Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Masonic Illustrated
  • June 1, 1906
  • Page 9
  • The Problem of the Degrees.
Current:

The Masonic Illustrated, June 1, 1906: Page 9

  • Back to The Masonic Illustrated, June 1, 1906
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article Order of the Temple. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article The Problem of the Degrees. Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Order Of The Temple.

The Most Eminent and Supreme Grand Alaster replied , expressing his pleasure in being present to consecrate this new Preceptory , in which he would always take a « reat interest . He urged the paramount importance of exercisin " the utmost care in the selection of those whom in the future

they might admit to membership , pointing out that a single unsuitable member might introduce a discordant element which would render harmonious work an impossibility . He expressed his pleasure that their choice of their first Preceptor had fallen on a Knight whose devotion to and

enthusiasm for the Order were so well known as was the case with E . Knight Palmer-Thomas , and concluded by wishing every success to the Sancta Maria Preceptory , coupling with the toast the name of the Eminent Preceptor . E . Knight Palmer-Thomas responded , thanking the Grand

Alaster on behalf of the Sancta Alaria Preceptory for his kind expressions and good wishes , and also for his advice , which would be carefully borne in mind and acted on . They were delighted to welcome the Great Officers , among whom were some particularly well known to them . He especially desired

to express his obligations to the Great Vice-Chancellor , the V . E . Knight C . F . Alatier , for the kind assistance he had so willingly rendered towards the establishment of the Preceptory , and he was also glad to have this opportunity of thanking the V . E . Knight for help readily and courteously

given to him personally on many occasions in the past . The E . Preceptor concluded by assuring the Grand Master that no effort would be wanting on the part of himself , his officers , or the Knights under his command to make the Sancta Maria Preceptory a success and a credit to the Order .

The Problem Of The Degrees.

The Problem of the Degrees .

BY ROIIERT FREKE GOULD , P . G . D ,

THERE are tw * o dates , which if carefully borne in mind , will materially assist in solving what is often described as the problem of the degrees . The first is 1723 and the second is 1738 , and the space they comprise in the History of our Society , has been termed the period of transition . At the earlier date two , and at the later date three

degrees ( or Steps in Masonry ) were worked with the sanction of the premier Grand Lodge . Masters ( or Fellow Crafts ) and Apprentices are mentioned in the Constitutions of 1723 ; and Alaster Alasons , Fellow Crafts , and Apprentices in the Constitution of 173 8 .

The first " Book of Constitutions " ( 1723 ) appeared six years after the formation of the " Mother of Grand Lodges " in 1717 . It may be safely regarded , therefore , as pointing not only to the number of degrees authorised by the Grand Lodge in 1723 , but as plainly indicating that the same

number and no less were also worked in the twilight of Speculative Masonry which immediately preceded the erection of a governing body of Symbolic Freemasonry in 1717 . In other words , it shows us that a system of two degrees had existed before the era of Grand Lodges , and continued to exist in 1723 .

This point , however , though now well settled , was a long debatable one , owing to a misreading of the evidence , as the terms " Alaster and Fellow Craft" which occur in the Constitutions of 1723 ( " Old Regulation XIII . " ) were extensively believed , on the publication of that book , to import the existence of / -co degrees superior to that of Apprentice . The

delusion spread and gradually worked out its own fulfilment , of which there is distinct proof in the Minutes of a Musical Society at London in 1725 , the famous speech of the Junior Grand Warden of York ( Francis Drake ) in 1726 ; the curious pamphlet of Samuel Pritchard in 1730 and the Irish

Consti-, tutions of John Pennell which were printed during the same year . Down to 1730 , however , the system of two degrees approved and recognised by the Grand Lodge in 1723 held its ground in the Lodges . But after that date there is evidence to show that the ambiguous language of Dr .

Anderson in the Constitutions of 1723 ( O . R . XIII . ) had been interpreted in a wrong sense , and the delusion rapidly attained such currency , that it was adopted and recognised by the Grand Lodge as being the true reading of the ancient text , in the Constitutions of 1738 .

About the middle of the iSth century there was a great schism , and the multiplication of spurious Rituals was the results . The ritual-mongers , indeed , knew little or nothing of the genuine secrects of the Craft , but they passed on to later generations the spurious tradition of three degrees ( and not I ' IVO only ) having been known and recognised by the

Grand Lodge of England in 1723 . Laurence Dermott and William Preston fully credited this " Spurious Tradition " and both the Aliiman Rezon of the one , and the " Illustrations " of the other are tinctured by this strangely-conceived superstition .

Even the critical Dr . Kloss was unable to detect the real meaning of " Old Regulation " XIII . ( 1723 ) , and so were Findel and Alackey , the last named of whom I mention with great respect , as there is probably no Alasonic writer of the century that has just passed away , who would , had his life

been prolonged , have used to greater advantage the important discoveries that have been made since his decease . The real number of degrees worked by the English Lodges in 1723 was lirst made known in the second volume of my original History of Freemasonry , published in 1885 , and

after running the gauntlet of much fraternal criticism , the interpretation which I ventured to pronounce upon the wording of " Old Regulation " XIII . ( 1723 ) , in that year , has been approved and adopted by all scholars of the Craft both in the Old World and the New .

It has taken indeed about twenty years to achieve this result , hence I cannot expect that a further inference which I drew ( in 1903 ) from the same premises ( to wit , the mistaken conclusions of the early commentators with respect to the Andersonian enigma of 1723 ) , will be accepted by any

considerable number of the literati ( leaving out of sight the illilerati ) of Freemasonry , until long after I have passed away to my rest . But in a parting word to the curious reader who maybe interested in the rise and progress of the so-called " Alasonic degrees " extraneous to those of the Ancient

Craft I recommend a glance at my Concise History of Freemasonry ( published by the Macoy Co ., of X ew York ) , and at the XVIth volume of the Transactions of the Quatuor Coronati Lodge—where my fuller views on the general subject of the " Scots " Degrees ( supplementary to those expressed in the Concise History ) are contained . Masonic Tidings , WISCONSIN , U . S . A .

Ar00902

At New York , recently , Thomas Aletelski was sentenced to imprisonment for forty months for burglary at Brooklyn . Interest in the case was caused by the introduction of Alasonic sentiment into the defence , and Aletelski became known as the Masonic burglar . The evidence shewed that when the proprietor of the house in Brooklyn woke up he found Metelski examining a Masonic emblem , and he explained

that he had come to rob the house , but could not do so now that he had found the owner to be a brother Mason . The burglar then let himself out of the house , but the owner gave a description to the police which led to the arrest of Metelski . Aletelski said he had trusted to the good faith of his intended victim as a Mason to refraim from further action .

“The Masonic Illustrated: 1906-06-01, Page 9” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 15 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mil/issues/mil_01061906/page/9/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
United Grand Lodge. Article 2
The New Grand Officers. Article 3
Royal Masonic Institution for Boys. Article 5
Kingsway Lodge, No. 3027. Article 7
Order of the Temple. Article 8
The Problem of the Degrees. Article 9
Untitled Article 9
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
A Masonic Library. Article 10
At the Sign of the Perfect Ashlar. Article 11
Untitled Ad 13
Scottish Freemasonry in Western Australia. Article 14
Provincial Grand Lodge of West Lancashire. Article 15
"Old City Taverns and Miasonry." Article 15
Fubilee Masters' Lodge, No. 2712—Ladies' Night. Article 16
History of the Lodge of Emulation , No. 21. Article 17
Untitled Ad 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

2 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

2 Articles
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Order Of The Temple.

The Most Eminent and Supreme Grand Alaster replied , expressing his pleasure in being present to consecrate this new Preceptory , in which he would always take a « reat interest . He urged the paramount importance of exercisin " the utmost care in the selection of those whom in the future

they might admit to membership , pointing out that a single unsuitable member might introduce a discordant element which would render harmonious work an impossibility . He expressed his pleasure that their choice of their first Preceptor had fallen on a Knight whose devotion to and

enthusiasm for the Order were so well known as was the case with E . Knight Palmer-Thomas , and concluded by wishing every success to the Sancta Maria Preceptory , coupling with the toast the name of the Eminent Preceptor . E . Knight Palmer-Thomas responded , thanking the Grand

Alaster on behalf of the Sancta Alaria Preceptory for his kind expressions and good wishes , and also for his advice , which would be carefully borne in mind and acted on . They were delighted to welcome the Great Officers , among whom were some particularly well known to them . He especially desired

to express his obligations to the Great Vice-Chancellor , the V . E . Knight C . F . Alatier , for the kind assistance he had so willingly rendered towards the establishment of the Preceptory , and he was also glad to have this opportunity of thanking the V . E . Knight for help readily and courteously

given to him personally on many occasions in the past . The E . Preceptor concluded by assuring the Grand Master that no effort would be wanting on the part of himself , his officers , or the Knights under his command to make the Sancta Maria Preceptory a success and a credit to the Order .

The Problem Of The Degrees.

The Problem of the Degrees .

BY ROIIERT FREKE GOULD , P . G . D ,

THERE are tw * o dates , which if carefully borne in mind , will materially assist in solving what is often described as the problem of the degrees . The first is 1723 and the second is 1738 , and the space they comprise in the History of our Society , has been termed the period of transition . At the earlier date two , and at the later date three

degrees ( or Steps in Masonry ) were worked with the sanction of the premier Grand Lodge . Masters ( or Fellow Crafts ) and Apprentices are mentioned in the Constitutions of 1723 ; and Alaster Alasons , Fellow Crafts , and Apprentices in the Constitution of 173 8 .

The first " Book of Constitutions " ( 1723 ) appeared six years after the formation of the " Mother of Grand Lodges " in 1717 . It may be safely regarded , therefore , as pointing not only to the number of degrees authorised by the Grand Lodge in 1723 , but as plainly indicating that the same

number and no less were also worked in the twilight of Speculative Masonry which immediately preceded the erection of a governing body of Symbolic Freemasonry in 1717 . In other words , it shows us that a system of two degrees had existed before the era of Grand Lodges , and continued to exist in 1723 .

This point , however , though now well settled , was a long debatable one , owing to a misreading of the evidence , as the terms " Alaster and Fellow Craft" which occur in the Constitutions of 1723 ( " Old Regulation XIII . " ) were extensively believed , on the publication of that book , to import the existence of / -co degrees superior to that of Apprentice . The

delusion spread and gradually worked out its own fulfilment , of which there is distinct proof in the Minutes of a Musical Society at London in 1725 , the famous speech of the Junior Grand Warden of York ( Francis Drake ) in 1726 ; the curious pamphlet of Samuel Pritchard in 1730 and the Irish

Consti-, tutions of John Pennell which were printed during the same year . Down to 1730 , however , the system of two degrees approved and recognised by the Grand Lodge in 1723 held its ground in the Lodges . But after that date there is evidence to show that the ambiguous language of Dr .

Anderson in the Constitutions of 1723 ( O . R . XIII . ) had been interpreted in a wrong sense , and the delusion rapidly attained such currency , that it was adopted and recognised by the Grand Lodge as being the true reading of the ancient text , in the Constitutions of 1738 .

About the middle of the iSth century there was a great schism , and the multiplication of spurious Rituals was the results . The ritual-mongers , indeed , knew little or nothing of the genuine secrects of the Craft , but they passed on to later generations the spurious tradition of three degrees ( and not I ' IVO only ) having been known and recognised by the

Grand Lodge of England in 1723 . Laurence Dermott and William Preston fully credited this " Spurious Tradition " and both the Aliiman Rezon of the one , and the " Illustrations " of the other are tinctured by this strangely-conceived superstition .

Even the critical Dr . Kloss was unable to detect the real meaning of " Old Regulation " XIII . ( 1723 ) , and so were Findel and Alackey , the last named of whom I mention with great respect , as there is probably no Alasonic writer of the century that has just passed away , who would , had his life

been prolonged , have used to greater advantage the important discoveries that have been made since his decease . The real number of degrees worked by the English Lodges in 1723 was lirst made known in the second volume of my original History of Freemasonry , published in 1885 , and

after running the gauntlet of much fraternal criticism , the interpretation which I ventured to pronounce upon the wording of " Old Regulation " XIII . ( 1723 ) , in that year , has been approved and adopted by all scholars of the Craft both in the Old World and the New .

It has taken indeed about twenty years to achieve this result , hence I cannot expect that a further inference which I drew ( in 1903 ) from the same premises ( to wit , the mistaken conclusions of the early commentators with respect to the Andersonian enigma of 1723 ) , will be accepted by any

considerable number of the literati ( leaving out of sight the illilerati ) of Freemasonry , until long after I have passed away to my rest . But in a parting word to the curious reader who maybe interested in the rise and progress of the so-called " Alasonic degrees " extraneous to those of the Ancient

Craft I recommend a glance at my Concise History of Freemasonry ( published by the Macoy Co ., of X ew York ) , and at the XVIth volume of the Transactions of the Quatuor Coronati Lodge—where my fuller views on the general subject of the " Scots " Degrees ( supplementary to those expressed in the Concise History ) are contained . Masonic Tidings , WISCONSIN , U . S . A .

Ar00902

At New York , recently , Thomas Aletelski was sentenced to imprisonment for forty months for burglary at Brooklyn . Interest in the case was caused by the introduction of Alasonic sentiment into the defence , and Aletelski became known as the Masonic burglar . The evidence shewed that when the proprietor of the house in Brooklyn woke up he found Metelski examining a Masonic emblem , and he explained

that he had come to rob the house , but could not do so now that he had found the owner to be a brother Mason . The burglar then let himself out of the house , but the owner gave a description to the police which led to the arrest of Metelski . Aletelski said he had trusted to the good faith of his intended victim as a Mason to refraim from further action .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 8
  • You're on page9
  • 10
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy