Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • April 23, 1864
  • Page 5
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, April 23, 1864: Page 5

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, April 23, 1864
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article ARCHITECTURE IN FRANCE. ← Page 2 of 6 →
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Architecture In France.

date is given , m the guide-books , as 1114 , and it is said not to have been altered since . Nearly every arch is pointed , and it is so Gothic in its general feeling , so advanced in many of its details , that it is scarcely possible to credit its date to be so early . M . Yiollet-le-Duc , indeed ,

considers that it was almost destroyed before 1190 , and rebuilt circ . 1200 , and that date quite harmonizes with its present appearance . The shafting to the piers is so delicate in form as almost to be painfully so in parts , those of the nave especially . The mouldings are those so well known in later

times , and much of the enrichment is beautifully gracful , though the capitals retain much of the Romanesque in their foliage . The only thing wanting to complete the Gothic is tracery to the windows ; and were the church restored in its integrity , or finished as designed , one thing more

¦ onl y ivould be required to make it almost perfect —the chevet in place of the strai ght end . Laon altogether may be described as being thoroughly Gothic in outline , with much more Romanesque in detail , than works of the same date with us . It is a marvel in art , and presents a subject well

worth the most attentive study . Only a few miles from it is Noyon , almost perfect in plan , but wanting the picturesque towers of Laon .

Farther south , and about level with each other ¦ are Senlis , between Noyon and Paris , and St . Remi , at Rheims , much more to the east , both Romanesque , but St . Remi has strong marks ( in its towers particularly ) of the German influences which ive should expect to find there . Then we

find at Paris a still more curious contrast in style and dates , for we have in the earlier parts of St . Denis a great approach towards the perfect Gothic , whereas , within a short distance of it , there remains the church of St . Germain des Pres , built twenty years laterand perfectly Romanesque . This

, curious fact was brought very prominently forward by Mr . Scott , in his Royal Academy lectures . But still rnore curious is the history of St . Germain , as told by the writers upon it ; for they give clear and positive accounts of the church having been altogether rebuilt in the seventeenth century . I

cannot account for these statements , and merely bring them forward as not to be forgotten . The church is well known to me , and I do not believe that any restoration such as this must have been could have been carried out at the date assigned to it , or even now ; but , as the church is a most important one , the statements above alluded to should be known .

A little south of Paris we get Sens to the east , and Chartres to the west ; Sens Traditional , but Chartres pure Romanesque in its sculptured porch and west front . A little farther south and we come to the nave of the great cathedral of Le Mans , near Chartres .

This , too , is one that requires very strict examination on the spot . The arches over columns have clearly been put in round , the pointed arches of

mouldings have been introduced afterwards ; and it seemed to me , on close scrutiny , from a seeming alteration in the curve of the main arch ribs spanning the nave , that they were put in , at first round nearly to the apex , and then the summit altered into a point . I have a very strong

impression that the whole of this nave was finished at or near the end of the eleventh century , and that we have in it the nearest approach in these parts to the true basilican outline of the nave , it having been altered only as we find it in the twelfth century . A very little farther south and we come

on the Loire , to Angers and Tours cathedrals , and St . Nicholas , Blois . Tours was late in the century , and the earlier part is of well-advanced Gothic . But Angers and St . Nicholas seem much earlier , and present very noteable features . Angers has the bold cross , aisleless plan of Angouleme , but ivithout its domes ,

the church , of some 50 feet span , being vaulted with hi gh domical vaults , and nearly all the arches pointed : the ornamentation very rich and beautifully carved . But Angers contains very much of early date of extreme interest . St . Serge , for instance , the

choir whereof is said to be still earlier than the cathedral , and yet is designed with an elegance and lightness that make its feeling Gothic altogether . In fact , there are very few specimens of our Pointed architecture to equal it in lightness . Then , in St . Nicholas at Blois , we find the southern dome

combined with the northern chevet , the arches partly pointed and partly round , and the dome itself most curiously formed in a half-Byzantine , half-Eastern way . Blois is just at the midway between northern and southern influences , and its architecture is influenced just as we might expect .

South a little farther , but more to the east , and out of the direct reach of inediteval traffic , is the magnificent church of Bourges . This is chiefly of later date than the twelfth century , but there still stand , little the worse for their 700 years' wear , the two grand portals , north and south , and in

them you have the stiff archaic sculpture of the time . Bourges is now in the very heart of France , but it was , at that time , an outlying post in a barren country , and one does not look for nor find much progress there . Southward again , in the direct track of trade , we come to

Poictierssouthward still of that , to Angouleme ; both too well known to need much notice here . Poictiers is northern in its domical vaulting , and southern in the want of clerestory and triforium . Angouleme has the northern chevet , theAngiovine aisleless planand the altogether southern domes .

, These domes are Byzantine altogether . And now , for my last examples , we reach Moissac , Tarascon , and Aries , all in the great southern province : no trace there of northern art ; no fine lights and shadows from clerestory and triforium ; no boldly soaring towers ; no beautifully-planned apse . . We

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1864-04-23, Page 5” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 16 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_23041864/page/5/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
FREEMASONS' HALL.—THE NEW BUILDINGS. Article 1
ARCHITECTURE IN FRANCE. Article 4
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 9
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 11
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 12
METROPOLITAN. Article 13
PROVINCIAL. Article 14
ANCIENT AND ACCEPTED RITE. Article 16
ROYAL ARCH. Article 17
ISLE OF MAN. Article 17
THE WEEK. Article 18
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

3 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

3 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

2 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Architecture In France.

date is given , m the guide-books , as 1114 , and it is said not to have been altered since . Nearly every arch is pointed , and it is so Gothic in its general feeling , so advanced in many of its details , that it is scarcely possible to credit its date to be so early . M . Yiollet-le-Duc , indeed ,

considers that it was almost destroyed before 1190 , and rebuilt circ . 1200 , and that date quite harmonizes with its present appearance . The shafting to the piers is so delicate in form as almost to be painfully so in parts , those of the nave especially . The mouldings are those so well known in later

times , and much of the enrichment is beautifully gracful , though the capitals retain much of the Romanesque in their foliage . The only thing wanting to complete the Gothic is tracery to the windows ; and were the church restored in its integrity , or finished as designed , one thing more

¦ onl y ivould be required to make it almost perfect —the chevet in place of the strai ght end . Laon altogether may be described as being thoroughly Gothic in outline , with much more Romanesque in detail , than works of the same date with us . It is a marvel in art , and presents a subject well

worth the most attentive study . Only a few miles from it is Noyon , almost perfect in plan , but wanting the picturesque towers of Laon .

Farther south , and about level with each other ¦ are Senlis , between Noyon and Paris , and St . Remi , at Rheims , much more to the east , both Romanesque , but St . Remi has strong marks ( in its towers particularly ) of the German influences which ive should expect to find there . Then we

find at Paris a still more curious contrast in style and dates , for we have in the earlier parts of St . Denis a great approach towards the perfect Gothic , whereas , within a short distance of it , there remains the church of St . Germain des Pres , built twenty years laterand perfectly Romanesque . This

, curious fact was brought very prominently forward by Mr . Scott , in his Royal Academy lectures . But still rnore curious is the history of St . Germain , as told by the writers upon it ; for they give clear and positive accounts of the church having been altogether rebuilt in the seventeenth century . I

cannot account for these statements , and merely bring them forward as not to be forgotten . The church is well known to me , and I do not believe that any restoration such as this must have been could have been carried out at the date assigned to it , or even now ; but , as the church is a most important one , the statements above alluded to should be known .

A little south of Paris we get Sens to the east , and Chartres to the west ; Sens Traditional , but Chartres pure Romanesque in its sculptured porch and west front . A little farther south and we come to the nave of the great cathedral of Le Mans , near Chartres .

This , too , is one that requires very strict examination on the spot . The arches over columns have clearly been put in round , the pointed arches of

mouldings have been introduced afterwards ; and it seemed to me , on close scrutiny , from a seeming alteration in the curve of the main arch ribs spanning the nave , that they were put in , at first round nearly to the apex , and then the summit altered into a point . I have a very strong

impression that the whole of this nave was finished at or near the end of the eleventh century , and that we have in it the nearest approach in these parts to the true basilican outline of the nave , it having been altered only as we find it in the twelfth century . A very little farther south and we come

on the Loire , to Angers and Tours cathedrals , and St . Nicholas , Blois . Tours was late in the century , and the earlier part is of well-advanced Gothic . But Angers and St . Nicholas seem much earlier , and present very noteable features . Angers has the bold cross , aisleless plan of Angouleme , but ivithout its domes ,

the church , of some 50 feet span , being vaulted with hi gh domical vaults , and nearly all the arches pointed : the ornamentation very rich and beautifully carved . But Angers contains very much of early date of extreme interest . St . Serge , for instance , the

choir whereof is said to be still earlier than the cathedral , and yet is designed with an elegance and lightness that make its feeling Gothic altogether . In fact , there are very few specimens of our Pointed architecture to equal it in lightness . Then , in St . Nicholas at Blois , we find the southern dome

combined with the northern chevet , the arches partly pointed and partly round , and the dome itself most curiously formed in a half-Byzantine , half-Eastern way . Blois is just at the midway between northern and southern influences , and its architecture is influenced just as we might expect .

South a little farther , but more to the east , and out of the direct reach of inediteval traffic , is the magnificent church of Bourges . This is chiefly of later date than the twelfth century , but there still stand , little the worse for their 700 years' wear , the two grand portals , north and south , and in

them you have the stiff archaic sculpture of the time . Bourges is now in the very heart of France , but it was , at that time , an outlying post in a barren country , and one does not look for nor find much progress there . Southward again , in the direct track of trade , we come to

Poictierssouthward still of that , to Angouleme ; both too well known to need much notice here . Poictiers is northern in its domical vaulting , and southern in the want of clerestory and triforium . Angouleme has the northern chevet , theAngiovine aisleless planand the altogether southern domes .

, These domes are Byzantine altogether . And now , for my last examples , we reach Moissac , Tarascon , and Aries , all in the great southern province : no trace there of northern art ; no fine lights and shadows from clerestory and triforium ; no boldly soaring towers ; no beautifully-planned apse . . We

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 4
  • You're on page5
  • 6
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy