Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Quarterly Review
  • Dec. 31, 1846
  • Page 110
Current:

The Freemasons' Quarterly Review, Dec. 31, 1846: Page 110

  • Back to The Freemasons' Quarterly Review, Dec. 31, 1846
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article LITERARY NOTICES. ← Page 5 of 8 →
Page 110

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Literary Notices.

Masonry ; and that it was not admitted into their system till after the building of Freemasons' Hall in the year 1776 . " In proof that the members of the constitutional Grand Lodge were , at this period , ignorant of its existence , and disclaimed its authority as a Masonic innovation , the Grand Secretary of the moderns stated , in answer to the petition of an ancient Mason for pecuniary relief , about the year 1758— ' Being an aucient Masonyou are not entitled to

, any of our charity . The ancient Masons have a Lodge at the ' Five Bells , ' in the Strand , and their secretary ' s name is Dermott . OUR SOCIETY IS NEITHER ARCH , ROYAL AKCH , nor ancient , so that you have no right to partake of our charity . ' It is clear , therefore , that the moderns had ho'Royal Arch in 1758 ; and equally clear that it had been long practised by the ancients , who were entirely ignorant of it at the first breaking out of the schism ; for they were then members of Lodges under

the constitutions of England ; and if they were acquainted with the degree , they were bound on their allegiance to communicate it to their superiors , if , as they afterwards asserted , it formed a constituent part of ancient Masonry , which they did not do . And if they were not acquainted with it , as it is reasonable to presume , how did they know it after the schism , if it was not a new invention , or a new communication ? And it could not be the latter for the reasons already stated . The conclusion is , therefore , inevitable , that the ancients fabricated the degree .

. " In confirmation of this fact , the same Book of Constitutions declares , that 'it is impossible to exalt a modern Mason to the Royal Arch , without previously conferring upon him the Master ' s degree according to their own ceremonies' This assertion was doubtless made on the ground that'lie was already in possession of the Master ' s word , which they knew was communicated in the third degree , according to the terms of the 'Master ' s part , ' as then practised by the modern Grand Lodge : for the

first lectures which were drawn up by Bros . Payne , Anderson , Desaguliers , Martin Folkes , Madden , and other eminent Masons , expressly declare in the degree of Master , that' that whicli was lost / meaning the Master Mason ' s word , 'is now found ; ' i . e . in the latter ceremonies of the third degree , when it was delivered to the newly-raised Master in form ; -and , therefore , the I ' oyal Arch degree would have thrown no new light on the subject to a constitutional Master Mason .

"This is a convincing proof that the difference between the ancient and modern systems consisted solely in the mutilation ofthe third degree ; and it is actually referred to in the proceedings of the modern Grand Loclge , in 1755 , where they express their disapprobation at the conduct ' of the ancients in 'introducing novelties and conceits of opinionative persons , to create belief that there have been other societies of Masons more , ancient than this society ; ' evidently alluding to the establishment of the Royal Arch ; which they publicly repudiated three years after- ; wards , as I have already shown , by declaring that they knew nothing of 'either Arch orRoyal Arch . '" - ¦¦' . ' -.

. , Many interesting particulars respecting the schism are added ; arid the Doctor appears to think that , in its effects , it was rather beneficial to . the Craft than otherwise . Thus he says- — ' '" ¦ '" : ' " ' ' " " '" -It . will be unnecessary to enquire whether all . this is , c ' onsisten . t ; vyith the-requirements of-Masonic duty . It is clear ' that . .. disobedience ,. is a breach of Masonic law . The very essence of the , institution is founded on obedience to authority ; and this once forfeited , led to division ,

“The Freemasons' Quarterly Review: 1846-12-31, Page 110” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 23 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fqr/issues/fqr_31121846/page/110/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE FREEMASONS' QUARTERLY REVIEW. Article 1
ON CORN, WINE, AND OIL. Article 8
THAT RELIGION IN WHICH ALL MEN AGREE.* Article 9
ON THE VITRIFIED FORTS IN NORTH BRITAIN. Article 13
ESOTERIC AND EXOTERIC MASONRY. Article 18
MASONS' MARKS. Article 19
STATE OF MASONRY IN IRELAND. Article 20
ON THE ABUSE OF FREEMASONRY. Article 28
THE FREEMASONS' LEXICON. Article 30
BRITISH FREEMASONRY AND CATHOLICISM. Article 35
SIR CHARLES WOLSELEY'S LETTERS. Article 37
TO THE CATHOLIC HIERARCHY OF ENGLAND. Article 38
THE INQUISITION IN ROME. Article 40
THE HIGH DEGREES OF FREEMASONRY. Article 41
THE LIBRARY QUESTION. Article 45
TO THE EDITOR. Article 47
TO THE EDITOR. Article 47
TO THE EDITOR. Article 47
TO THE EDITOR. Article 48
TO THE EDITOR. Article 48
TO THE EDITOR. Article 49
TO THE EDITOR Article 49
ADVENTURES OF A MASONIC HAT. Article 50
POETRY. Article 51
MONODY Article 51
MASONIC INTELLIGENCE. Article 54
QUARTERLY COMMUNICATION. Article 56
GRAND CONCLAVE OF ENGLAND AND WALES. Article 57
SUPREME COUNCIL 33nn DEGREE FOR ENGLAND AND WALES. Article 58
THE REPORTER. Article 62
CHIT CHAT. Article 62
Obituary. Article 64
PROVINCIAL. Article 66
SCOTLAND. Article 91
IRELAND. Article 97
FOREIGN.* Article 99
AMERICA.—UNITED STATES. Article 105
INDIA.* Article 105
LITERARY NOTICES. Article 106
ANNUS LATOMIÆ , Article 114
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 115
THE FREEMASONS' QUARTERLY REVIEW. Article 117
f^^^^^^^^ m^W^W. ^Ai^sgi^iz^^ ^SSS^S^L S... Article 118
FREEMASONS' QUARTERLY ADVERTISER. No. XVI.—DECEMBER 31, 1846. Article 119
35, CHARTER HOUSE SQUARE, MRS. ECCLES, Article 120
FREEMASONRY. BROTHER J. P. ACKLA M, MASO... Article 121
FREEMASONRY. "D ROTHER ROBERT C. TATE, J... Article 121
FREEMASONRY. W. EVANS, MASONIC JEWELLER ... Article 121
FREEMASONRY. V : BROTHER W. POVEY, MASON... Article 121
Extract from "ELEMENTS OF ART," by J. D.... Article 122
Just Published, price 2s. Gd., A NEW WOR... Article 122
SMALL DEBTS AND DAMAGES ACT, 9 & 10 VICT... Article 122
|ggv . QTOOPING of the SHOULDERS and CON... Article 122
IJENIOWSKI'S ARTIFICIAL MEMORY. Lectures... Article 123
"OOBLVSON'S PATENT BARLEY is the only ge... Article 123
Untitled Ad 123
THE LICENSED VICTUALLERS' AND GENERAL FI... Article 124
WOOD'S CIGAR ESTABLISHMENT, No. 69, King... Article 124
: LIMBIRD'S MAGNUM RQNUM STEEL PENS. "~"... Article 124
PALLADIUM LIFE ASSURANCE SOCIETY, 7, WAT... Article 125
THATCHES.—The most scientific and accura... Article 125
C O MPORT POR TENDE R FEET , &c. T| ALL ... Article 125
("•ALL'S ANTIBILIOUS PILLS.— The most us... Article 126
3y Her Majesty's ( *^^^^^®TO^^^fex »oyal... Article 127
: ft' ^fiR - &^F;:J£&M m R&": . | : 5fty... Article 128
Untitled Ad 129
Untitled Ad 130
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

2 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

2 Articles
Page 21

Page 21

1 Article
Page 22

Page 22

1 Article
Page 23

Page 23

1 Article
Page 24

Page 24

1 Article
Page 25

Page 25

1 Article
Page 26

Page 26

1 Article
Page 27

Page 27

1 Article
Page 28

Page 28

2 Articles
Page 29

Page 29

1 Article
Page 30

Page 30

2 Articles
Page 31

Page 31

1 Article
Page 32

Page 32

1 Article
Page 33

Page 33

1 Article
Page 34

Page 34

1 Article
Page 35

Page 35

1 Article
Page 36

Page 36

1 Article
Page 37

Page 37

1 Article
Page 38

Page 38

2 Articles
Page 39

Page 39

1 Article
Page 40

Page 40

1 Article
Page 41

Page 41

2 Articles
Page 42

Page 42

1 Article
Page 43

Page 43

1 Article
Page 44

Page 44

1 Article
Page 45

Page 45

2 Articles
Page 46

Page 46

1 Article
Page 47

Page 47

4 Articles
Page 48

Page 48

2 Articles
Page 49

Page 49

3 Articles
Page 50

Page 50

2 Articles
Page 51

Page 51

3 Articles
Page 52

Page 52

1 Article
Page 53

Page 53

1 Article
Page 54

Page 54

1 Article
Page 55

Page 55

1 Article
Page 56

Page 56

2 Articles
Page 57

Page 57

2 Articles
Page 58

Page 58

1 Article
Page 59

Page 59

1 Article
Page 60

Page 60

1 Article
Page 61

Page 61

1 Article
Page 62

Page 62

2 Articles
Page 63

Page 63

1 Article
Page 64

Page 64

2 Articles
Page 65

Page 65

1 Article
Page 66

Page 66

2 Articles
Page 67

Page 67

1 Article
Page 68

Page 68

1 Article
Page 69

Page 69

1 Article
Page 70

Page 70

1 Article
Page 71

Page 71

1 Article
Page 72

Page 72

1 Article
Page 73

Page 73

1 Article
Page 74

Page 74

1 Article
Page 75

Page 75

1 Article
Page 76

Page 76

1 Article
Page 77

Page 77

1 Article
Page 78

Page 78

1 Article
Page 79

Page 79

1 Article
Page 80

Page 80

1 Article
Page 81

Page 81

1 Article
Page 82

Page 82

1 Article
Page 83

Page 83

1 Article
Page 84

Page 84

1 Article
Page 85

Page 85

1 Article
Page 86

Page 86

1 Article
Page 87

Page 87

1 Article
Page 88

Page 88

1 Article
Page 89

Page 89

1 Article
Page 90

Page 90

1 Article
Page 91

Page 91

2 Articles
Page 92

Page 92

1 Article
Page 93

Page 93

1 Article
Page 94

Page 94

1 Article
Page 95

Page 95

1 Article
Page 96

Page 96

1 Article
Page 97

Page 97

2 Articles
Page 98

Page 98

1 Article
Page 99

Page 99

2 Articles
Page 100

Page 100

1 Article
Page 101

Page 101

1 Article
Page 102

Page 102

1 Article
Page 103

Page 103

1 Article
Page 104

Page 104

1 Article
Page 105

Page 105

3 Articles
Page 106

Page 106

2 Articles
Page 107

Page 107

1 Article
Page 108

Page 108

1 Article
Page 109

Page 109

1 Article
Page 110

Page 110

1 Article
Page 111

Page 111

1 Article
Page 112

Page 112

1 Article
Page 113

Page 113

1 Article
Page 114

Page 114

1 Article
Page 115

Page 115

1 Article
Page 116

Page 116

1 Article
Page 117

Page 117

1 Article
Page 118

Page 118

1 Article
Page 119

Page 119

1 Article
Page 120

Page 120

1 Article
Page 121

Page 121

4 Articles
Page 122

Page 122

4 Articles
Page 123

Page 123

3 Articles
Page 124

Page 124

3 Articles
Page 125

Page 125

3 Articles
Page 126

Page 126

1 Article
Page 127

Page 127

1 Article
Page 128

Page 128

1 Article
Page 129

Page 129

1 Article
Page 130

Page 130

1 Article
Page 110

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Literary Notices.

Masonry ; and that it was not admitted into their system till after the building of Freemasons' Hall in the year 1776 . " In proof that the members of the constitutional Grand Lodge were , at this period , ignorant of its existence , and disclaimed its authority as a Masonic innovation , the Grand Secretary of the moderns stated , in answer to the petition of an ancient Mason for pecuniary relief , about the year 1758— ' Being an aucient Masonyou are not entitled to

, any of our charity . The ancient Masons have a Lodge at the ' Five Bells , ' in the Strand , and their secretary ' s name is Dermott . OUR SOCIETY IS NEITHER ARCH , ROYAL AKCH , nor ancient , so that you have no right to partake of our charity . ' It is clear , therefore , that the moderns had ho'Royal Arch in 1758 ; and equally clear that it had been long practised by the ancients , who were entirely ignorant of it at the first breaking out of the schism ; for they were then members of Lodges under

the constitutions of England ; and if they were acquainted with the degree , they were bound on their allegiance to communicate it to their superiors , if , as they afterwards asserted , it formed a constituent part of ancient Masonry , which they did not do . And if they were not acquainted with it , as it is reasonable to presume , how did they know it after the schism , if it was not a new invention , or a new communication ? And it could not be the latter for the reasons already stated . The conclusion is , therefore , inevitable , that the ancients fabricated the degree .

. " In confirmation of this fact , the same Book of Constitutions declares , that 'it is impossible to exalt a modern Mason to the Royal Arch , without previously conferring upon him the Master ' s degree according to their own ceremonies' This assertion was doubtless made on the ground that'lie was already in possession of the Master ' s word , which they knew was communicated in the third degree , according to the terms of the 'Master ' s part , ' as then practised by the modern Grand Lodge : for the

first lectures which were drawn up by Bros . Payne , Anderson , Desaguliers , Martin Folkes , Madden , and other eminent Masons , expressly declare in the degree of Master , that' that whicli was lost / meaning the Master Mason ' s word , 'is now found ; ' i . e . in the latter ceremonies of the third degree , when it was delivered to the newly-raised Master in form ; -and , therefore , the I ' oyal Arch degree would have thrown no new light on the subject to a constitutional Master Mason .

"This is a convincing proof that the difference between the ancient and modern systems consisted solely in the mutilation ofthe third degree ; and it is actually referred to in the proceedings of the modern Grand Loclge , in 1755 , where they express their disapprobation at the conduct ' of the ancients in 'introducing novelties and conceits of opinionative persons , to create belief that there have been other societies of Masons more , ancient than this society ; ' evidently alluding to the establishment of the Royal Arch ; which they publicly repudiated three years after- ; wards , as I have already shown , by declaring that they knew nothing of 'either Arch orRoyal Arch . '" - ¦¦' . ' -.

. , Many interesting particulars respecting the schism are added ; arid the Doctor appears to think that , in its effects , it was rather beneficial to . the Craft than otherwise . Thus he says- — ' '" ¦ '" : ' " ' ' " " '" -It . will be unnecessary to enquire whether all . this is , c ' onsisten . t ; vyith the-requirements of-Masonic duty . It is clear ' that . .. disobedience ,. is a breach of Masonic law . The very essence of the , institution is founded on obedience to authority ; and this once forfeited , led to division ,

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 109
  • You're on page110
  • 111
  • 130
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy