Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Oct. 12, 1861
  • Page 9
  • CORRESPONDENCE.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Oct. 12, 1861: Page 9

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Oct. 12, 1861
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article NOTES ON LITERATURE SCIENCE AND ART. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Notes On Literature Science And Art.

twelve volumes . An English translation , of Mazzmi's Diciies of Man- may shortly be looked for from the press . AA'illiam Mee , the author of the beautiful and once-popular song of Alice Greg , is now an inmate of Shallow Union AVorkhouse , in Derbyshire . ' Professor Masson , in Macmillan's Magazine , very ably remarks

as follows on the purport of history : — " What is history for but to recover forgotten names that ought not to be forgotten , to make rich our memories , to connect the life of the present , through an avenue of increasingly strong recollections , with the life of the past ? And more ancl more it will be found that in history , as in other things , superficiality will not do—that there must be quarrying and deep digging , ancl turning over and over of heaps of buried

material , ancl marshalling of entire orders of facts that have heen lost sight of but are still recoverable ; that the presentation again and again , as in most of our popular narratives , of a few large historical names and incidents already familiar , with repetitions ofthe old comments respecting them , and a dash of twopenny philosophy about the laws of progress , is a method of sheer indolence , which , is beggaring our historical literature before our very eyes , and driving us farther ancl farther from all hope of ever knowing what

the real laws of human progress may have been ; that , in short , while the largest names and events will ahvays have the preference , it is the very use of history to chastise our ignorance and rouse our curiosity over and over again , by revealing to us what a

multiplicity of things , behind those names and events , and yet in vital connection with them , remains to be known . Ancl where shall history exercise itself more usefully , with any such end in view , than in the exploration of our own national annals—of those English , Irish , and Scottish affairs of a few by-past centuries , out of which , by direct development , our own civilisation has come ? Shall it be deemed right and proper that volume after volume should be written that we may know a thing or two about

Tiglath-Pileser and other polysyllabic Assyrians—shall it be deemed a labour worthy of our scholars and historians to clear up for us the politics of Nikias , or to tell the true story of the Gracchi—and shall it he with impatience that , because of our very ignorance in our own national history , we hear of men who , though they did chance to wear homespun . English or Scottish names , did more for ns a good deal than ever Tiglath-Pileser meant to do , were more akin to us than Nikias , served our liberties more nearly than , all

the Roman Gracchi ? At all events , if a modern writer , of his own free will , does make a raid among those less-known worthies of our national past—if , with an intent not to honour but 'co vilify , he pays a visit to their graves , disturbing in that little-invaded solitude the grass ancl the weeds that time has made so rank—what is any one else to do that may have been lingering among these graves before him , on an errand more like that of Old Mortality , but to start up , mallet and chisel in hand , and confront the intruder ?"

At a public meeting held in the town-hall , Ripon , on Friday , the 4 th inst ., our R . AV . Bro . the Earl de Grey and Ripon in the chair , it was resolved to repair and restore the ancient cathedral of that city , at an estimated cost of £ 32 , 000 . An able and lengthy report by Mr . Scott , the eminent Gothic architect , was read to the meeting .

A new novel , entitled The StoTcesleg Secret , by Miss Yonge , is just being published . She has also in the press a work on Christian names .

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

The JSditor is not responsible for the opinions expressed by Correspondents . BRO . PETER'S METHOD OF RECRUITING FOR FREEMASONRY .

IO THE EDITOK OP THE Pr . EIi'iSOXS' -JiGAZIJfE AXD HAS 03 . IC HIEBOE . DEAE SIE AND BEOTHEE , —In pleading , at page 191 of your useful magazine , for the removal of that un-Masonic regulation which denies to the most intelligent and virtuous man in the world the glorious privileges of our Craft , if he happen toserve his country as a private soldierI acknow

^ , - ledged " that the army generally is not the best place in which to recruit for Freemasonry ; " whereupon Bro . Webster , the Secretary of the Britannia Lodge ( No . 162 ) , Sheffield ) , takes exception to the phrase " recruiting for Freemasonry , " though he himself , in the same letter in which he is horrified at my expression , uses the certainly not less

objectionable one of " not Avhere we should seek , brethren . " Is not this really a distinction without a difference ? I will not do Bro . Webster the injustice to pervert his meaning , as he has evidently clone mine ; but as that remakably charitably-minded correspondent , J . W . W ., who " was initiated in a military lodge , ancl Master of it [ of which I have no doubt ] several times , " has also gloated ovor Avhat

he evidently regards as my bad Masonry , —remarking that what I mean by recruiting for Freemasonry he is " at a loss to know , " as soliciting even is " strictly forbidden , " and that my obligation should have , taught me better ; I will now proceed to explain what I mean by " recruiting for Freemasonry . " As I shall have much to say on this subject , I will divide my remarks into a series of letters , so that I

may not trespass too much on your pages ; and I will leave it to the good sense of your readers to determine whether I am what Bro . Webster has proclaimed me , or the ( if possible ) still more degraded ancl depraved monster Avhich J . W . W . has conjured up in his imagination . And in the very commencement of my promised explanation , it wil he well to see what the term recruiting , or , as I used it , to recruit , really means . WALKER defines it " To re-pair anytlvinq wasted hy new supplies ; io supply an array

with new men . " Now , as one half of tbe contentions in the Avorld arise from different parties putting different meanings on the same expressions , and foolishly striving to find something in which they differ , instead of going together as far as they can hand in hand , and then each parting in peace when they can accompany one another no further , I will , in these letters , from time to time , by your permission ,

boldly but reverently state my views on the present state of Freemasonry , what it too often is , and what it always should be , in practice , and prove to every " true and faithfal brother amongst us " that it is not " Peter , " but those who differ from him , who remove our ancient landmarks , and degrade our Royal Art . And if I write strongly on the subject , it is because I feel strongly too ; and I beseech

every true brother who may peruse my letters , to believe me when I state that it is not from the paltry desire of giving pain to any one that I take up my pen , but from higher and holier motives . Ancl as every true reformer must expect abuse and slander , and all sorts of persecution which may he in the power of the friends of corruption , I shall not be surprised if , during the progress of my epistles through the press , I am attacked with still more virulence even than I have been . But , as our gifted brother , Du . CHAELES MACKAA " , truly sings : —

" But truth shall conquer at ths last , For round and round me run , Ancl ever the right comes uppermost , And ever is justice done . " The very fact that I was anxious in any way " to -recruit " for the Craft , might have shov / ii that I had zeal for the

Order ; and if brothers thought that- it was not a zeal according to knowledge , it was their duty , in a different spirit to Avhat has been shown towards me , to bring me to the light . " Their obligations should have taught them better . " That the ranks of Freemasonry must he " recruited , " year by year , every sensible man will allow , unless the Orderis to cease to exist ; a catastrophe which will not happen

whilst there is so much work for it yet to do . And yet we are continually losing our brethren : some by the hand of death—that inevitable destiny which the Master Mason has been so wisely taught to contemplate ; seme b y removal to foreign lands ; some by Avithdrawal from our loclges , though they can never withdraAV from the Masonic obligation , however much they may practically despise it . It is evident ,

then , that our ranks must be constantly supplied with younger brethren , Avho will learn the Eoyal Art from the old Craftsmen , and carry on the great work of Freemasonry when their aged instructors are no longer able to bear the heat ancl burden of the clay . Ancl of each aged Mason may it be said : — " Age sits with decent grace upon his visage ,

Ancl worthily becomes his silver locks ; He wears the marks of many years well spent , Of virtue , truth well tried , ancl wise experiance . " — lueliolas JEoioe ,

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1861-10-12, Page 9” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 30 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_12101861/page/9/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
MASTERS, WARDENS, AND PAST MASTERS. Article 1
FRANCE. Article 2
ARCHITECTURE AND ARCHÆOLOGY. Article 2
FROM WESTMINSTER TO LONDON BRIDGE. Article 4
THE EXHIBITION OF 1862. Article 5
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 7
NOTES ON LITERATURE SCIENCE AND ART. Article 8
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 9
FREEMASON'S WIFE. Article 10
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 11
THE GIRLS' SCHOOL. Article 11
METROPOLITAN. Article 11
PROVINCIAL. Article 11
TURKEY. Article 13
INDIA. Article 13
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR. Article 15
MARK MASONRY. Article 15
NOTES ON MUSIC AND THE DRAMA. Article 16
PUBLIC AMUSEMENTS. Article 16
THE WEEK. Article 17
Untitled Article 20
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

4 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

2 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

3 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

5 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

4 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

4 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

3 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

4 Articles
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Notes On Literature Science And Art.

twelve volumes . An English translation , of Mazzmi's Diciies of Man- may shortly be looked for from the press . AA'illiam Mee , the author of the beautiful and once-popular song of Alice Greg , is now an inmate of Shallow Union AVorkhouse , in Derbyshire . ' Professor Masson , in Macmillan's Magazine , very ably remarks

as follows on the purport of history : — " What is history for but to recover forgotten names that ought not to be forgotten , to make rich our memories , to connect the life of the present , through an avenue of increasingly strong recollections , with the life of the past ? And more ancl more it will be found that in history , as in other things , superficiality will not do—that there must be quarrying and deep digging , ancl turning over and over of heaps of buried

material , ancl marshalling of entire orders of facts that have heen lost sight of but are still recoverable ; that the presentation again and again , as in most of our popular narratives , of a few large historical names and incidents already familiar , with repetitions ofthe old comments respecting them , and a dash of twopenny philosophy about the laws of progress , is a method of sheer indolence , which , is beggaring our historical literature before our very eyes , and driving us farther ancl farther from all hope of ever knowing what

the real laws of human progress may have been ; that , in short , while the largest names and events will ahvays have the preference , it is the very use of history to chastise our ignorance and rouse our curiosity over and over again , by revealing to us what a

multiplicity of things , behind those names and events , and yet in vital connection with them , remains to be known . Ancl where shall history exercise itself more usefully , with any such end in view , than in the exploration of our own national annals—of those English , Irish , and Scottish affairs of a few by-past centuries , out of which , by direct development , our own civilisation has come ? Shall it be deemed right and proper that volume after volume should be written that we may know a thing or two about

Tiglath-Pileser and other polysyllabic Assyrians—shall it be deemed a labour worthy of our scholars and historians to clear up for us the politics of Nikias , or to tell the true story of the Gracchi—and shall it he with impatience that , because of our very ignorance in our own national history , we hear of men who , though they did chance to wear homespun . English or Scottish names , did more for ns a good deal than ever Tiglath-Pileser meant to do , were more akin to us than Nikias , served our liberties more nearly than , all

the Roman Gracchi ? At all events , if a modern writer , of his own free will , does make a raid among those less-known worthies of our national past—if , with an intent not to honour but 'co vilify , he pays a visit to their graves , disturbing in that little-invaded solitude the grass ancl the weeds that time has made so rank—what is any one else to do that may have been lingering among these graves before him , on an errand more like that of Old Mortality , but to start up , mallet and chisel in hand , and confront the intruder ?"

At a public meeting held in the town-hall , Ripon , on Friday , the 4 th inst ., our R . AV . Bro . the Earl de Grey and Ripon in the chair , it was resolved to repair and restore the ancient cathedral of that city , at an estimated cost of £ 32 , 000 . An able and lengthy report by Mr . Scott , the eminent Gothic architect , was read to the meeting .

A new novel , entitled The StoTcesleg Secret , by Miss Yonge , is just being published . She has also in the press a work on Christian names .

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

The JSditor is not responsible for the opinions expressed by Correspondents . BRO . PETER'S METHOD OF RECRUITING FOR FREEMASONRY .

IO THE EDITOK OP THE Pr . EIi'iSOXS' -JiGAZIJfE AXD HAS 03 . IC HIEBOE . DEAE SIE AND BEOTHEE , —In pleading , at page 191 of your useful magazine , for the removal of that un-Masonic regulation which denies to the most intelligent and virtuous man in the world the glorious privileges of our Craft , if he happen toserve his country as a private soldierI acknow

^ , - ledged " that the army generally is not the best place in which to recruit for Freemasonry ; " whereupon Bro . Webster , the Secretary of the Britannia Lodge ( No . 162 ) , Sheffield ) , takes exception to the phrase " recruiting for Freemasonry , " though he himself , in the same letter in which he is horrified at my expression , uses the certainly not less

objectionable one of " not Avhere we should seek , brethren . " Is not this really a distinction without a difference ? I will not do Bro . Webster the injustice to pervert his meaning , as he has evidently clone mine ; but as that remakably charitably-minded correspondent , J . W . W ., who " was initiated in a military lodge , ancl Master of it [ of which I have no doubt ] several times , " has also gloated ovor Avhat

he evidently regards as my bad Masonry , —remarking that what I mean by recruiting for Freemasonry he is " at a loss to know , " as soliciting even is " strictly forbidden , " and that my obligation should have , taught me better ; I will now proceed to explain what I mean by " recruiting for Freemasonry . " As I shall have much to say on this subject , I will divide my remarks into a series of letters , so that I

may not trespass too much on your pages ; and I will leave it to the good sense of your readers to determine whether I am what Bro . Webster has proclaimed me , or the ( if possible ) still more degraded ancl depraved monster Avhich J . W . W . has conjured up in his imagination . And in the very commencement of my promised explanation , it wil he well to see what the term recruiting , or , as I used it , to recruit , really means . WALKER defines it " To re-pair anytlvinq wasted hy new supplies ; io supply an array

with new men . " Now , as one half of tbe contentions in the Avorld arise from different parties putting different meanings on the same expressions , and foolishly striving to find something in which they differ , instead of going together as far as they can hand in hand , and then each parting in peace when they can accompany one another no further , I will , in these letters , from time to time , by your permission ,

boldly but reverently state my views on the present state of Freemasonry , what it too often is , and what it always should be , in practice , and prove to every " true and faithfal brother amongst us " that it is not " Peter , " but those who differ from him , who remove our ancient landmarks , and degrade our Royal Art . And if I write strongly on the subject , it is because I feel strongly too ; and I beseech

every true brother who may peruse my letters , to believe me when I state that it is not from the paltry desire of giving pain to any one that I take up my pen , but from higher and holier motives . Ancl as every true reformer must expect abuse and slander , and all sorts of persecution which may he in the power of the friends of corruption , I shall not be surprised if , during the progress of my epistles through the press , I am attacked with still more virulence even than I have been . But , as our gifted brother , Du . CHAELES MACKAA " , truly sings : —

" But truth shall conquer at ths last , For round and round me run , Ancl ever the right comes uppermost , And ever is justice done . " The very fact that I was anxious in any way " to -recruit " for the Craft , might have shov / ii that I had zeal for the

Order ; and if brothers thought that- it was not a zeal according to knowledge , it was their duty , in a different spirit to Avhat has been shown towards me , to bring me to the light . " Their obligations should have taught them better . " That the ranks of Freemasonry must he " recruited , " year by year , every sensible man will allow , unless the Orderis to cease to exist ; a catastrophe which will not happen

whilst there is so much work for it yet to do . And yet we are continually losing our brethren : some by the hand of death—that inevitable destiny which the Master Mason has been so wisely taught to contemplate ; seme b y removal to foreign lands ; some by Avithdrawal from our loclges , though they can never withdraAV from the Masonic obligation , however much they may practically despise it . It is evident ,

then , that our ranks must be constantly supplied with younger brethren , Avho will learn the Eoyal Art from the old Craftsmen , and carry on the great work of Freemasonry when their aged instructors are no longer able to bear the heat ancl burden of the clay . Ancl of each aged Mason may it be said : — " Age sits with decent grace upon his visage ,

Ancl worthily becomes his silver locks ; He wears the marks of many years well spent , Of virtue , truth well tried , ancl wise experiance . " — lueliolas JEoioe ,

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 8
  • You're on page9
  • 10
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy