Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • June 4, 1881
  • Page 6
Current:

The Freemason, June 4, 1881: Page 6

  • Back to The Freemason, June 4, 1881
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article GRAND LODGE OF MARK MASTERS. ← Page 3 of 3
    Article ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR GIRLS. Page 1 of 1
    Article MASONIC HISTORY AND HISTORIANS. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Grand Lodge Of Mark Masters.

Grand Lodge was then closed , and the brethren adjourned to a superb banquet . After dinner the toasts were proposed . Lord HENNIKER , in proposing the first toast of the evening , " The Queen and Mark Masonry , " referred to the fact that three of Her Majesty ' s sons were already distinguished Masons , and that it had that day been made known that another son , the Duke of Albany , was made a Past . Grand Master of the Order .

Earl of LATHOM : I rise to propose the next toast to you , but before doing so I hope you will allow me to make a very few observations . Our Grand Master has shown me an excellent example of being brief in the toast he has just proposed . You also know well that I am never long , but there are some among you who have met with me in Warwickshire , where , I regret to say , I departed from my usual custom of brevity . The matter ,

however , was taken up with such effect b y my hearers that I cannot but say that I thank those brethren who took up and acted on the words I spoke on that occasion . Mark Masonry , during the time I have had the pleasure lo rule over you , has prospered ; during the past three years seventy-two new Mark lodges have been consecrated , which is double the rate of increase of

former periods , and , in proposing " The Health of my Successor , Lord Henniker , " I cannot do better than express my hope that he ma ) ' find at the end of a similar period that instead of seventy-two , a hundred and fortyfour new lodges have been added to the roll . Trusting that he may have a prosperous term of office , I now ask you to drink his very good health .

LORD HENNIKER : I thank my respected and worshipful friend , the Past Grand Master , for the kind manner in which he has proposed this toast , and I thank you for the cordial and kind way in which you have replied . I appreciate your kindness , and I appreciate it in this way—for your feeling towards your Past Grand Master , who has proposed this toast , for his past services to you , and for your promise to support me in the task I have

undertaken . I shall not easily forget this occasion . I shall remember il as not only the occasion of a great pleasure , in having been so cordiall y received , but also as a rather conspicuous occasion in Mark Masonry ; and I am fortunate that my day of installation is what Bro . Binckes has called the silver wedding of Mark Masonry . Among men and women who have passed periods of five and twenty years together in social happiness and

social usefulness the silver wedding mark . ' ; that they possess in a great degree , in a marked degree , the social quality , the quality we most admire in Mark Masonry . I think , brethren , that this Grand Mark Lodge may possess something of these qualities . You have heard what your late Master has said about the increase of Mark Masonry during his year of office . This is a matter of pleasure and satisfaction , for we must have a

feeling of triumph at the success of the Order . I was talking to my friend , Bro . Sandenian , from my own piovince , and he was telling me lhat when he was made a Mark Master he was one of the first of those who had joined Lodge No . 7 . That is eighteen years ago , and now we have thirty-one provinces , 290 lodges , and 15 , 000 members r and , as your Past Grand Master has told you , not only have we increased enormous ) ) ' lately , but we arc increasing more rapidly now than we have ever increased before . It is

something to say , and something for me to think of , that you have placed me oyer this large portion of the Craft . What I can say , brethren , is this , that I will do my very best to preside over you in a manner which may be satisfactory to you during my term of office , and I only hope that I may be so successful that the good wish of your Immediate Past Grand Master , that his number of new lodges may be doubled during my term , may come true . All I can say is to repeat that I will do my best to arrive at that result , and your kindness to-night enco urages me to the task .

Bro . BROADLEY : It is the twenty-fifth anniversary of this Grand Lodge , and I may be pardoned if I say that the toast of "The M . W . Past Grand Mark Master Masons " is almost the toast of the evening , and we have to congratulate the Grand Mark Lodge of England that it has become what it is to-day . 1 rise to propose " The Health of the Past Grand Masters of the Order , " a list of eight , beginning with Lord Leigh and ending with ( he Earl of Lathom , who have as Grand Mark Masters devoted their time to the

interests of the Order . We have had a great gathering this evening and have many distinguished brethren amongst us , not only from all parts of the country but also from a foreign country , which 1 am sorry to say is politically under a cloud at present , but where I can tell you the Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons of England will never be forgotten . It is my privilege to propose "The Health of the M . W . Past Grand Masters , " coupling therewith the names of Bro . W . W . B . Beach , M . P ., and Bro . the Rev . Raymond Portal .

Bro . PORTAL : I feel it is a proud position to have to return thanks for a body of Masons composed of such illustrious names as stand on the roll of the Past Grand Masters of this Grand Lodge , and to have assisted one whose rule has been confessedly most able and deservedl y most popular .

Rome was not built in a day ; Sir Christopher Wren lived to see the completion of his work ; but we shall not live to see the completion of ours , though we have had the satisfaction to see the vast progress it has made . In linies past we have endeavoured to do our best for the Order , and we shall continue to do what we can lo conduce to its success .

Bro . W . W . B . BEACH , M . P ., also responded to the toast . Bro . Sir E . LECHMERE , Bart ., proposed "The Health of the R . W . D . Grand Master , and the Grand Officers , Past and Present . " Bro . Lord KINTORE said it was with no ordinary feelings that he , a Scotch Mason , had assisted there that night , and listened to the toast in which he was concerned . He spoke of the coldness with which Mark

Masonry was , only a few years since , looked upon by the Grand Lodge of England , and contrasted it with the more cordial fcelings-that now prevailed . He hoped the good feeling would goon increasing ; that the English and Scotch Masons would work together , and draw the bonds of brotherhood closer . This had been a very great day for them all , and he felt that all their efforts in the past had been amply rewarded by that day ' s success .

The toast " Success to the Mark Benevolent Fund " was proposed by Bro . BEACH , and responded to by Bro . MATIER , who spoke in so low a tone that only disjointed fragments of sentences reached our reporter . " The Health of the Ladies " concluded the list of toasts ; and Bro . BINCKES , who had been all the evening assisting in entertaining the fair visitors , was summoned from the other room to reply to the toast , " which he did with his customary genial exuberance of language .

The musical arrangements were under the direction of Bro . Edwin M . Lotc , P . G . Mark Organist , assisted b y Madame Thaddetis Wells , Miss Hebe Barlow , Miss Mary Morton , Bro . John Stcdman , Bio . E gbert Roberts , Bro . Schuberth , and Bro . Stedman ' s choir boys .

Royal Masonic Institution For Girls.

ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR GIRLS .

We arc pleased now to be able to give a detailed list of the contributions from the Province of Gloucestershire announced at the festival . Bro . Henry Godfrey , J . P ., who now serves his third Stewardship with an aggregate amount of . £ 446 , nobly heads the list with £ -2 iS 8 s ., followed b y Bro . Clement Tudway with £ ISI 13 s ., and Bro . J . Brooksmith with £ " 142 14 s . To Bro . Col . H . G . Basevi , although the modest sum of £ 30 9 s . only appears against his name , a great portion of the success achieved by the province is due , and we congratulate him and the Province of Gloucestershire on the splendid result of their efforts .

Lodge . £ s . d . Lodge . £ s . d . S 2 Bro . Col . I-I . G . Basevi ... 30 9 o 493 Bro . G . W . Haines ... 43 1 o S 2 „ Baron de Ferrieres , 493 „ A . V . Hatton ... 10 10 o M . P . 10 10 o 493 „ Samuel Moss ... 10 10 o S 2 „ Henry Godfrey , J . P . 21 S S o 493 „ R . A . Matthews ... 550 S 2 „ Ernest W . Godfrey ... 10 io o 592 „ John Mullings ... to 10 o S 2 „ W . H . Gurnett ... G 3 o o 592 „ Clement Tudway ... 1 S 1 13 o Chapter . S 39 „ ] ames Bruton ... 10 10 o

S 2 Comp . J . Brooksmith , S 39 „ John Bryan 10 10 o D . P . G . M 142 14 o S 39 „ li . Vassar Smith ... 96 1 o S 2 „ W . Forth 27 0 o S 39 „ Robert W . White ... 15 15 o S 2 „ W . R . Porcher ... 15 15 o 900 „ Edward J . Gregory ... 22 1 o Lodge . 10 G 7 „ W . C . Heane ... n 11 o 24 G Bro . Edwin Lawrence ... 26 5 o 7067 „ Cranstoun Kerr ... 16 16 o 24 G „ George Norman ... 10 10 o Total £ 1000 o o

Masonic History And Historians.

MASONIC HISTORY AND HISTORIANS .

BY MASONIC STUDENT . As an illustration of the real difficulty of Masonic history still , I take up a contribution to it in 1 SS 1 lrom a new Body at the Antipodes , calling itself the Grand Lodge of New South Wales . In its proceedings at p . 25 occurs the following passage , which is a "gem " in its way .

"Now let us see how the Grand Lodge of England was established . It was not established in thc _ same regular and cons : itutional manner that the Grand Lodge of Canada was , nor is there any analogy between their proceedings and ours . We have chosen to follow the good example of our Canadian brethren , and we have not seccdeel as the four London Lodges did from the Grand Lodge of York . At the time of this

secession we find that there was the Grand Lodge of England established in the year 92 G at York , and having at that time jurisdiction over thirty-two daughter lodges . Notwithstanding that there was a Grand Lodge of England , we lind thai ; the Masonic Body in the south of England or London , then numbering four lodges , formed themselves into a Grand Lodge in the \ ear 1717 . "

There are , perhaps , in this one passage more errors than one could think possible to be found in a Masonic historical statement of 18 S 1 , and which will startle Bro . Hughan , as they have startled me , inasmuch as they seem to set at defiance all the careful researches and competent criticisms of these later days . Let us take the statement in its details .

1 . The declaration that in 1717 the Grand Lodge of York , established in 926 , was in full jurisdiction at York over thirty-two lodges is , indeed , a wonderful one . The whole question of 926 is pre-historic , at any rate , depends solely on a Guild legend , and how far the Grand Lodge at York in 1717 was in activity is a matier of very grave doubt indeed . The thirty-two lodges " non sunt . " Even Bro . Hughan or Bro . Gould will be puzzled at such a statement , and would like , with me , to sec their names and numbers . This is the way wc write Masonic history to-day .

2 . I am not aware that until the patent to the Lodge of Antiquity , late in the iSlh century , the Grand Lodge of York , revived b y . Drake , ever claimed or exercized authority South of the Trent . If it did the proof of it has yet to be found ; I know ol no such exercize , and I am quite sure Bro . Hughan does not , or he would have told me of it .

3 . In no sense , as far as I know , is it true that the London lodge seceded from the Grand Lodge of York . Whatever had become of the Lodge of Warrington in 1646 , or the Lodges in Staffordshire in [ 1667 , or of the Masons in London , assembled in Masons' Hall , Basinghall-street , in 16 S 2 , it is quite clear that earl y in the iSlh century Masonry in London was in a

dormant stale . There is not the slightest proof that in any way the London Masons had any connection with York . On the contrary , if our Masonic writers can be depended upon , there was a synchronous list of two sets of Grand Masters for the North and South , running " pari passu , " side b y side .

But leaving this point , out , the Masons of 1717 were no seceders , they were acting " pleno jure " in reviving a dormant Grand Lodge , which they sought , remember , 10 do , ( what Drake did at York later ) , and if the argument is good for anything , ( which , however , il is not ) , the York Grand Lodge , confessedly in abeyance—asjthe French say " en sommeil , " sleepmi ght with equal justice be contended to be a " secession" from the London Grand Lodge , then in full activity .

Bui the truth is all such arguments are out of place , and wide of the mark , and practically " nihil ad rem . " The York Masons acted on their full right later , just as the London Masons acted on their full ri ght earlier , and all the known London lodges existing met , and unanimousl y agreed to revive the Grand Lodge , and to set up the Quarterl y Communications , & c . Anderson , in his ori ginal account , 1723 , says : "And now the freeborn

British nations , etc ., having cf late much indulged their happy genius for Masonry of every sort , revived the drooping lodges of London , this fair metropolis llourisheth as well as other parts with several worthy particular lodges that have a Quarterl y Communication and an Annual Grand Assembly , wherein the forms and usages of the most ancient and worshi pful Fraternity are wisel y propagated , and the Royal Art duly cultivated , " & c . In 1723 there were in London twenty lodges .

In 1 73 S there were 106 London lodges and 47 in the country , and Anderson thus enlarges on the proceedings of 1716 : " The few lodges in London , finding themselves neglected by Sir Christopher Wren , thought fit to cement under a Grand Master , & -c , they constituted themselves ( that is the four lodges mentioned ) " pro tempore " in due form , and forthwith revived the Quarterl y Communication of the officers of lodges , called the Grand Lodge , kc .

I do not stop to enquire how far Anderson is absolutel y correct in all his particular statements , but I merely use his words to shew that no idea of a " secession from York " ever entered into the heads of the Masons of 1716-17 . Indeed , in the nature of things it could not be so , and I have , for my part , never understood how or why any writer could talk of a secession from

“The Freemason: 1881-06-04, Page 6” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 12 April 2026, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_04061881/page/6/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
CONTENTS. Article 1
Untitled Article 1
UNITED GRAND LODGE. Article 2
GRAND LODGE OF MARK MASTERS. Article 4
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR GIRLS. Article 6
MASONIC HISTORY AND HISTORIANS. Article 6
"LONG LIVERS." Article 7
THE AMERICAN PAST MASTER'S DEGREE. Article 7
PRESBYTERIANISM AND FREEMASONRY. Article 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
Original Correspondence. Article 8
Reviews. Article 9
Masonic Notes and Queries. Article 9
THE BOYS' SCHOOL CRICKET MATCH. Article 9
LAYING THE FOUNDATION STONE OF A NEW FREEMASONS' HALL AT MELTHAM. Article 9
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR BOYS. Article 10
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 10
Royal Arch. Article 11
Mark Masonry. Article 11
Red Cross of Constantine. Article 11
Rosicrucian Society. Article 11
Jamaica. Article 12
Obituary. Article 12
General Tidings. Article 12
Masonic Tidings. Article 12
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS Article 13
Births, Marriages, and Deaths. Article 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Page 1

Page 1

3 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

3 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

5 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

9 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

5 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

4 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

7 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

5 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

5 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

7 Articles
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Grand Lodge Of Mark Masters.

Grand Lodge was then closed , and the brethren adjourned to a superb banquet . After dinner the toasts were proposed . Lord HENNIKER , in proposing the first toast of the evening , " The Queen and Mark Masonry , " referred to the fact that three of Her Majesty ' s sons were already distinguished Masons , and that it had that day been made known that another son , the Duke of Albany , was made a Past . Grand Master of the Order .

Earl of LATHOM : I rise to propose the next toast to you , but before doing so I hope you will allow me to make a very few observations . Our Grand Master has shown me an excellent example of being brief in the toast he has just proposed . You also know well that I am never long , but there are some among you who have met with me in Warwickshire , where , I regret to say , I departed from my usual custom of brevity . The matter ,

however , was taken up with such effect b y my hearers that I cannot but say that I thank those brethren who took up and acted on the words I spoke on that occasion . Mark Masonry , during the time I have had the pleasure lo rule over you , has prospered ; during the past three years seventy-two new Mark lodges have been consecrated , which is double the rate of increase of

former periods , and , in proposing " The Health of my Successor , Lord Henniker , " I cannot do better than express my hope that he ma ) ' find at the end of a similar period that instead of seventy-two , a hundred and fortyfour new lodges have been added to the roll . Trusting that he may have a prosperous term of office , I now ask you to drink his very good health .

LORD HENNIKER : I thank my respected and worshipful friend , the Past Grand Master , for the kind manner in which he has proposed this toast , and I thank you for the cordial and kind way in which you have replied . I appreciate your kindness , and I appreciate it in this way—for your feeling towards your Past Grand Master , who has proposed this toast , for his past services to you , and for your promise to support me in the task I have

undertaken . I shall not easily forget this occasion . I shall remember il as not only the occasion of a great pleasure , in having been so cordiall y received , but also as a rather conspicuous occasion in Mark Masonry ; and I am fortunate that my day of installation is what Bro . Binckes has called the silver wedding of Mark Masonry . Among men and women who have passed periods of five and twenty years together in social happiness and

social usefulness the silver wedding mark . ' ; that they possess in a great degree , in a marked degree , the social quality , the quality we most admire in Mark Masonry . I think , brethren , that this Grand Mark Lodge may possess something of these qualities . You have heard what your late Master has said about the increase of Mark Masonry during his year of office . This is a matter of pleasure and satisfaction , for we must have a

feeling of triumph at the success of the Order . I was talking to my friend , Bro . Sandenian , from my own piovince , and he was telling me lhat when he was made a Mark Master he was one of the first of those who had joined Lodge No . 7 . That is eighteen years ago , and now we have thirty-one provinces , 290 lodges , and 15 , 000 members r and , as your Past Grand Master has told you , not only have we increased enormous ) ) ' lately , but we arc increasing more rapidly now than we have ever increased before . It is

something to say , and something for me to think of , that you have placed me oyer this large portion of the Craft . What I can say , brethren , is this , that I will do my very best to preside over you in a manner which may be satisfactory to you during my term of office , and I only hope that I may be so successful that the good wish of your Immediate Past Grand Master , that his number of new lodges may be doubled during my term , may come true . All I can say is to repeat that I will do my best to arrive at that result , and your kindness to-night enco urages me to the task .

Bro . BROADLEY : It is the twenty-fifth anniversary of this Grand Lodge , and I may be pardoned if I say that the toast of "The M . W . Past Grand Mark Master Masons " is almost the toast of the evening , and we have to congratulate the Grand Mark Lodge of England that it has become what it is to-day . 1 rise to propose " The Health of the Past Grand Masters of the Order , " a list of eight , beginning with Lord Leigh and ending with ( he Earl of Lathom , who have as Grand Mark Masters devoted their time to the

interests of the Order . We have had a great gathering this evening and have many distinguished brethren amongst us , not only from all parts of the country but also from a foreign country , which 1 am sorry to say is politically under a cloud at present , but where I can tell you the Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons of England will never be forgotten . It is my privilege to propose "The Health of the M . W . Past Grand Masters , " coupling therewith the names of Bro . W . W . B . Beach , M . P ., and Bro . the Rev . Raymond Portal .

Bro . PORTAL : I feel it is a proud position to have to return thanks for a body of Masons composed of such illustrious names as stand on the roll of the Past Grand Masters of this Grand Lodge , and to have assisted one whose rule has been confessedly most able and deservedl y most popular .

Rome was not built in a day ; Sir Christopher Wren lived to see the completion of his work ; but we shall not live to see the completion of ours , though we have had the satisfaction to see the vast progress it has made . In linies past we have endeavoured to do our best for the Order , and we shall continue to do what we can lo conduce to its success .

Bro . W . W . B . BEACH , M . P ., also responded to the toast . Bro . Sir E . LECHMERE , Bart ., proposed "The Health of the R . W . D . Grand Master , and the Grand Officers , Past and Present . " Bro . Lord KINTORE said it was with no ordinary feelings that he , a Scotch Mason , had assisted there that night , and listened to the toast in which he was concerned . He spoke of the coldness with which Mark

Masonry was , only a few years since , looked upon by the Grand Lodge of England , and contrasted it with the more cordial fcelings-that now prevailed . He hoped the good feeling would goon increasing ; that the English and Scotch Masons would work together , and draw the bonds of brotherhood closer . This had been a very great day for them all , and he felt that all their efforts in the past had been amply rewarded by that day ' s success .

The toast " Success to the Mark Benevolent Fund " was proposed by Bro . BEACH , and responded to by Bro . MATIER , who spoke in so low a tone that only disjointed fragments of sentences reached our reporter . " The Health of the Ladies " concluded the list of toasts ; and Bro . BINCKES , who had been all the evening assisting in entertaining the fair visitors , was summoned from the other room to reply to the toast , " which he did with his customary genial exuberance of language .

The musical arrangements were under the direction of Bro . Edwin M . Lotc , P . G . Mark Organist , assisted b y Madame Thaddetis Wells , Miss Hebe Barlow , Miss Mary Morton , Bro . John Stcdman , Bio . E gbert Roberts , Bro . Schuberth , and Bro . Stedman ' s choir boys .

Royal Masonic Institution For Girls.

ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR GIRLS .

We arc pleased now to be able to give a detailed list of the contributions from the Province of Gloucestershire announced at the festival . Bro . Henry Godfrey , J . P ., who now serves his third Stewardship with an aggregate amount of . £ 446 , nobly heads the list with £ -2 iS 8 s ., followed b y Bro . Clement Tudway with £ ISI 13 s ., and Bro . J . Brooksmith with £ " 142 14 s . To Bro . Col . H . G . Basevi , although the modest sum of £ 30 9 s . only appears against his name , a great portion of the success achieved by the province is due , and we congratulate him and the Province of Gloucestershire on the splendid result of their efforts .

Lodge . £ s . d . Lodge . £ s . d . S 2 Bro . Col . I-I . G . Basevi ... 30 9 o 493 Bro . G . W . Haines ... 43 1 o S 2 „ Baron de Ferrieres , 493 „ A . V . Hatton ... 10 10 o M . P . 10 10 o 493 „ Samuel Moss ... 10 10 o S 2 „ Henry Godfrey , J . P . 21 S S o 493 „ R . A . Matthews ... 550 S 2 „ Ernest W . Godfrey ... 10 io o 592 „ John Mullings ... to 10 o S 2 „ W . H . Gurnett ... G 3 o o 592 „ Clement Tudway ... 1 S 1 13 o Chapter . S 39 „ ] ames Bruton ... 10 10 o

S 2 Comp . J . Brooksmith , S 39 „ John Bryan 10 10 o D . P . G . M 142 14 o S 39 „ li . Vassar Smith ... 96 1 o S 2 „ W . Forth 27 0 o S 39 „ Robert W . White ... 15 15 o S 2 „ W . R . Porcher ... 15 15 o 900 „ Edward J . Gregory ... 22 1 o Lodge . 10 G 7 „ W . C . Heane ... n 11 o 24 G Bro . Edwin Lawrence ... 26 5 o 7067 „ Cranstoun Kerr ... 16 16 o 24 G „ George Norman ... 10 10 o Total £ 1000 o o

Masonic History And Historians.

MASONIC HISTORY AND HISTORIANS .

BY MASONIC STUDENT . As an illustration of the real difficulty of Masonic history still , I take up a contribution to it in 1 SS 1 lrom a new Body at the Antipodes , calling itself the Grand Lodge of New South Wales . In its proceedings at p . 25 occurs the following passage , which is a "gem " in its way .

"Now let us see how the Grand Lodge of England was established . It was not established in thc _ same regular and cons : itutional manner that the Grand Lodge of Canada was , nor is there any analogy between their proceedings and ours . We have chosen to follow the good example of our Canadian brethren , and we have not seccdeel as the four London Lodges did from the Grand Lodge of York . At the time of this

secession we find that there was the Grand Lodge of England established in the year 92 G at York , and having at that time jurisdiction over thirty-two daughter lodges . Notwithstanding that there was a Grand Lodge of England , we lind thai ; the Masonic Body in the south of England or London , then numbering four lodges , formed themselves into a Grand Lodge in the \ ear 1717 . "

There are , perhaps , in this one passage more errors than one could think possible to be found in a Masonic historical statement of 18 S 1 , and which will startle Bro . Hughan , as they have startled me , inasmuch as they seem to set at defiance all the careful researches and competent criticisms of these later days . Let us take the statement in its details .

1 . The declaration that in 1717 the Grand Lodge of York , established in 926 , was in full jurisdiction at York over thirty-two lodges is , indeed , a wonderful one . The whole question of 926 is pre-historic , at any rate , depends solely on a Guild legend , and how far the Grand Lodge at York in 1717 was in activity is a matier of very grave doubt indeed . The thirty-two lodges " non sunt . " Even Bro . Hughan or Bro . Gould will be puzzled at such a statement , and would like , with me , to sec their names and numbers . This is the way wc write Masonic history to-day .

2 . I am not aware that until the patent to the Lodge of Antiquity , late in the iSlh century , the Grand Lodge of York , revived b y . Drake , ever claimed or exercized authority South of the Trent . If it did the proof of it has yet to be found ; I know ol no such exercize , and I am quite sure Bro . Hughan does not , or he would have told me of it .

3 . In no sense , as far as I know , is it true that the London lodge seceded from the Grand Lodge of York . Whatever had become of the Lodge of Warrington in 1646 , or the Lodges in Staffordshire in [ 1667 , or of the Masons in London , assembled in Masons' Hall , Basinghall-street , in 16 S 2 , it is quite clear that earl y in the iSlh century Masonry in London was in a

dormant stale . There is not the slightest proof that in any way the London Masons had any connection with York . On the contrary , if our Masonic writers can be depended upon , there was a synchronous list of two sets of Grand Masters for the North and South , running " pari passu , " side b y side .

But leaving this point , out , the Masons of 1717 were no seceders , they were acting " pleno jure " in reviving a dormant Grand Lodge , which they sought , remember , 10 do , ( what Drake did at York later ) , and if the argument is good for anything , ( which , however , il is not ) , the York Grand Lodge , confessedly in abeyance—asjthe French say " en sommeil , " sleepmi ght with equal justice be contended to be a " secession" from the London Grand Lodge , then in full activity .

Bui the truth is all such arguments are out of place , and wide of the mark , and practically " nihil ad rem . " The York Masons acted on their full right later , just as the London Masons acted on their full ri ght earlier , and all the known London lodges existing met , and unanimousl y agreed to revive the Grand Lodge , and to set up the Quarterl y Communications , & c . Anderson , in his ori ginal account , 1723 , says : "And now the freeborn

British nations , etc ., having cf late much indulged their happy genius for Masonry of every sort , revived the drooping lodges of London , this fair metropolis llourisheth as well as other parts with several worthy particular lodges that have a Quarterl y Communication and an Annual Grand Assembly , wherein the forms and usages of the most ancient and worshi pful Fraternity are wisel y propagated , and the Royal Art duly cultivated , " & c . In 1723 there were in London twenty lodges .

In 1 73 S there were 106 London lodges and 47 in the country , and Anderson thus enlarges on the proceedings of 1716 : " The few lodges in London , finding themselves neglected by Sir Christopher Wren , thought fit to cement under a Grand Master , & -c , they constituted themselves ( that is the four lodges mentioned ) " pro tempore " in due form , and forthwith revived the Quarterl y Communication of the officers of lodges , called the Grand Lodge , kc .

I do not stop to enquire how far Anderson is absolutel y correct in all his particular statements , but I merely use his words to shew that no idea of a " secession from York " ever entered into the heads of the Masons of 1716-17 . Indeed , in the nature of things it could not be so , and I have , for my part , never understood how or why any writer could talk of a secession from

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 5
  • You're on page6
  • 7
  • 14
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2026

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy