Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Jan. 2, 1864
  • Page 11
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Jan. 2, 1864: Page 11

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Jan. 2, 1864
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. ← Page 2 of 3 →
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Notes And Queries.

" Tho indiscriminate admission into the Order of any class or denomination of persons cannot fail to operate injuriously , and to bring discredit upon the Craft ; but this observation applies with equal force to the Christian portion of the woi-kl as to any other . The whole tenor of our laws , as well as of the ancient charges , is to guard against the initiation of individuals whose conduct , character , or education would not reflect credit on Masonry : and it is greatly to be regretted that these regulations are not sufficiently attended to .

" Opinion of Fr . Grant , Trot : G . M . of Bengal , " In regard to the admission of Hindoos and Mussulmans into Masonry , as authorised in the communication just read from His Eoyal Highness the Grand Master of all England and its territories , I feel it to bo my duty to say a few words , in order to inculcate the greatest caution among all members of the Craft , as to the persons

belonging to the two great classes of natives of India proper to be recommended for initiation into our Order . " You are well aware , my brethren , that when a highly distinguished and respectable Hindoo was proposed for initiation by a member of one of our Calcutta lodges , an insuperable difficulty presented itself in the question of how he was to be obligated ? This was more especiall

y the case as he was understood to live at variance with many of the rules of the caste . How are wo also to reconcile a belief , in its full aud sufficient integrity , in tho G . A . O . T . U . with a system of gross idolatry , or a state of morals hinging mainly upon external observances ? Mussulmans have the Koran , and upon that book they may be obligated .

" As respects Hindoos again , supposing that candidates may satisfy us concerning a true belief in the Almighty Architect of the Universe and a future state of responsibility and rewards and punishments , upon what are we to obligate them ? The Teds , the Piirans , or their Commentaries ? Aud how are wo to reconcile certain anomalies with the calls and duties of Masonryand to arrive

, at a sufficient knowledge of the moral worth of those whom they affect , previous to recommending them for the fellowship and privileges and mysteries of tho Craft ? " As respects the question of moral character , there is

not , among ourselves , or Europeans in general in this country , a man whose conduct and habits of life are not known to his neighbours , and not one upon whom there is not a moral check through that chain of electric sympathy that binds our institutions and connects every man as a link to his follow , on the basis of a wholly domestic system that has stood the tost of ages , and a

common philanthropy utterly alien , as far as we are aware , to the systems of caste and polygamy . The consequence is , that moral flagrancy , or conduct palpably at issue with the moral sense , instantly thrills through all the links of our social chain . " What a mighty engine of moral influence and control have we here !

" Turn we now to the natives : what do we know of their conduct as moral agents , or of their social sympathies P Almost nothing ! Shut up as they are beyond our reach by a strict and impenetrable circle of exclusion and the darkest privacy , what can we know of their family aud domestic traits , thoughts , principles , and acts , or of their virtues and vices behind this iron

curtain . Of the tendencies of such a system , and some of the revolting anomalies which it gives rise to and fosters as in a hotbed , I need say nothing , for the results and effects are familiar to tho most superficial observers . " I am grieved to confess it , but still , after a residence of twenty-six years in this country , I am entitled to express an opinion upon a matter of such importance to

our ancient and honourable institution . Ancl is not the general disregard of the natives for truth so notorious , that while wc grieve at it , we cannot , at the same time , deny the fact ? Hero is an awful difficulty that meets us at tho very threshold of the question .

" Truth is the very rock upou which all moral principle and social security are founded . He whose name aud attributes are revealed in this blessed book open before me , has , as one of his most distinguishing titles , the name of the God of Truth . Our great adversary again , that mysterious being who is emphatically the Evil One , is , by a strikingly tremendous antithesis , also revealed

as the Father of Lies ! I trust the day is coming when his empire over the hearts of men hero will wither , and when truth shall , with the natives , be not merely a word but a quality , full of regenerative and salutary influences ; but , in the meantime , their laxity in this fundamental requisite of our institution offers a most serious obstacle to their admission into , or advancement iu , the

columns of Masonry . "Ton will readily understand how necessary it is to the keeping of a secret , that he to whom it is to be entrusted is a good man and true ! Am I not justified , in particularly putting you on your guard to seek beforehand , for satisfactory testimony that the native whom , you arc called upou to proposeor to recommend for

, Masonry , is under the tongue of good repute ? Ton are not , allow me to observe , my dear brethren , in this inquisition , to rest satisfied . with one native ' s report or recommendation of another native . " So and so is a very good man , " will one native testify for another , when a little more enquiry into details will show bow very widely you and he mny he at issuo concerning your mutual

notions of what constitutes a good man ! I am sorry to say , deeply sorry to declare , that , after all my experience of the natives of this country , it amounts , in the abstract , to this , that of all the natives whom I have ever known , two or three fingers would cover the names of those whom I could venture conscientiously to recommend for initiation into , or exaltation in , Masonry . "You cannot , then , I would again and again impress

it upon you ( and all over whom you have the influence in the Craft ) , in recommending or entertaining in lodges recommendations of natives for initiation into our Order , be too cautious iu making searching enquiry as to whether they are under the tongue of good repute or not , and while doing so , bear in mind that the standard of good repute is one thing with you , and another with

them , and that the safest plan is to consider your own minimum , of what you understand by moral goodness and good repute as their average maximum . In this way you may reach a practical average that may render it sale for you to propose or second natives for initiation . "But there is another point of view , which I have reserved any allusion to . I regard its affecting our columns

as a possibility , but nothing more . Nevertheless , the bare possibility of such a thing occurring renders it my duty to notice it . "A needy brother of base mind might , by a concurrence of circumstances , get into the chair of a fodge . To such a one natives of sufficient wealth , but otherwise wholly unworthymight address themselves covertl

, y , and enter into our venerable institution through the door of what I may be allowed to call Masonic simony . I cannot contemplate such a possibility without horror ; but I merely mention it to put you on your guard . Eoi-, thanks to the G . A . O . T . U ., I can say it with truth , and I feel proud to say it , that nothing of the sort has occurred while I have had the honour to holding the Provincial

Grand Hiram , and that I reckon it as one of the most fortunate circumstances of my life , that I am surrounded and supported by such an able , respectable , truly honourable , ancl honest body of worthy and true men . " " We do not think this article would be complete if wc did not joublisk the declaration made by Baboo Khettermohun Gangooly , previous to his initiation in Lodge Saint John .

" ' I am not a Pantheist or a Polytheist . I do not indentify my Creator with any one of his creatures . I believe in the existence and superintendence of one G . A . O . T . U ., whose wish is the happiness of all his crea-

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1864-01-02, Page 11” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 16 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_02011864/page/11/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 2
THE FREEMASONS MAGAZINE. AND MASONIC MIRROR. Article 3
Untitled Article 5
MOTHER KILWINNING. Article 8
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 10
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 12
MASONIC POWERS. Article 12
LODGE OF EMERGENCY. Article 12
Untitled Article 12
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 13
METROPOLITAN. Article 13
PROVINCIAL. Article 15
ROYAL ARCH. Article 16
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR. Article 17
CHANNEL ISLANDS. Article 17
Obituary. Article 20
PUBLIC AMUSEMENTS. Article 21
THE WEEK. Article 22
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 22
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

6 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

3 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

3 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

2 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

2 Articles
Page 21

Page 21

1 Article
Page 22

Page 22

3 Articles
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Notes And Queries.

" Tho indiscriminate admission into the Order of any class or denomination of persons cannot fail to operate injuriously , and to bring discredit upon the Craft ; but this observation applies with equal force to the Christian portion of the woi-kl as to any other . The whole tenor of our laws , as well as of the ancient charges , is to guard against the initiation of individuals whose conduct , character , or education would not reflect credit on Masonry : and it is greatly to be regretted that these regulations are not sufficiently attended to .

" Opinion of Fr . Grant , Trot : G . M . of Bengal , " In regard to the admission of Hindoos and Mussulmans into Masonry , as authorised in the communication just read from His Eoyal Highness the Grand Master of all England and its territories , I feel it to bo my duty to say a few words , in order to inculcate the greatest caution among all members of the Craft , as to the persons

belonging to the two great classes of natives of India proper to be recommended for initiation into our Order . " You are well aware , my brethren , that when a highly distinguished and respectable Hindoo was proposed for initiation by a member of one of our Calcutta lodges , an insuperable difficulty presented itself in the question of how he was to be obligated ? This was more especiall

y the case as he was understood to live at variance with many of the rules of the caste . How are wo also to reconcile a belief , in its full aud sufficient integrity , in tho G . A . O . T . U . with a system of gross idolatry , or a state of morals hinging mainly upon external observances ? Mussulmans have the Koran , and upon that book they may be obligated .

" As respects Hindoos again , supposing that candidates may satisfy us concerning a true belief in the Almighty Architect of the Universe and a future state of responsibility and rewards and punishments , upon what are we to obligate them ? The Teds , the Piirans , or their Commentaries ? Aud how are wo to reconcile certain anomalies with the calls and duties of Masonryand to arrive

, at a sufficient knowledge of the moral worth of those whom they affect , previous to recommending them for the fellowship and privileges and mysteries of tho Craft ? " As respects the question of moral character , there is

not , among ourselves , or Europeans in general in this country , a man whose conduct and habits of life are not known to his neighbours , and not one upon whom there is not a moral check through that chain of electric sympathy that binds our institutions and connects every man as a link to his follow , on the basis of a wholly domestic system that has stood the tost of ages , and a

common philanthropy utterly alien , as far as we are aware , to the systems of caste and polygamy . The consequence is , that moral flagrancy , or conduct palpably at issue with the moral sense , instantly thrills through all the links of our social chain . " What a mighty engine of moral influence and control have we here !

" Turn we now to the natives : what do we know of their conduct as moral agents , or of their social sympathies P Almost nothing ! Shut up as they are beyond our reach by a strict and impenetrable circle of exclusion and the darkest privacy , what can we know of their family aud domestic traits , thoughts , principles , and acts , or of their virtues and vices behind this iron

curtain . Of the tendencies of such a system , and some of the revolting anomalies which it gives rise to and fosters as in a hotbed , I need say nothing , for the results and effects are familiar to tho most superficial observers . " I am grieved to confess it , but still , after a residence of twenty-six years in this country , I am entitled to express an opinion upon a matter of such importance to

our ancient and honourable institution . Ancl is not the general disregard of the natives for truth so notorious , that while wc grieve at it , we cannot , at the same time , deny the fact ? Hero is an awful difficulty that meets us at tho very threshold of the question .

" Truth is the very rock upou which all moral principle and social security are founded . He whose name aud attributes are revealed in this blessed book open before me , has , as one of his most distinguishing titles , the name of the God of Truth . Our great adversary again , that mysterious being who is emphatically the Evil One , is , by a strikingly tremendous antithesis , also revealed

as the Father of Lies ! I trust the day is coming when his empire over the hearts of men hero will wither , and when truth shall , with the natives , be not merely a word but a quality , full of regenerative and salutary influences ; but , in the meantime , their laxity in this fundamental requisite of our institution offers a most serious obstacle to their admission into , or advancement iu , the

columns of Masonry . "Ton will readily understand how necessary it is to the keeping of a secret , that he to whom it is to be entrusted is a good man and true ! Am I not justified , in particularly putting you on your guard to seek beforehand , for satisfactory testimony that the native whom , you arc called upou to proposeor to recommend for

, Masonry , is under the tongue of good repute ? Ton are not , allow me to observe , my dear brethren , in this inquisition , to rest satisfied . with one native ' s report or recommendation of another native . " So and so is a very good man , " will one native testify for another , when a little more enquiry into details will show bow very widely you and he mny he at issuo concerning your mutual

notions of what constitutes a good man ! I am sorry to say , deeply sorry to declare , that , after all my experience of the natives of this country , it amounts , in the abstract , to this , that of all the natives whom I have ever known , two or three fingers would cover the names of those whom I could venture conscientiously to recommend for initiation into , or exaltation in , Masonry . "You cannot , then , I would again and again impress

it upon you ( and all over whom you have the influence in the Craft ) , in recommending or entertaining in lodges recommendations of natives for initiation into our Order , be too cautious iu making searching enquiry as to whether they are under the tongue of good repute or not , and while doing so , bear in mind that the standard of good repute is one thing with you , and another with

them , and that the safest plan is to consider your own minimum , of what you understand by moral goodness and good repute as their average maximum . In this way you may reach a practical average that may render it sale for you to propose or second natives for initiation . "But there is another point of view , which I have reserved any allusion to . I regard its affecting our columns

as a possibility , but nothing more . Nevertheless , the bare possibility of such a thing occurring renders it my duty to notice it . "A needy brother of base mind might , by a concurrence of circumstances , get into the chair of a fodge . To such a one natives of sufficient wealth , but otherwise wholly unworthymight address themselves covertl

, y , and enter into our venerable institution through the door of what I may be allowed to call Masonic simony . I cannot contemplate such a possibility without horror ; but I merely mention it to put you on your guard . Eoi-, thanks to the G . A . O . T . U ., I can say it with truth , and I feel proud to say it , that nothing of the sort has occurred while I have had the honour to holding the Provincial

Grand Hiram , and that I reckon it as one of the most fortunate circumstances of my life , that I am surrounded and supported by such an able , respectable , truly honourable , ancl honest body of worthy and true men . " " We do not think this article would be complete if wc did not joublisk the declaration made by Baboo Khettermohun Gangooly , previous to his initiation in Lodge Saint John .

" ' I am not a Pantheist or a Polytheist . I do not indentify my Creator with any one of his creatures . I believe in the existence and superintendence of one G . A . O . T . U ., whose wish is the happiness of all his crea-

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 10
  • You're on page11
  • 12
  • 22
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy