded vessels would have had the flood-tide to go in and the ebb to return , after having accomplished their destruction ; whilst- it was evident that if not attacked , the same floodtide would enable the French ships aground to float and escapewith

, which view some were heaving their guns and stores overboard .. On ascertaining this , I again signalised , ' The enemy is preparing- to heave off ; ' ancl entertaining no doubt that the commander-in-chief would not permit such a catastrophe , the Imperieu . se . dropped her anchor close to the Boyart Shoal , in readiness for any service that might be required . "

Lord Cochrane confident that neither forts , ships , or shoals offered any danger , still Lord Gambier would not venture ; and then in order to force the Admiral , Lord Cochrane adopted a characteristic device which hacl the effect of bringing some of the fleet to his aid , for he remembered Lord Jtulgrave's words , which he says ran in his ears , and they were , " The Admiralty is bent on destroying that fleet before it can get out to the West Indies ;" so lie resolved to put his ship in such a position that she must be either backed by others or lost ,

and"In despair , lest the ships still aground should also effect their escape , at 1 p . m . I ordered the anchor of the Impcrieuse to be hove atrip , ancl thus we drifted stern foremost towards the enemy . I say ' drifted , ' for I clid not venture to make sail , lest the movement might be seen from the flag-ship , and a signal of recall should defeat my purpose of making an attack with the Impcrieuse ; the object of this being to compel the commander-in-chief to send vessels to our assistance , in which case I knew their captains would at once attack the ships which hacl not been

allowed to heave off ancl escape . " Had this means not been resorted to , not a single enemy ' s ship would have been destroyed , for all could have hove off almost without damage , and that , to all appearance , without the slightest attempt at molestation on the part of the British fleet . It was better to risk the frigate , or even my commission , than to suffer such a disgraceful termination to the expectations of the Admiralty , after having driven ashore the enemy ' s fleet ; ancl therefore we drifted bthe wind and tide slowlpast the

y y fortifications on Isle d'Aix , about which the commander-in-chief hacl expressed so many fears in his last letter to the board ; but though they fired at us with every gun that could be brought to bear , the distance was too great to inflict damage . " Proceeding thus till 1 . 30 p . m ., and then suddenly making sail after the nearest of the enemy ' s ves-sels escaping , at 1 . 10 p . m . the signal was run up to the peak of the Impcrieuse , ' Enemy superior to chasing ship , but inferior to the fleet . ' No attention being paid to this signal , at 1 . 45

p . m . I again signalled , ' In want of assistance , ' which was true enough , being in a single frigate , close to several enemy's ships of the line . "As this signal , according to the code then in use , was coupled with the one signifying 'in distress , ' the signal officer on boarcl the flag ship thus interpreted it to the commander-in-chief , a circumstance which will require brief explanation . ' In order to divert ouv attention from the vessels we were pursuiu g these having thrown their guns overboard , the Calcutta , which ' , vas st i

aground , broadside ou , began tiring at us . Before proceeding further it became , therefore , necessary tu attack her , and at 1 ' 50 wo shortened sail and returned the lire . At 2 the lmpcricv . se . came to anchor in five fathoms , and , veering to half a cable , kept fast the spring , firing upon the Calcutta with our broadside , and at the same time upon the Agmlon . and the Yille de Varsorie ivith our forecastle and bow guns , both these ships being aground , stern on , in an opposite direction . " This proceeding—though there could be no doubt of our being jhi

want of assistance , ' seeing that our single frigate , unaided , was engaging three line-of-batt ! e ships—did not look much like being ' in distress , ' as tho signal officer of thc Caledonia had interpreted the signal ; the nature of which could not , however , have deceived the coinniaiiclcr-iu-chief , who must have witnessed the circumstances under which the signal had been made by the Impcrieuse . After engaging the Calcutta for some time , and . simultaneously firing had at th

into the sterns of the two grounded line-of-battle ships , wc leng the satisfaction of observing several ships sent to our assistance—viz ., Emerald , Unicorn , Indefatigable , Valiant . Jierr . nge , Pulluz , and Ai ' jle . On seeing this , the captain ancl crew of the Calcutta abandoned their vessel , of which the boats of the Impcrieuse took possession before the vessels sent to our ' assistance' came down . " So , with the assistance of these additional ships , the work was partially completed which might have been done effectually if

there had been corresponding energy on the part of the admiral . If Lord Cochrane ' s representation of the matter is the true one , he certainly may be excused for the warmth with which he at the time denounced , and still is indignant at , the stupidity and incapacity of his chief . The English government was anxious to make the best of it , and , according to Lord Cochrane , attempted to bribe him off for telling the truth , by the offer of an

independent squadron—to his rejection of which offer he ascribes the ruin of his prospects . Lord Gambier was acquitted by an English courtmartial . But it is to be noted that the hig hest French authorities entirely support Lord Cochrane ' s assertion that nothing but the English admiral ' s inconceivable hesitation saved a relic of the French fleet . "The French admiral was an imbecile , " said Napoleon , " and yours was as bad . " If Cochrane had been supof not onl

ported he would have taken every one the ships . He y could have destroyed them , but he mig ht and would have taken them out . " And " a more competent witness even than Napoleon , Admiral Jurieu de la Graviere , who was present at the action , after describing the " esprit de vertige" wliich had seized the whole French fleet , involving the most heroic in the common weakness , gives his judgment that "to mollesse cle Lord Gambier le courage and le sang fraid de quelques wis de uos qfficiers , preserverent seitls I'escadre Francaisc d ' une mine tolale . "

¦ NOTES ON LITERATURE , SCIENCE , At \ lJ ) ART . LOED MACATJL . VT had fixed , in his own mind , the extreme limit to which time and his vast store of materials would enable him , under favourable circumstances , to carry his history—that is , if wo are to place any reliance in the following statement of the Inverness Advertiser : — " "We have seen a letter to a gentleman from the great historian , dated Holly Lodge , 13 th October , 1 S 58 , in which he says : ' I have long given

up the hope that I shall lie able to bring the history of England down to the time of the Porteons mob . I have , therefore , no motive for investing minutely the circumstances of that affair , ancl I should not wish to engage in an inquiry which , however curious and amusing it might be , must divert me from more useful researches . '" Mr . Thomas Adolphus Trollope ( a brother of the well known novelist , and the author of " A Decade of Italian AVomen , " & e . ) has in prepara - tion a new work entitled " Tha Merchant Princes of Florence . " Jlr .

Trollope has resided in Florence for some years . ""SYe hear , " says the Publishers' Circular , "that JSo . 5 of the Cornhill Magazine will contain an article by Mr . Herman Merivale , under secretary of the colonial department , giving some curious interesting details respecting Lord Macaulay and the Junius controversy ; also an article by Rusk ' ui . Miss Adelaide Procter contributes a lyric poem ; the editor another Roundabout Paper . "

M . Alexandre Dumas has favoured the world with the commencement of a translation of "Au Autobiography of Horace , discovered by M . Dumas iu the Library of the Vatican . " The opening portions tell us all about Horace ' s boyhood , and give a graphic account of his first visit to Rome , ancl his being placed by his father under the care of the terrible pedagogue , plagosus Orbilius . The opinion of the literary world upon Mr . Dumas ' s new production may be guessed from the following extract

from one of the best written papers in Paris : — " Dumas must have exhausted all the imagination with which nature endowed him—must have run short of old books and of all kind assistants—to have resorted to such a profanation of one of the most celebrated names of antiquity , '

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 10
  • You're on page11
  • 12
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy