Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Sept. 20, 1862
  • Page 2
  • A ROMAN CATHOLIC'S NOTION OF FREEMASONRY.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Sept. 20, 1862: Page 2

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Sept. 20, 1862
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article MOTHER KILWINNING.—No. I. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article A ROMAN CATHOLIC'S NOTION OF FREEMASONRY. Page 1 of 4 →
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Mother Kilwinning.—No. I.

enterprising publishers of the one here referred to , they will adopt effectual means for securing , as far as practicable , perfect accuracy in the matters treated of in its pages . The class of readers among whom the Lexicon is likely to circulate , will not rest satisfied with a revision of any Masonic work so palpably

superficial as that to which the one under the hand of its Glasgow editor has heen subjected . We hope soon to see a revised edition worthy of the literary acquirements of a English Craftsman . In response to the kindly expressed aud

encouraging imitation of " A" conveyed to us through the MAGAZINE of the 9 th ult ., and also with the view of rectifying the errors which , in his notice of Kilwinning , Bro Mackey has unwittingly propagated , and which have most unaccountably been perpetuated by his Scottish reviser , we purpose contributing a few

running notes on the subject of Mother Kilwinning . We have not time to devote to the writing of a history of that famous lodge , nor are we in possession of Masonic knowledge superior to that within reach of every inquiring brother , but from our close

connection with the Mother Lodge , and the frequent opportunities we have enjoyed for consulting the records preserved in its archives , we may possibly be enabled to communicate some scraps of information which , if not of any great importance in themselves , may , when taken in conjunction with what others have drawn

from ancient Masonic minute books , be useful in aiding the student of Masonic history in his researches after the ancient land-marks of the Order , which are being rapidly obliterated through the ignorance or apathy of many of those who ought to be the conservators of our lodge records .

A Roman Catholic's Notion Of Freemasonry.

A ROMAN CATHOLIC'S NOTION OF FREEMASONRY .

( Continued from page Wo . ) Mr . Kohertson having concluded his historical sketch of our Order , proceeds to enquire how such au institution , which he is forced to admit is , " apparently so praiseworthy , " could have drawn down the censures of the Church and the hostility of so many

different governments ? And then adds : — " Let us investigate the matter calmly and with care . In the first place , the Catholic Church condemns all societies which , like that of tho Freemasons , impose secret oaths . The Scripture tells us , that " oar speech should be yea , yea , and nay , na }'; and that it is not lawful to swear . " The Church , which brings a message

from God , and speaks to us in the name of God , can exact an oath of its ; and so can the civil power ; for it has received from God the sword of justice , and , for the ends of justice , it bids us invoke the name of tho Supreme Author of all right . " Secondly , the oaths of the Freemasons arc not only secret , but , at the best , unnecessary ; for , should we even he unable to prove that in very many countries the ultimate objects of Freemasonry are most culpable , yet all admit that the matters sworn to in the minor grades are

most frivolous and . puerile . But a frivolous or unnecessary oath is in the eyes of the Church a guilty oath . " Next to secret oaths , there is another offence chargeable 021 tho Masonic , as on all other secret societies . This is , that it destroys human freedom , as it removes all individual responsibility . The mason of one grade knows not the projects of the brothers of a higher degree , nor

the lodges of one country , tho schemes , the principles , and tho workings of those of another . The individual is the blind , passive instrument of au Order , whose ultimate aims are wrapped up in secrecy . He is like a man who without a lamp enters into a dark cavern , whose length and breadth he knows not , nor the tortuous pasthat cross the main path . Where the ends of an

sages institution are kept secret , aud tho means only are avowed , judgment is at fault , and the individual cannot estimate the ex-tent of the responsibility he incurs for the errors of his Order . " But , in the third place , a more serious charge yet attaches to Freemasonry . There are some secret societies whose professed aim is the removal of certain local

grievances , or a violent overthrow of some particular Government . But the Masonic Order pretends to be in possession of a secret to make man better and happier than Christ , His Apostles , and His Church have made , or can make them . Monstrous pretension ! How is this esoteric teaching consistent with the full aud final revelation of divine truths ? If in the deep midnight ol

heathenism , the sago had been justified m seeking in the Itlysteries of Eleusis for a keener apprehension of the truths of primitive religion , how does this justify the Mason in tho mid-day effulgence of Christianity , to tell mankind that he has a wonderful secret for advancing thorn , iu virtue and in happiness—a secret unknown to the Incarnate God , and to the Church with which , as He

promised , the Paraclete should abide for ever ? And even the Protestant , who rejects the teaching of that unerring Church , if bo admits Christianity to be a final PkCveAation , must scout the pretensions of a society , that claims the possession of moral truths unknown to the Christian religion . ' ' The very pretensions of the Mason are thus impious

and absurb . lie stands condemned on his own showing ; and any inquiry into the doctrines and the workings of his Order becomes utterly superfluous . But when , further , ho obstinately withholds from the knowledge of the competent authority his marvellous remedies for tho moral and social maladies of men , what is he but and charlatan who refuses to submit to the examination of a

medical board his pretended wonderful cures ?" If the P . oinish Church has chosen to condemn all societies that impose secret oaths , by what power has it dons so ? The mere Bull of a Pope , without being confirmed by a council , is not to be taken as an act of the church , and this Mr . Eobertson knows better than we do .

The matters sworn to m wnat Mr . Robertson pleases to term " the minor grades" are neither frivolous nor puerile . Preemnsonry distinguishes her children by the knowledge and possession of certain signs ancl words , which are used all over the world as keys to our privileges , and that these signs and words shall not be divulged to relatives or friendsan oath

, to keep them secret is demanded . Their importance in being confined to those who have properly come by them , i . e ., by initiation , is of the utmost consequence to every Freemason in the universe , aud to keep them secure , we use the most binding form which can he applied to a man ' s conscienceand call him ,

, upon when he has those secrets entrusted to him , to promise , in the most solemn manner , by oath , that he will not reveal them . The words and the signs , ol themselves , are of no very particular importance hi "

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1862-09-20, Page 2” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 5 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_20091862/page/2/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
MOTHER KILWINNING.—No. I. Article 1
A ROMAN CATHOLIC'S NOTION OF FREEMASONRY. Article 2
BRITISH ARCHITECTS. Article 5
THE PATH OF LIFE. —AN ALLEGORY. Article 6
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 9
THE PARIS UNIVERSAL AND PERMANENT EXHIBITION. Article 12
CASES OF EMERGENCY. Article 12
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 13
THE MOUNT CALVARY ENCAMPMENT. Article 13
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 14
PROVINCIAL. Article 14
AUSTRALIA. Article 14
CANADA. Article 15
AMERICA. Article 16
ROYAL ARCH. Article 16
MARK MASONRY. Article 17
Poetry. Article 17
TO A YOUNG MASON WHO DECLARED HE SAW NO BEAUTY IN NATURE. Article 17
Obituary. Article 17
FREEMASONS AT LAW. Article 18
THE WEEK. Article 19
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

3 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

4 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

3 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

4 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

6 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

3 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Mother Kilwinning.—No. I.

enterprising publishers of the one here referred to , they will adopt effectual means for securing , as far as practicable , perfect accuracy in the matters treated of in its pages . The class of readers among whom the Lexicon is likely to circulate , will not rest satisfied with a revision of any Masonic work so palpably

superficial as that to which the one under the hand of its Glasgow editor has heen subjected . We hope soon to see a revised edition worthy of the literary acquirements of a English Craftsman . In response to the kindly expressed aud

encouraging imitation of " A" conveyed to us through the MAGAZINE of the 9 th ult ., and also with the view of rectifying the errors which , in his notice of Kilwinning , Bro Mackey has unwittingly propagated , and which have most unaccountably been perpetuated by his Scottish reviser , we purpose contributing a few

running notes on the subject of Mother Kilwinning . We have not time to devote to the writing of a history of that famous lodge , nor are we in possession of Masonic knowledge superior to that within reach of every inquiring brother , but from our close

connection with the Mother Lodge , and the frequent opportunities we have enjoyed for consulting the records preserved in its archives , we may possibly be enabled to communicate some scraps of information which , if not of any great importance in themselves , may , when taken in conjunction with what others have drawn

from ancient Masonic minute books , be useful in aiding the student of Masonic history in his researches after the ancient land-marks of the Order , which are being rapidly obliterated through the ignorance or apathy of many of those who ought to be the conservators of our lodge records .

A Roman Catholic's Notion Of Freemasonry.

A ROMAN CATHOLIC'S NOTION OF FREEMASONRY .

( Continued from page Wo . ) Mr . Kohertson having concluded his historical sketch of our Order , proceeds to enquire how such au institution , which he is forced to admit is , " apparently so praiseworthy , " could have drawn down the censures of the Church and the hostility of so many

different governments ? And then adds : — " Let us investigate the matter calmly and with care . In the first place , the Catholic Church condemns all societies which , like that of tho Freemasons , impose secret oaths . The Scripture tells us , that " oar speech should be yea , yea , and nay , na }'; and that it is not lawful to swear . " The Church , which brings a message

from God , and speaks to us in the name of God , can exact an oath of its ; and so can the civil power ; for it has received from God the sword of justice , and , for the ends of justice , it bids us invoke the name of tho Supreme Author of all right . " Secondly , the oaths of the Freemasons arc not only secret , but , at the best , unnecessary ; for , should we even he unable to prove that in very many countries the ultimate objects of Freemasonry are most culpable , yet all admit that the matters sworn to in the minor grades are

most frivolous and . puerile . But a frivolous or unnecessary oath is in the eyes of the Church a guilty oath . " Next to secret oaths , there is another offence chargeable 021 tho Masonic , as on all other secret societies . This is , that it destroys human freedom , as it removes all individual responsibility . The mason of one grade knows not the projects of the brothers of a higher degree , nor

the lodges of one country , tho schemes , the principles , and tho workings of those of another . The individual is the blind , passive instrument of au Order , whose ultimate aims are wrapped up in secrecy . He is like a man who without a lamp enters into a dark cavern , whose length and breadth he knows not , nor the tortuous pasthat cross the main path . Where the ends of an

sages institution are kept secret , aud tho means only are avowed , judgment is at fault , and the individual cannot estimate the ex-tent of the responsibility he incurs for the errors of his Order . " But , in the third place , a more serious charge yet attaches to Freemasonry . There are some secret societies whose professed aim is the removal of certain local

grievances , or a violent overthrow of some particular Government . But the Masonic Order pretends to be in possession of a secret to make man better and happier than Christ , His Apostles , and His Church have made , or can make them . Monstrous pretension ! How is this esoteric teaching consistent with the full aud final revelation of divine truths ? If in the deep midnight ol

heathenism , the sago had been justified m seeking in the Itlysteries of Eleusis for a keener apprehension of the truths of primitive religion , how does this justify the Mason in tho mid-day effulgence of Christianity , to tell mankind that he has a wonderful secret for advancing thorn , iu virtue and in happiness—a secret unknown to the Incarnate God , and to the Church with which , as He

promised , the Paraclete should abide for ever ? And even the Protestant , who rejects the teaching of that unerring Church , if bo admits Christianity to be a final PkCveAation , must scout the pretensions of a society , that claims the possession of moral truths unknown to the Christian religion . ' ' The very pretensions of the Mason are thus impious

and absurb . lie stands condemned on his own showing ; and any inquiry into the doctrines and the workings of his Order becomes utterly superfluous . But when , further , ho obstinately withholds from the knowledge of the competent authority his marvellous remedies for tho moral and social maladies of men , what is he but and charlatan who refuses to submit to the examination of a

medical board his pretended wonderful cures ?" If the P . oinish Church has chosen to condemn all societies that impose secret oaths , by what power has it dons so ? The mere Bull of a Pope , without being confirmed by a council , is not to be taken as an act of the church , and this Mr . Eobertson knows better than we do .

The matters sworn to m wnat Mr . Robertson pleases to term " the minor grades" are neither frivolous nor puerile . Preemnsonry distinguishes her children by the knowledge and possession of certain signs ancl words , which are used all over the world as keys to our privileges , and that these signs and words shall not be divulged to relatives or friendsan oath

, to keep them secret is demanded . Their importance in being confined to those who have properly come by them , i . e ., by initiation , is of the utmost consequence to every Freemason in the universe , aud to keep them secure , we use the most binding form which can he applied to a man ' s conscienceand call him ,

, upon when he has those secrets entrusted to him , to promise , in the most solemn manner , by oath , that he will not reveal them . The words and the signs , ol themselves , are of no very particular importance hi "

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • You're on page2
  • 3
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy