Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Sept. 30, 1876
  • Page 3
  • NEW RULES AND REGULATIONS PROPOSED BY BRO. METHAM.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Sept. 30, 1876: Page 3

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Sept. 30, 1876
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE LATEST ABUSE OF FREEMASONRY. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article NEW RULES AND REGULATIONS PROPOSED BY BRO. METHAM. Page 1 of 2
    Article NEW RULES AND REGULATIONS PROPOSED BY BRO. METHAM. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 3

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Latest Abuse Of Freemasonry.

learned—to select a single instance—that the Marquis of Harfcingfcon , the leader of the Liberal Party in the House of Commons , is in the foremost rank of Masons . Ifc must follow , then , that as the Conservative principles of Messrs . Beach and Ford are embodied in Masonry , they being

Freemasons , so the Liberal principles of the Marquis of Hartingtori , he being a Freeemason , must likewise be embodied in Masonry . Therefore , to place the matter before our readers in Euclidian fashion , two sets of political principles , directly opposed to each other , are in consonance

with the principles of the same Institution . But things which are in consonance with the same thing are in consonance with each other ; therefore , Conservative principles and Liberal principles are in consonance with each other But they have long since been proved to be antagonistic ;

therefore , Liberal and Conservative principles are both in consonance with , and opposed to each other ; which is absurd . But , of course , any inqniry that would have led to this result would only have left this splenetic writer less room for the exercise of his spleen at the expense of Messrs . Beach and Ford .

We come next to the moral aspect of Freemasonry . The writer is dreadfully shocked the Lodge afc Havant should have been dedicated to " Masonry , Virtue , and Universal Benevolence , " and remarks that " it is notorious that many Masons attach more importance to their Masonry than to

all the virtues in the world . " According to our humble unenlightened Masonic notions , Masonry includes both Virtue and Universal Benevolence . Rightly , therefore , ¦ was Masonry , as being the whole , placed first in order , and then "Virtue and Universal Benevolence , " which are only

two of its constituent parts . Then , we are told " of all the shams of the Order , the assumption of Universal Benevolence is the greatest and most preposterous . " This , as being the mere expression of an opinion , need not detain ns long . The good that Freemasonry does may fairly be

set against the assumed Benevolence , which is "the greatest and most preposterous of all the shams of the Order . " Again , if people are prejudiced , we consider it would not be very difficult for them , on public grounds , to believe that "the operations of Masonry , as a secret society ,

are actually pernicious . But , unfortunately for this belief , we are not a secret society in the sense intended by this writer . We are all duly registered according to law , at least in this country , so that the government can easily learn , if it choses , who and what manner of men we are . At the

time the law was enacted against secret societies , Freemasons were specially and by name exempted from its operation . This would certainly nofc have been the case had we been a " pernicious " society . As to the statement that "the reason the Masons do not reveal their secret is no

doubt that they have none to reveal , " we confess we have heard this more than once , but it was always made by non-Masons , who were probably very angry they could not discover it . It happens , indeed , as regards this assertion , that we have our secrets , though they are not of the

dangerous character this writer may imagine . We have touched briefly upon the leading points of this viciously-written article . Were all the world as well

acquainted with Freemasonry as we Masons are , we should allow all such attacks to pass unnoticed . But a mystery attaches to us , and when we find onr Order assailed with nearly two whole columns of abuse , it is , perhaps , as well the world should know the abuse is uncalled for .

Moreover , there is a further justification in the case of this particular specimen of the abuse which is occasionall y levelled at us . It will be difficult to find its equal either in vulgarity of tone or the profundity of its ignorance .

New Rules And Regulations Proposed By Bro. Metham.

NEW RULES AND REGULATIONS PROPOSED BY BRO . METHAM .

WE cannot say we are disposed to accept , in their entirety , the suggestions which Bro . Metham offered in his address at South Molton for the better regulation of the Devonian Lodges . To certain of these no reasonable Mason would dream of taking exception . To

others , however , there are , we fancy , innumerable objections , and some of these are likely to prove unanswerable . Bro . Metham has fulfilled a most painful duty admirably . He has proclaimed publicly that certain recent matters in his province have brought , and continue to bring , a

New Rules And Regulations Proposed By Bro. Metham.

large amount of odium on tho Craft . He is naturally anxious to prevent a recurrence of them . Having , therefore , in tho first place boldly and publicly denounced the un-Masonic conduct of certain brethren , he endeavoured to indicate the likeliest means for preventing such

misconduct m the future . He therefore submitted a series of six regulations , by which it occurred to him this desirable consummation might be attained . We give them seriatim , with our reasons for agreeing or disagreeing , as the case may be , with their respective points . They aro as follow ;

1 . " The abandonment of refreshments , as a rule , after every Lodge meeting . " We take exception to this proposed rule . Oar Lodges meet but seldom , from six to twelve times in the year , rarely oftener . The bulk of the members aro men who

would either dine or sup about the hour when Lodges adjourn for refreshment . It seems to us a needlessly harsh rule that would deny the twenty or thirty members , who have attended the duties of the evening , the privilege of sitting round the same table , and enjoying a brief

fraternal intercourse over a well served dinner or supper , similar in degree and kind to what they would indulge in at their own homes . We have no very high opinion of men who cannot be trusted to share a homely meal without being guilty of some impropriety . Some there are , of course

who will make the Lodge dinner or banquet an opportunity for over-indulgence in the pleasures of the table . Those , however , we are happy to believe form only an insignificant minority among Craftsmen , and it strikes us the height of unreason that the vices of the very few should be

visited on the many . Those who cannot take Lodge refreshment without committing themselves more or less grossly are not fit to associate with other members , 01 indeed to mix in any society of men . What we object toand we hope we can enjoy the goods things of this life as

well as other folk—are the elaborate and oftentimes pretentious banquets , which by many are regarded as the be-all and end-all of Freemasonry . Against this it is we are anxious

to believe our worthy brother is raising his voice ; and in sofar as this is the case , but only to that extent , do we think refreshment after a Lodge meeting should be dispensed with .

2 . " That when refreshments are taken on special occasions they should , under no circumstances whatever , bo prolonged beyond eleven o ' clock . ^ We think this a perfectly just and reasonable proposition . We consider the brethren have a right to

refreshment after labour , not from any canting , hypocritical motive , but for reasons we have already indicated . It is allowable for a Mason to take similar refreshment from home to what he would partake of at home . Ifc is

desirable to encourage social intercourse among brethren . But while we recognise the propriety of Lodge refreshment , we see no reason why it should be prolonged to an unseasonable hour .

3 . " That no brother should be allowed to sit at table who had not attended the duties of his Lodge during the evening . " This is obviously a just rule to propose , though there are numerous instances in which ifc would as obviously be

discourteous to enforce it . For instance , the Secretaries of our Charitable Institutions have very onerous duties to perform . It is impossible they can always attend the duties of the Lodges they are invited or desire to visit . But as

applied to members of the Lodge itself , the old fashioned rule of " No Song , no Supper , " is a just one . It is the workman who stands in need of refreshment , not he who shirks his work .

4 . " That no brother who becomes insolvent should be allowed to continue a member of a Lodge , nor be admitted into any other Lodge until his debts have been paid in full . " Here , again , we must join issue with Bro . Metham .

Such a rule smacks not a little of the objectionable practice of "hitting a man when he is down . " There are , undoubtedly , many persons who make a point of incurring debt , and then wash themselves , periodically , of their

liabilities , by seeking the protection of the Court of Bankruptcy . It is impossible , of course , to condemn the conduct of such persons too severely . But the majority of insolvent persons become so most unwillingly , through no fault of their own . PeradYenture they haye suffered

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1876-09-30, Page 3” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 1 Aug. 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_30091876/page/3/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
INDISCRIMINATE ADMISSION OF CANDIDATES. Article 1
THE LATEST ABUSE OF FREEMASONRY. Article 2
NEW RULES AND REGULATIONS PROPOSED BY BRO. METHAM. Article 3
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 4
WHICH IS CORRECT ? Article 4
Untitled Article 5
LAYING THE FOUNDATION STONE OF THE NEW DOCKS AT AYR. Article 5
UNIFORMITY OF WORKING. Article 7
REVIEWS. Article 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
OUR WEEKLY BUDGET. Article 8
Old Warrants. Article 9
RENFREWSHIRE EAST PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE. Article 10
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 11
GLASGOW AND THE WEST OF SCOTLAND. Article 11
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 12
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Article 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

4 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

6 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

3 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

13 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

18 Articles
Page 3

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Latest Abuse Of Freemasonry.

learned—to select a single instance—that the Marquis of Harfcingfcon , the leader of the Liberal Party in the House of Commons , is in the foremost rank of Masons . Ifc must follow , then , that as the Conservative principles of Messrs . Beach and Ford are embodied in Masonry , they being

Freemasons , so the Liberal principles of the Marquis of Hartingtori , he being a Freeemason , must likewise be embodied in Masonry . Therefore , to place the matter before our readers in Euclidian fashion , two sets of political principles , directly opposed to each other , are in consonance

with the principles of the same Institution . But things which are in consonance with the same thing are in consonance with each other ; therefore , Conservative principles and Liberal principles are in consonance with each other But they have long since been proved to be antagonistic ;

therefore , Liberal and Conservative principles are both in consonance with , and opposed to each other ; which is absurd . But , of course , any inqniry that would have led to this result would only have left this splenetic writer less room for the exercise of his spleen at the expense of Messrs . Beach and Ford .

We come next to the moral aspect of Freemasonry . The writer is dreadfully shocked the Lodge afc Havant should have been dedicated to " Masonry , Virtue , and Universal Benevolence , " and remarks that " it is notorious that many Masons attach more importance to their Masonry than to

all the virtues in the world . " According to our humble unenlightened Masonic notions , Masonry includes both Virtue and Universal Benevolence . Rightly , therefore , ¦ was Masonry , as being the whole , placed first in order , and then "Virtue and Universal Benevolence , " which are only

two of its constituent parts . Then , we are told " of all the shams of the Order , the assumption of Universal Benevolence is the greatest and most preposterous . " This , as being the mere expression of an opinion , need not detain ns long . The good that Freemasonry does may fairly be

set against the assumed Benevolence , which is "the greatest and most preposterous of all the shams of the Order . " Again , if people are prejudiced , we consider it would not be very difficult for them , on public grounds , to believe that "the operations of Masonry , as a secret society ,

are actually pernicious . But , unfortunately for this belief , we are not a secret society in the sense intended by this writer . We are all duly registered according to law , at least in this country , so that the government can easily learn , if it choses , who and what manner of men we are . At the

time the law was enacted against secret societies , Freemasons were specially and by name exempted from its operation . This would certainly nofc have been the case had we been a " pernicious " society . As to the statement that "the reason the Masons do not reveal their secret is no

doubt that they have none to reveal , " we confess we have heard this more than once , but it was always made by non-Masons , who were probably very angry they could not discover it . It happens , indeed , as regards this assertion , that we have our secrets , though they are not of the

dangerous character this writer may imagine . We have touched briefly upon the leading points of this viciously-written article . Were all the world as well

acquainted with Freemasonry as we Masons are , we should allow all such attacks to pass unnoticed . But a mystery attaches to us , and when we find onr Order assailed with nearly two whole columns of abuse , it is , perhaps , as well the world should know the abuse is uncalled for .

Moreover , there is a further justification in the case of this particular specimen of the abuse which is occasionall y levelled at us . It will be difficult to find its equal either in vulgarity of tone or the profundity of its ignorance .

New Rules And Regulations Proposed By Bro. Metham.

NEW RULES AND REGULATIONS PROPOSED BY BRO . METHAM .

WE cannot say we are disposed to accept , in their entirety , the suggestions which Bro . Metham offered in his address at South Molton for the better regulation of the Devonian Lodges . To certain of these no reasonable Mason would dream of taking exception . To

others , however , there are , we fancy , innumerable objections , and some of these are likely to prove unanswerable . Bro . Metham has fulfilled a most painful duty admirably . He has proclaimed publicly that certain recent matters in his province have brought , and continue to bring , a

New Rules And Regulations Proposed By Bro. Metham.

large amount of odium on tho Craft . He is naturally anxious to prevent a recurrence of them . Having , therefore , in tho first place boldly and publicly denounced the un-Masonic conduct of certain brethren , he endeavoured to indicate the likeliest means for preventing such

misconduct m the future . He therefore submitted a series of six regulations , by which it occurred to him this desirable consummation might be attained . We give them seriatim , with our reasons for agreeing or disagreeing , as the case may be , with their respective points . They aro as follow ;

1 . " The abandonment of refreshments , as a rule , after every Lodge meeting . " We take exception to this proposed rule . Oar Lodges meet but seldom , from six to twelve times in the year , rarely oftener . The bulk of the members aro men who

would either dine or sup about the hour when Lodges adjourn for refreshment . It seems to us a needlessly harsh rule that would deny the twenty or thirty members , who have attended the duties of the evening , the privilege of sitting round the same table , and enjoying a brief

fraternal intercourse over a well served dinner or supper , similar in degree and kind to what they would indulge in at their own homes . We have no very high opinion of men who cannot be trusted to share a homely meal without being guilty of some impropriety . Some there are , of course

who will make the Lodge dinner or banquet an opportunity for over-indulgence in the pleasures of the table . Those , however , we are happy to believe form only an insignificant minority among Craftsmen , and it strikes us the height of unreason that the vices of the very few should be

visited on the many . Those who cannot take Lodge refreshment without committing themselves more or less grossly are not fit to associate with other members , 01 indeed to mix in any society of men . What we object toand we hope we can enjoy the goods things of this life as

well as other folk—are the elaborate and oftentimes pretentious banquets , which by many are regarded as the be-all and end-all of Freemasonry . Against this it is we are anxious

to believe our worthy brother is raising his voice ; and in sofar as this is the case , but only to that extent , do we think refreshment after a Lodge meeting should be dispensed with .

2 . " That when refreshments are taken on special occasions they should , under no circumstances whatever , bo prolonged beyond eleven o ' clock . ^ We think this a perfectly just and reasonable proposition . We consider the brethren have a right to

refreshment after labour , not from any canting , hypocritical motive , but for reasons we have already indicated . It is allowable for a Mason to take similar refreshment from home to what he would partake of at home . Ifc is

desirable to encourage social intercourse among brethren . But while we recognise the propriety of Lodge refreshment , we see no reason why it should be prolonged to an unseasonable hour .

3 . " That no brother should be allowed to sit at table who had not attended the duties of his Lodge during the evening . " This is obviously a just rule to propose , though there are numerous instances in which ifc would as obviously be

discourteous to enforce it . For instance , the Secretaries of our Charitable Institutions have very onerous duties to perform . It is impossible they can always attend the duties of the Lodges they are invited or desire to visit . But as

applied to members of the Lodge itself , the old fashioned rule of " No Song , no Supper , " is a just one . It is the workman who stands in need of refreshment , not he who shirks his work .

4 . " That no brother who becomes insolvent should be allowed to continue a member of a Lodge , nor be admitted into any other Lodge until his debts have been paid in full . " Here , again , we must join issue with Bro . Metham .

Such a rule smacks not a little of the objectionable practice of "hitting a man when he is down . " There are , undoubtedly , many persons who make a point of incurring debt , and then wash themselves , periodically , of their

liabilities , by seeking the protection of the Court of Bankruptcy . It is impossible , of course , to condemn the conduct of such persons too severely . But the majority of insolvent persons become so most unwillingly , through no fault of their own . PeradYenture they haye suffered

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 2
  • You're on page3
  • 4
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy