Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • May 8, 1869
  • Page 11
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, May 8, 1869: Page 11

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, May 8, 1869
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article UNIFORMITY OF RITUAL. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article UNIFORMITY OF RITUAL. Page 2 of 2
    Article MASONIC PERSECUTION.—WITNESSES TO THE TRUTH. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Uniformity Of Ritual.

independent bodies of the Order first connected themselves with the Masonic fraternity . Preceptory for the Temple and Priory , or Coiamander for the Order of St . J ohn or Malta , ought to be the designation . The title of Prelate is also a modern innovation ; Chaplain was the only name by which

brethren ordained for religious duties , and exempt from military service , were known in the Order . Captains of Columns and Lines are not to be found amongst the titles . In the costume , since the ridiculous appendage of the apron has been superseded by the surcoat or tunic , a move has been made in the

right direction , but why not add the red skull cap and spurs , which Avould be in accordance with ancient usage . Discontinue the theatrical black silk gauntlets , and substitute the buff leather ones—a distinction in the costume of the Chaplain is necessary . The jewels or insignia of the Order demand

consideration . The silver star now worn , was never a badge of the ancient Order , and is but a paltry affair at best . The old authors ou the Orders of Knighthood , say : — " Les Chevaliers du Temple iis etoient vetus d ' un habit blanc , et par dessus iis partoient selons , les un une croix patriarchal rouge potence ,

_ et une croix a huit points , aussi , rouge et bordu d'or selons les autres . " This cross ' ' has the extremities concave , > 5 « to show the eight points , and this varies from our " * - cross patee . The cross patriarchal , with the white habit , appears to have been given them when they first made their professions to the Patriarch of Jerusalem , but when they exempted themselves from obedience to him they changed the cross

patriarchal to a block one of eight points , Avith an orle or bordure white , and this has been adopted by the Scottish Templars . Your correspondent , "Lupus " who wrote so interesting a letter on heraldic badges , page 24 S , will find mention of this cross in " Andrew Flavine , Theatre of Honour , '' Book ix ., p . 7 , and

• also in a note on the Beauseant in the " Statutes of the Scottish Templars , "—bearing testimony , as I do , to the correctness of the remarks of "Lupus" on the armorial bearings of the Hospitallers , I cannot agree Avith him that the present cross for a Prior of the Masonic Order of Malta ( borrowed from the

Ordre du Temple of France ) , is at all inappropriate , for here Ave have the true eight pointed Avhite cross of Malta , charged with the red cross of the Templar , thus combining the two Orders , as practised in England . For the armorial hearings of English Knights , Bro .

Oneal Haye has suggested , page 150 , an excellent augmentation by placing ( as I now understand him ) the cross of the Temple aud St . John on a chief parted in the centre by the shield of England , the three golden lions . The old ceremonies of a receptionand the rituals

, used in the three kingdoms will require to be carefully examined to form a correct and uniform one , based on historical accuracy . The Orders are now viewed in their true character , as chivalrie , and the fable of their origin as secret high degrees of Masonry quite discorded .

These remarks refer equally to the Order of Malta , the ritual adopted in England being capable of great improvement . It is the same , Avith some trifling alterations , as that used in Scotland , where it has

Uniformity Of Ritual.

been known since the end of the last century , and then spoken of as of long standing . The late Judge Waller Rodwell Wright , who was at one time Grand Master of the English Templars , in a report to the Grand Lodge of England , from the Island of Malta , stated , that although there was

evidence of a lodge of Freemasons having existed there amongst the Knights in the middle of the last century , Freemasonry was not connected with the Order of St . John . We are , therefore , led to believe that the present Masonic Order of Malta was derivedwith that of the Templefrom Scotland

, , , where the two Orders were united , ancl existed as State Orders to the period of the Reformation , when their scattered members associated themselves with the Masonic fraternity . I am satisfied that any brother interested in the Orders will with me thatas far as the altered

agree , state of society permits a return to correct usages and customs cannot be too strongly advocated . 9 th April , 1869 . CANADA .

2 &

Masonic Persecution.—Witnesses To The Truth.

MASONIC PERSECUTION . —WITNESSES TO THE TRUTH .

TO THE BDITOn OF THE FBEEMASOJfS MAGAZINE AUD MASOKIC MIBEOB . Dear Sir and Brother . —Another contributor to " Notes and Queries , " page 330 of your Magazine , alluding to the re-discovered mysteries , asks whether Bro . Melville "is not trying to impose upon the public , " verily the question is an invidious one ,

persecuting a brother—a scholar—whose truth alone performed the herculean task of disintegrating from the lumber , the historic debris of by-gone ages—the sacred mysteries which the distinguished historian , the late Bro . Oliver , with singular foresight and perspicuity , so far knew Avere held secret by the Order ,

that he ingeniously declared they had been long , long lost . Had your contributor , with brotherly courtesy , gone , to and earnestly sought "light , " from Bro . Melville , on the subject of the sacred mysteries , and had he been thereafter ' competent to prove their fallacy , then and not until then , he would have been

amply justified in denounced their author as an " impostor . " " Take nothing for granted " is the sage ' s advice to students , but it is not by denials , however lustily uttered , any more than by analytical inaction that students can ever hope to solve problems , or test the

properties of simples . Your contributor ignores the sage's advice , for he disregards e \ idenee , and passes sentence Avithout even giving the accused the benefit of a doubt ; what would have been said of the judge in the case of Miss Saurin , had he not devoted the most patient , the most

undivided attention to the most minute testimony for days in succession , before summing up and pronouncing judgment thereon ? In the case of Bro . Melville , the Grand Registrar bears witness he had been shown by him that the " ceremonies " were registered in heaven ! and who in their philosophy could ever before have dreamt

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1869-05-08, Page 11” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 15 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_08051869/page/11/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
NUMBERS. Article 1
MASONIC CELESTIAL MYSTERIES. Article 2
THE KNIGHTS TEMPLARS. Article 6
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 8
UNIFORMITY OF RITUAL. Article 10
MASONIC PERSECUTION.—WITNESSES TO THE TRUTH. Article 11
OUR CARDINAL AND THE DUBLIN GRAND MASONIC ASSEMBLY. Article 12
BRO. MELVILLE AND HIS DISCOVERIES. Article 12
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 14
MASONIC ARCHÆOLOGICAL INSTITUTE. Article 14
METROPOLITAN. Article 15
PROVINCIAL. Article 16
SCOTLAND. Article 17
CHANNEL ISLANDS. Article 17
ROYAL ARCH. Article 18
MEETINGS OF THE LEARNED SOCIETIES. Article 19
LIST OF LODGE, &c., MEETINGS FOR WEEK ENDING 15TH MAY, 1869. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

3 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

3 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

3 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

2 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

4 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

2 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

3 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

1 Article
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Uniformity Of Ritual.

independent bodies of the Order first connected themselves with the Masonic fraternity . Preceptory for the Temple and Priory , or Coiamander for the Order of St . J ohn or Malta , ought to be the designation . The title of Prelate is also a modern innovation ; Chaplain was the only name by which

brethren ordained for religious duties , and exempt from military service , were known in the Order . Captains of Columns and Lines are not to be found amongst the titles . In the costume , since the ridiculous appendage of the apron has been superseded by the surcoat or tunic , a move has been made in the

right direction , but why not add the red skull cap and spurs , which Avould be in accordance with ancient usage . Discontinue the theatrical black silk gauntlets , and substitute the buff leather ones—a distinction in the costume of the Chaplain is necessary . The jewels or insignia of the Order demand

consideration . The silver star now worn , was never a badge of the ancient Order , and is but a paltry affair at best . The old authors ou the Orders of Knighthood , say : — " Les Chevaliers du Temple iis etoient vetus d ' un habit blanc , et par dessus iis partoient selons , les un une croix patriarchal rouge potence ,

_ et une croix a huit points , aussi , rouge et bordu d'or selons les autres . " This cross ' ' has the extremities concave , > 5 « to show the eight points , and this varies from our " * - cross patee . The cross patriarchal , with the white habit , appears to have been given them when they first made their professions to the Patriarch of Jerusalem , but when they exempted themselves from obedience to him they changed the cross

patriarchal to a block one of eight points , Avith an orle or bordure white , and this has been adopted by the Scottish Templars . Your correspondent , "Lupus " who wrote so interesting a letter on heraldic badges , page 24 S , will find mention of this cross in " Andrew Flavine , Theatre of Honour , '' Book ix ., p . 7 , and

• also in a note on the Beauseant in the " Statutes of the Scottish Templars , "—bearing testimony , as I do , to the correctness of the remarks of "Lupus" on the armorial bearings of the Hospitallers , I cannot agree Avith him that the present cross for a Prior of the Masonic Order of Malta ( borrowed from the

Ordre du Temple of France ) , is at all inappropriate , for here Ave have the true eight pointed Avhite cross of Malta , charged with the red cross of the Templar , thus combining the two Orders , as practised in England . For the armorial hearings of English Knights , Bro .

Oneal Haye has suggested , page 150 , an excellent augmentation by placing ( as I now understand him ) the cross of the Temple aud St . John on a chief parted in the centre by the shield of England , the three golden lions . The old ceremonies of a receptionand the rituals

, used in the three kingdoms will require to be carefully examined to form a correct and uniform one , based on historical accuracy . The Orders are now viewed in their true character , as chivalrie , and the fable of their origin as secret high degrees of Masonry quite discorded .

These remarks refer equally to the Order of Malta , the ritual adopted in England being capable of great improvement . It is the same , Avith some trifling alterations , as that used in Scotland , where it has

Uniformity Of Ritual.

been known since the end of the last century , and then spoken of as of long standing . The late Judge Waller Rodwell Wright , who was at one time Grand Master of the English Templars , in a report to the Grand Lodge of England , from the Island of Malta , stated , that although there was

evidence of a lodge of Freemasons having existed there amongst the Knights in the middle of the last century , Freemasonry was not connected with the Order of St . John . We are , therefore , led to believe that the present Masonic Order of Malta was derivedwith that of the Templefrom Scotland

, , , where the two Orders were united , ancl existed as State Orders to the period of the Reformation , when their scattered members associated themselves with the Masonic fraternity . I am satisfied that any brother interested in the Orders will with me thatas far as the altered

agree , state of society permits a return to correct usages and customs cannot be too strongly advocated . 9 th April , 1869 . CANADA .

2 &

Masonic Persecution.—Witnesses To The Truth.

MASONIC PERSECUTION . —WITNESSES TO THE TRUTH .

TO THE BDITOn OF THE FBEEMASOJfS MAGAZINE AUD MASOKIC MIBEOB . Dear Sir and Brother . —Another contributor to " Notes and Queries , " page 330 of your Magazine , alluding to the re-discovered mysteries , asks whether Bro . Melville "is not trying to impose upon the public , " verily the question is an invidious one ,

persecuting a brother—a scholar—whose truth alone performed the herculean task of disintegrating from the lumber , the historic debris of by-gone ages—the sacred mysteries which the distinguished historian , the late Bro . Oliver , with singular foresight and perspicuity , so far knew Avere held secret by the Order ,

that he ingeniously declared they had been long , long lost . Had your contributor , with brotherly courtesy , gone , to and earnestly sought "light , " from Bro . Melville , on the subject of the sacred mysteries , and had he been thereafter ' competent to prove their fallacy , then and not until then , he would have been

amply justified in denounced their author as an " impostor . " " Take nothing for granted " is the sage ' s advice to students , but it is not by denials , however lustily uttered , any more than by analytical inaction that students can ever hope to solve problems , or test the

properties of simples . Your contributor ignores the sage's advice , for he disregards e \ idenee , and passes sentence Avithout even giving the accused the benefit of a doubt ; what would have been said of the judge in the case of Miss Saurin , had he not devoted the most patient , the most

undivided attention to the most minute testimony for days in succession , before summing up and pronouncing judgment thereon ? In the case of Bro . Melville , the Grand Registrar bears witness he had been shown by him that the " ceremonies " were registered in heaven ! and who in their philosophy could ever before have dreamt

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 10
  • You're on page11
  • 12
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy