Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Dec. 27, 1890
  • Page 4
  • ELECTA'S CHOICE.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Dec. 27, 1890: Page 4

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Dec. 27, 1890
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article ELECTA'S CHOICE. Page 1 of 3
    Article ELECTA'S CHOICE. Page 1 of 3 →
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Electa's Choice.

ELECTA'S CHOICE .

A CHRISTMAS STORY .

Br REV . H . A . GUILD , LINCOLN , NEBRASKA . FAR from it , Mr . Dictum . If you imagine that my judgment ia to be controlled aud my actions directed by such considerations , yon are doomed to disappointment bitter and lusting , it may be . When convinced that a man ' s course of conduct is determined by devotion to a

cherished principle , even though that principle may not commend itself to my approval , I can summon for him some measure of respect , and find excuse for his modes of operation . Bufc when , as in this case , I am forced to t' . e conviction that ho is swayed and governed by tho power of

prejudice , and would compel others to tbe occupancy of a like position , then my soul revolts , and I tnrn from him with indignation . My father was a Freemason for more than twenty years , and was nofc only constantly interested in , but conscientiously devoted to the princi ples of that

ancient organisation . Ihe benefits derived by him from his membership in the Lodge , I have often heard him say , wero greater by far than those accz'uing from all other organisations , and these , as yon are aware , were numerous , for father was emphatically a society man . They were not

pecuniary benefits , tor he had no need of them , but thoso higher and nobler benefits thafc expand the mind and enlarge tho heart , and that even impart to the religion of Christ a greater breadth and a warmer glow . But now you come , without experience and without knowledge in

regard to these affiles , and coolly tell me that Masonry is a cheat , and modestly and generously suggest that if I will abandon all thought of uniting with the Order of the

Eastern Star , onr former pleasant relations may be resumed and closer ones established iu the future ! Was such mugnanimitv over before approached ? Can it ever again be equalled ?"

Are you not disposed to be sarcastic , Miss Electa ? Aud aro you nofc giving to my words an interpretation that they will scarcely warrant ? I am not seeking to impose conditions arbitrarily upon you , nor to demand a sacrifice that to you would be ' revolting . ' I have simply suggested

whether , in the absence of one thing , and in the presence of another , considering the circumstances in which we are placed , and in view of such circumstances and conditions as may yet bo in fche future , it wonld nofc be well to abandon or dismiss such designs and aims as at somo time mi ght

prove mutually embarrassing . Surely , you cannot afford to sacrifice upon the altar of the unknown , and , therefore , the untested , such hopes and aspirations as have mutually characterised us in the past . Were the matter one concerning which you had personal experience , or positive

information , tno case would be widely different . Such information as you possess , I am persuaded , from a careful investigation of the whole subject , has come to you from imperfectly informed sources , and is therefore unreliable .

Believe me that you are misinformed—greatly so—in regard to the history , purposes and processes , both of the Masonic Fraternity and of the Order of the Eastern Star . "

" I shall do nothing of the kind , Mr . Dictum ; nor could I do so without insulting the memory of as good a father ns ever lived , even as yon insult it by your unjust and unmanly proposition and demand . The information I have concerning the two organisations that you contemptuously

allude to came largely from my dear and honoured father , who , long a member of both societies , understood perfectly the matters whereof he affirmed . In no respect did he ever deceive me . On no account would he lead me astray and now , with cool assurance , you come to me with the

impossible proposition that I regard as untrustworthy the information communicated fco me in good faith by that father , and accept iu its place your own unsupported and unsatisfactory declarations ! You , with your ' careful investigations , ' mado in th darkness of superstition and

prejudice , with not a single ray of light illuminating your way ; you , whose * information ' can have no better source than conjecture , hatred , and the Cynosure—you , sir , havo the effrontery to demand that 1 discredit my father ,

and make you the receptacle of my confidence and faith ! Wonderful instance of assurance and modesty of demand I My information untrustworthy and unsatisfying ! Indeed , Mr . Dietnm ? I have not only that referred to , but look here . Behold these bound volumes of " The Voice of

Electa's Choice.

Masonry , " and scan the list of able , respected and compe-: cnfc contributor * . See these other Masonic periodicals and papers , and theso Masonic books . Gaze upon theso shelves laden with the productions of Morris , Pike , Mackey , Mitchell , Macoy , and others equally eminent ami reliable .

I have read all of these works , aud I have also ihe supporting testimony of hundreds of living and reliable witnesses , all about ns—the very best men and women in the community—all affirming that to be good and ennobling which you denominate as fraudulent and demoralisinir . Sir , yon

come to the wrong market with your wares . If , now , you have any facts , any arguments based upon that which is tangible and concretely real , produce them , and I will gt vo te them all the attention that thoy may merit . Bufc be

assured that mere declamation , or declaration , or conjecture , or hearsay , will not answer the purposes of thia discussion . "I fear , Miss Electa , that yon aro becoming excited . There is no occasion for excitement . Nor do I think it

desirable or profitable that we continue a controversy that would seem to give promise of unpleasant results . I suggest that we drop the whole thing for the present , at least , and turn to more agreeable topics . Remember that

Christmas is almost hero , and that we havo not complete ! the arrangements we had in view for that occasion . I am still ready to carry into execution my portion of the programme , despite our little intellectual divergences . "

" If you had no relish for this discussion , Mr . Dictum , it should not have been precipitated by you . It certainly was not of my seeking . As to the programme of which you speak , I do not think thafc ifc is suffering for want of attention . There was a time when I looked forward to the

coming of approaching Christmas with anticipated jos ' . That timo is not now . While Christmas holds in store no terrors for me , so far as I am aware , 1 can not overlook lite fact that conditions have materially changed within tho past few weeks , aud I cannot sny that I will be ready for

my part of the ' programme . ' To-morrow evening , Providenco permitting , I shall become a member of the Order cf the Eastern Star , aud shall thenceforward be eimbled to speak more authoritatively aud definitely iu regard to the

purposes and aims of that organisation . So , having a personal knowledge of the Order , you may ba afforded mors definite knowledge—if you still have faith in me—and then your own course can be more satisfactorily determined . "

" Really , Miss Electa , you cannot mean this . It can hardly be that you will so soon identify yourself with that organisation , in view of what has so recently transpired . I understood that this matter had been postponed indefinitely , aud until you could give it maturer consideration . "

" I am not responsible for your ' understanding' in this case , Mr . Dictum . Yon surely had no such assurance from me . If alive and well , I expect , as I am determined , to enter the Order of tho Eastern Star to-morrow evening . Here is the notice of my election , and of the appointment for my initiation . "

" This being true , then , Miss Electa , I presume that you will have no objection to my spending Christmas in San Francisco ?" " Not the slightest , sir , if such shall be your desire . But

before your departure I hope to have the pleasure of giving you my impressions concerning the Star , promising , should these be unfavourable , to give you the full benefit of your doubt . "

" Certainly , Miss Electa , I shall be moat happy to seo you again before I go , and to receive any genuine inform itipn that you may have to impart . " The evening for " work" had come , and Electa was duly

invested with the several degrees of the Eastern Star . The ceremonies of initiation , while pleasing in all their parts , had failed to fully meet all her anticipations . But if aught were lacking here , there was an infinite compensation in the sublime lessons inculcated throughout the

degrees , as will be seen . " Well , Miss Electa , I am here to make my final call . " " Final ! You really astonish me !" " Well , yes , final before my departure for San Francisco I leave in the morning . "

" This is very sudden , Mr . Dictum , but is perhaps just as well . You wish to carry my new ' impressions ' with you ? These , regarding the Eastern Star , are very favourable . Father had told me thafc the design of Freemasonry was to render its votaries wiser , better , and consequently happier . Of course , I believed him ; but I never accepted

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1890-12-27, Page 4” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 25 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_27121890/page/4/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
SCOTTISH MASONIC BENEVOLENCE. Article 1
THE RECENT SCOTTISH MASONIC BAZAAR. Article 2
THE GENERAL PRESS AND THE BAZAAR. Article 2
ABOUT PUBLIC INSTALLATIONS. Article 3
A MASONIC CONCERT AT BOLTON. Article 3
Untitled Ad 3
ELECTA'S CHOICE. Article 4
CATHOLICS v. FREEMASONS. Article 6
CONSECRATION OF THE CARNARVON LODGE, No. 2376. Article 6
PROV. GRAND LODGE OF THE ISLE OF MAN. Article 7
SCOTLAND. Article 7
Untitled Article 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
Untitled Article 8
PROV. G. LODGE OF DERBYSHIRE. Article 8
NOTICE OF MEETINGS. Article 10
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 11
Untitled Article 11
Untitled Article 11
Untitled Ad 11
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 12
INSTRUCTION. Article 12
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
LIST OF RARE AND VALUABLE WORKS ON FREEMASONRY. Article 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Article 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

4 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

5 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

3 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

5 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

12 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

5 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

5 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

11 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

13 Articles
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Electa's Choice.

ELECTA'S CHOICE .

A CHRISTMAS STORY .

Br REV . H . A . GUILD , LINCOLN , NEBRASKA . FAR from it , Mr . Dictum . If you imagine that my judgment ia to be controlled aud my actions directed by such considerations , yon are doomed to disappointment bitter and lusting , it may be . When convinced that a man ' s course of conduct is determined by devotion to a

cherished principle , even though that principle may not commend itself to my approval , I can summon for him some measure of respect , and find excuse for his modes of operation . Bufc when , as in this case , I am forced to t' . e conviction that ho is swayed and governed by tho power of

prejudice , and would compel others to tbe occupancy of a like position , then my soul revolts , and I tnrn from him with indignation . My father was a Freemason for more than twenty years , and was nofc only constantly interested in , but conscientiously devoted to the princi ples of that

ancient organisation . Ihe benefits derived by him from his membership in the Lodge , I have often heard him say , wero greater by far than those accz'uing from all other organisations , and these , as yon are aware , were numerous , for father was emphatically a society man . They were not

pecuniary benefits , tor he had no need of them , but thoso higher and nobler benefits thafc expand the mind and enlarge tho heart , and that even impart to the religion of Christ a greater breadth and a warmer glow . But now you come , without experience and without knowledge in

regard to these affiles , and coolly tell me that Masonry is a cheat , and modestly and generously suggest that if I will abandon all thought of uniting with the Order of the

Eastern Star , onr former pleasant relations may be resumed and closer ones established iu the future ! Was such mugnanimitv over before approached ? Can it ever again be equalled ?"

Are you not disposed to be sarcastic , Miss Electa ? Aud aro you nofc giving to my words an interpretation that they will scarcely warrant ? I am not seeking to impose conditions arbitrarily upon you , nor to demand a sacrifice that to you would be ' revolting . ' I have simply suggested

whether , in the absence of one thing , and in the presence of another , considering the circumstances in which we are placed , and in view of such circumstances and conditions as may yet bo in fche future , it wonld nofc be well to abandon or dismiss such designs and aims as at somo time mi ght

prove mutually embarrassing . Surely , you cannot afford to sacrifice upon the altar of the unknown , and , therefore , the untested , such hopes and aspirations as have mutually characterised us in the past . Were the matter one concerning which you had personal experience , or positive

information , tno case would be widely different . Such information as you possess , I am persuaded , from a careful investigation of the whole subject , has come to you from imperfectly informed sources , and is therefore unreliable .

Believe me that you are misinformed—greatly so—in regard to the history , purposes and processes , both of the Masonic Fraternity and of the Order of the Eastern Star . "

" I shall do nothing of the kind , Mr . Dictum ; nor could I do so without insulting the memory of as good a father ns ever lived , even as yon insult it by your unjust and unmanly proposition and demand . The information I have concerning the two organisations that you contemptuously

allude to came largely from my dear and honoured father , who , long a member of both societies , understood perfectly the matters whereof he affirmed . In no respect did he ever deceive me . On no account would he lead me astray and now , with cool assurance , you come to me with the

impossible proposition that I regard as untrustworthy the information communicated fco me in good faith by that father , and accept iu its place your own unsupported and unsatisfactory declarations ! You , with your ' careful investigations , ' mado in th darkness of superstition and

prejudice , with not a single ray of light illuminating your way ; you , whose * information ' can have no better source than conjecture , hatred , and the Cynosure—you , sir , havo the effrontery to demand that 1 discredit my father ,

and make you the receptacle of my confidence and faith ! Wonderful instance of assurance and modesty of demand I My information untrustworthy and unsatisfying ! Indeed , Mr . Dietnm ? I have not only that referred to , but look here . Behold these bound volumes of " The Voice of

Electa's Choice.

Masonry , " and scan the list of able , respected and compe-: cnfc contributor * . See these other Masonic periodicals and papers , and theso Masonic books . Gaze upon theso shelves laden with the productions of Morris , Pike , Mackey , Mitchell , Macoy , and others equally eminent ami reliable .

I have read all of these works , aud I have also ihe supporting testimony of hundreds of living and reliable witnesses , all about ns—the very best men and women in the community—all affirming that to be good and ennobling which you denominate as fraudulent and demoralisinir . Sir , yon

come to the wrong market with your wares . If , now , you have any facts , any arguments based upon that which is tangible and concretely real , produce them , and I will gt vo te them all the attention that thoy may merit . Bufc be

assured that mere declamation , or declaration , or conjecture , or hearsay , will not answer the purposes of thia discussion . "I fear , Miss Electa , that yon aro becoming excited . There is no occasion for excitement . Nor do I think it

desirable or profitable that we continue a controversy that would seem to give promise of unpleasant results . I suggest that we drop the whole thing for the present , at least , and turn to more agreeable topics . Remember that

Christmas is almost hero , and that we havo not complete ! the arrangements we had in view for that occasion . I am still ready to carry into execution my portion of the programme , despite our little intellectual divergences . "

" If you had no relish for this discussion , Mr . Dictum , it should not have been precipitated by you . It certainly was not of my seeking . As to the programme of which you speak , I do not think thafc ifc is suffering for want of attention . There was a time when I looked forward to the

coming of approaching Christmas with anticipated jos ' . That timo is not now . While Christmas holds in store no terrors for me , so far as I am aware , 1 can not overlook lite fact that conditions have materially changed within tho past few weeks , aud I cannot sny that I will be ready for

my part of the ' programme . ' To-morrow evening , Providenco permitting , I shall become a member of the Order cf the Eastern Star , aud shall thenceforward be eimbled to speak more authoritatively aud definitely iu regard to the

purposes and aims of that organisation . So , having a personal knowledge of the Order , you may ba afforded mors definite knowledge—if you still have faith in me—and then your own course can be more satisfactorily determined . "

" Really , Miss Electa , you cannot mean this . It can hardly be that you will so soon identify yourself with that organisation , in view of what has so recently transpired . I understood that this matter had been postponed indefinitely , aud until you could give it maturer consideration . "

" I am not responsible for your ' understanding' in this case , Mr . Dictum . Yon surely had no such assurance from me . If alive and well , I expect , as I am determined , to enter the Order of tho Eastern Star to-morrow evening . Here is the notice of my election , and of the appointment for my initiation . "

" This being true , then , Miss Electa , I presume that you will have no objection to my spending Christmas in San Francisco ?" " Not the slightest , sir , if such shall be your desire . But

before your departure I hope to have the pleasure of giving you my impressions concerning the Star , promising , should these be unfavourable , to give you the full benefit of your doubt . "

" Certainly , Miss Electa , I shall be moat happy to seo you again before I go , and to receive any genuine inform itipn that you may have to impart . " The evening for " work" had come , and Electa was duly

invested with the several degrees of the Eastern Star . The ceremonies of initiation , while pleasing in all their parts , had failed to fully meet all her anticipations . But if aught were lacking here , there was an infinite compensation in the sublime lessons inculcated throughout the

degrees , as will be seen . " Well , Miss Electa , I am here to make my final call . " " Final ! You really astonish me !" " Well , yes , final before my departure for San Francisco I leave in the morning . "

" This is very sudden , Mr . Dictum , but is perhaps just as well . You wish to carry my new ' impressions ' with you ? These , regarding the Eastern Star , are very favourable . Father had told me thafc the design of Freemasonry was to render its votaries wiser , better , and consequently happier . Of course , I believed him ; but I never accepted

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 3
  • You're on page4
  • 5
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy