Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Masonic Magazine
  • April 1, 1874
  • Page 23
Current:

The Masonic Magazine, April 1, 1874: Page 23

  • Back to The Masonic Magazine, April 1, 1874
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article Reviews. ← Page 2 of 3 →
Page 23

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Reviews.

( blank Averse , by the way , ) the dawn of a better and brighter day on this heavy and suffering world of ours . There are passages of considerable force and beauty in the long continued rolls of his poetic lucubration through ten books , but we fear that ,

to use a cant word just now , the poem is hardl y " realistic " enough for a large class of readers . Still wc gladly welcome this " waif" sent to our shores from the far Antipodes , although Ave are not " Millennarians" and find

, 10 , 000 lines rather a tough morsel to digest and to reA'ieAv . AVe admire always the efforts of poetic genius , and consider them " a good thing" for the world and for society .

Ireland Ur of the Chaldees . By Anna AVilkes . Trubner and Co . AVe confess to have boon greatly startled by this suggestion of the fair writer ! In fact , Ave felt at once that Ave wore like Paddy , Avhen his misthress introduced to his notice some one of those happy little

machines for domestic use , whether for churning in the dairy , or for cleaning knives in the pantry , unknoAvii in that good country of potatoes and buttermilk "Bedad , " says he , scratching his head , " Madam , it ' s mighty strange , and it

bothers me eomplately . " After all our exploration of the " Orient Clime , " after the diggings of Mr . Layard , and the labours of Sir H . Eawlinson , to be told that Ireland is Ur of the Chaldees , and that this is to bo proved by a AVOIIprintcd book of 207 close pages , is enough

to take aAvay one ' s breath . But AA'hcti AVO see how ethnology and philology , and more than one other " ology" is pressed very skilfully into Miss Wilkes ' s service ( it may be by the poAver of attraction ) , to support her theories , and enforce her argumentsone can only shake one ' s headand

, , rub one ' s eyes , like the dreamer aAvakened out of his long and fairy sleep . AVe regret to say that Ave cannot concur , on any single ground , with the fair expositrix of ancient names and geographical arrangements . There is a great deal ol

very loose and weak , and therefore mischieA r ous philology afloat at the present day , and AVO fear that M iss AVilkes has been lured by the Will-o ' -AVisp of fancied similarity and derivation , by a vivid imagination , and a considerable " copia verborum , " to propound what is in sober honesty

utterly untenable , and Ave feel Ave must say , puerile . The effect of her explanation would be , to reduce the Bible from an undoubted record of events , the * correctness of which record modern discoveries have most wonderfully demonstrated to the utter

discomfiture of the sceptical school , to a mere collection of mythical rhapsodies ; and Ave oaiinot for one moment accept either Miss AVilkes ' s views , or even her skilful manipulation of historical facts and geographical divisionsand philological

de-, rivations , by which she seeks to give consistency to her very deftly raised , but very fragile " castle in the air . " Ur of tho Chaldees , wherever exactly that spot may

bo , is far away from the Irish Channel ; and the " Green Isle , " the " Terne " of old Minstrel song , is still as ever , and ever Avill remain , in herself and by herself , simply " Ireland ; " " ould Ireland , " if you like . No one Avho has seen her green hills ,

and laughed with her lvarm-hearted people , but Avill always wish her well , but to make her anything else but Ireland would bo " Avrong if possible , and if possible wrong . " Paddy Avould probably stare , if he was told that his country Avas Ur of the Chaldees ,

and not Ireland , and though a lady is always treated very civilly in Ireland , ho would be a very bold man who would take aAvay the " old name" of their country from the Irish people . The Treasury of Language * . A Eudhnentary Dictionary of Universal Philology . —Hall and Co .

Wo have been much pleased witluthis simple and unpretending but very useful little work . The science of Philology has been making vast strides amongst us these last feAv years , and since the publication of Cardinal AViseman ' s admirable work

, the "Connection of scioi-cc Avith revealed religion , " many steps -have been taken in advance . It seems that there are , Avith root languages , and doriv d languages , and " patois " languages , and corrupted languages with languages proper , and

sub-divisions or dialects of the same , little * hort of 3 , 000 knoAvn forms in the world . Of course many of these are practically dead languages , but they have to be considered in a treatise on Philology . It seems impossible to lay doAvn any correct estimate of tho speaking languages of the world , not only so—as opinions may differ on the

“The Masonic Magazine: 1874-04-01, Page 23” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 24 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmg/issues/mmg_01041874/page/23/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Monthly Masonic Summary. Article 1
ANCIENT MASONIC LODGES, No. 3. Article 2
UN SOUVENIR DU PASSE. Article 4
ROOKSTONE PRIORY. Article 5
MEMORIAL ADDRESS Article 8
ST. VALENTINE'S DAY. Article 12
ON CHANGE TOUJOURS ICI. Article 13
Cleanings form Old Documents. Article 14
THE MASON'S ORPHAN DAUGHTER. Article 15
IF WE WOULD. Article 17
EARLY HISTORY OF FREEMASONRY IN AMERICA. Article 18
DOWN INTO THE DUST . Article 22
Reviews. Article 22
Our Archaeological Corner. Article 24
Correspondence. Article 25
THE GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND AND ITS MEMBERSHIP. Article 25
THE LEVEL AND THE SQUARE. Article 26
THE MUSICAL RITUAL. Article 27
A WARNING FROM AMERICA-AN IMPOSTOR. Article 29
MASONIC DRONES. Article 30
FREEMASONRY DEFENDED. Article 30
Monthly Odds and Ends. Article 32
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

2 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

2 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

3 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

1 Article
Page 21

Page 21

1 Article
Page 22

Page 22

3 Articles
Page 23

Page 23

1 Article
Page 24

Page 24

3 Articles
Page 25

Page 25

3 Articles
Page 26

Page 26

2 Articles
Page 27

Page 27

1 Article
Page 28

Page 28

1 Article
Page 29

Page 29

3 Articles
Page 30

Page 30

3 Articles
Page 31

Page 31

1 Article
Page 32

Page 32

2 Articles
Page 23

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Reviews.

( blank Averse , by the way , ) the dawn of a better and brighter day on this heavy and suffering world of ours . There are passages of considerable force and beauty in the long continued rolls of his poetic lucubration through ten books , but we fear that ,

to use a cant word just now , the poem is hardl y " realistic " enough for a large class of readers . Still wc gladly welcome this " waif" sent to our shores from the far Antipodes , although Ave are not " Millennarians" and find

, 10 , 000 lines rather a tough morsel to digest and to reA'ieAv . AVe admire always the efforts of poetic genius , and consider them " a good thing" for the world and for society .

Ireland Ur of the Chaldees . By Anna AVilkes . Trubner and Co . AVe confess to have boon greatly startled by this suggestion of the fair writer ! In fact , Ave felt at once that Ave wore like Paddy , Avhen his misthress introduced to his notice some one of those happy little

machines for domestic use , whether for churning in the dairy , or for cleaning knives in the pantry , unknoAvii in that good country of potatoes and buttermilk "Bedad , " says he , scratching his head , " Madam , it ' s mighty strange , and it

bothers me eomplately . " After all our exploration of the " Orient Clime , " after the diggings of Mr . Layard , and the labours of Sir H . Eawlinson , to be told that Ireland is Ur of the Chaldees , and that this is to bo proved by a AVOIIprintcd book of 207 close pages , is enough

to take aAvay one ' s breath . But AA'hcti AVO see how ethnology and philology , and more than one other " ology" is pressed very skilfully into Miss Wilkes ' s service ( it may be by the poAver of attraction ) , to support her theories , and enforce her argumentsone can only shake one ' s headand

, , rub one ' s eyes , like the dreamer aAvakened out of his long and fairy sleep . AVe regret to say that Ave cannot concur , on any single ground , with the fair expositrix of ancient names and geographical arrangements . There is a great deal ol

very loose and weak , and therefore mischieA r ous philology afloat at the present day , and AVO fear that M iss AVilkes has been lured by the Will-o ' -AVisp of fancied similarity and derivation , by a vivid imagination , and a considerable " copia verborum , " to propound what is in sober honesty

utterly untenable , and Ave feel Ave must say , puerile . The effect of her explanation would be , to reduce the Bible from an undoubted record of events , the * correctness of which record modern discoveries have most wonderfully demonstrated to the utter

discomfiture of the sceptical school , to a mere collection of mythical rhapsodies ; and Ave oaiinot for one moment accept either Miss AVilkes ' s views , or even her skilful manipulation of historical facts and geographical divisionsand philological

de-, rivations , by which she seeks to give consistency to her very deftly raised , but very fragile " castle in the air . " Ur of tho Chaldees , wherever exactly that spot may

bo , is far away from the Irish Channel ; and the " Green Isle , " the " Terne " of old Minstrel song , is still as ever , and ever Avill remain , in herself and by herself , simply " Ireland ; " " ould Ireland , " if you like . No one Avho has seen her green hills ,

and laughed with her lvarm-hearted people , but Avill always wish her well , but to make her anything else but Ireland would bo " Avrong if possible , and if possible wrong . " Paddy Avould probably stare , if he was told that his country Avas Ur of the Chaldees ,

and not Ireland , and though a lady is always treated very civilly in Ireland , ho would be a very bold man who would take aAvay the " old name" of their country from the Irish people . The Treasury of Language * . A Eudhnentary Dictionary of Universal Philology . —Hall and Co .

Wo have been much pleased witluthis simple and unpretending but very useful little work . The science of Philology has been making vast strides amongst us these last feAv years , and since the publication of Cardinal AViseman ' s admirable work

, the "Connection of scioi-cc Avith revealed religion , " many steps -have been taken in advance . It seems that there are , Avith root languages , and doriv d languages , and " patois " languages , and corrupted languages with languages proper , and

sub-divisions or dialects of the same , little * hort of 3 , 000 knoAvn forms in the world . Of course many of these are practically dead languages , but they have to be considered in a treatise on Philology . It seems impossible to lay doAvn any correct estimate of tho speaking languages of the world , not only so—as opinions may differ on the

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 22
  • You're on page23
  • 24
  • 32
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy