Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Oct. 27, 1883
  • Page 3
  • AN ANTI-MASONIC AGITATION.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Oct. 27, 1883: Page 3

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Oct. 27, 1883
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article HIGH DEGREES. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article AN ANTI-MASONIC AGITATION. Page 1 of 1
    Article AN ANTI-MASONIC AGITATION. Page 1 of 1
Page 3

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

High Degrees.

posed io each other , assume to confer the same high degrees . Then , when onepartyexcommunicates theother , and exposes all of its naughtiness , and the other retorts and exposes the naughtiness of the first , Brethren of Solomonic wisdom smile , and congratulate themselves upon the fact that ,

after all , they themselves possess the much coveted and truly genuine "highest and last degree , " about which there can be no contention as to its regularity or antiquity . Brethren should manifest their appreciation of tho only ancient and universally accepted degrees , including as they

do the highest of all , by diligent attendance at the meetings of the respective Masonic bodies in which they are conferred . Always do full justice , first to your Lodge and Chapter ; and afterwards devote what time you may to other bodies . The former are entitled to your loyal and

cordial allegiance . They made you , Masonically , what you are ; they include in their membership the entire Masonic family ; they are elevated , dignified , and enlightened ; and search where you will , go where you may , you can find outside of them no higher degree . —Keystone . ¦

An Anti-Masonic Agitation.

AN ANTI-MASONIC AGITATION .

fTIHAT unscrupulous party . manager , wire puller and corrupter of -i- popular constituencies , Thurlow Weed , who had more actions for libel brought against him than any editor in America , gives an account in his autobiograph y , recently published at Boston , of an anti . Masonio movement in New York State whioh has , as a Times reviewer remarks , a curious resemblance to the anti Semitic agitation in Hungary . A mysterious disapperance , due to suicideto accident

, , absconding , or ordinary crime , was turned to shameful but most profitable account for political purposes , and in fact created the po . litical reputation of the aroh-apostle of the movement , Thurlow Weed . In his autobiography , Weed naturally adheres to the lie whioh he propagated , but the friendshi p which he boasts of maintaining to the end with those whom he accused , and still posthumously accuses , of the murder , is utterly inconsistent with a genuine belief in the

horrors whioh he relates . As individual and popular force become to an increasing extent repressed by the strong arm of the law , the at . tempt to misdirect that arm itself by false accusations , carefully prepared and placed in a credible li ght by all kinds of lying reports spread abroad in the press , will become more frequent , since whether the charge succeeds or not in the courts , its effect upon the populace is pretty sure to be useful to the party whioh forges the slanderous tale .

The Freemasons were the victims in 1826 in America , as the Jews were recently in Hungary ; and the history of the anti-Masonic feud is full of instruction to ourselves . Weed ' s account of it is warped and coloured to palliate his own disgraceful share in spreading the scandal and obscuring the truth . But practically it is the confession of a Thug . After naively recounting his exploits in bribing the rural

electors of New York with 8 , 000 dollars sent to him one Sunday morning in a large bandana handkerchief , he tells ua that he was at Rochester , New York , editing a paper , when he was asked to print a revelation of the first three degrees in Freemasonry , which a Captain William Morgan had been writing out . The request was refused , on the ground that a partner in the paper was a Freemason .

In the following September intelligence reached Rochester that Captain Morgan , who had removed to Batavia , New York , with his wife , had been spirited away , and that the printed sheets of a book describing the secrets of Freemasonry had also disappeared . Morgan , it seemed , by the interposition of Masons , had been released from temporary detention at Canandaigua . The wife of his gaoler

deposed that she saw and heard him struggling with men who , on his leaving the gaol , forced him into a carriage . About the same time a body of men , supposed to be young Freemasons , attacked and tried to burn the office at which Morgan ' s book was being printed . Many respectable Freemasons , accused of having assisted in the abduction , were brought to trial , in five different counties . Convictions

of John Whitney and others were obtained . The opinion still was that Morgan had only been carried off . In October 1827 , two residents of Carleton , Orleans county , discovered a dead body much decayed on the beach at a point at which the Oak Orchard Creek enters Lake Ontario . An inquest was held , and elicited nothing . When an account of tbe body was received at Rochester , Morgan ' s

acquaintances were convinced the body was his . It was exhumed , and many persons , including Mrs . Morgan , identified it . A jury , among whom was Thurlow Weed , agreed unanimously that it was the body of William Morgan . Almost immediately afterwards information was received that a Canadian , Timothy Munroe , had been drowned in the Niagara River in September 1827 . Masons and

their friends declared the body was his . Once more it was exhumed , in the presence of a crowd of Masons and anti-Masons , and Mrs . Timoth y Munroe was there . The clothes had been preserved , and she was asked to describe those her husband wore . Her description tallied minutely , to a darn , with the clothes of the drowned corpse . But her recollections of her husband ' s body differed . Her husband had been four inches taller , and the colour of his hair was dissimilar .

As Thurlow Weed himself puts it , "The question , as far as it had heen settled testimony , seemed to involve the contradiction , if not the absurdity , of proving that Mnnroe's clothes were found upon the body either of Morgan , or of some unknown person . " The clothes had been worn by Munroe a year after the presumed drowning of a man upon whose body they were found . Thurlow Weed , writing in 1869 , professed , as persuaded in 1829 , that he had actually looked at Carleton on the murdered body of Morgan , He knew how the crime

An Anti-Masonic Agitation.

was committed . He had heard from tho lips of John Whitney , in the presence and with the assent of Colonel Jewett , another Mason , who had been tried for his share in the abduction , that Whitney and others drowned Morgan in Lake Ontario b y direction of the highest Masonio authority , given one evening after those engaged had been " called from labour to refreshment . "

In the Morgan mystery the attempt was to prove that the drowned body was the subject of a murder , and had been clothed in some inexplicable way in another man ' s clothes . In the Tiaza-Eszlar prosecution the allegation was that the bod y discovered in the Theiss was the subject of no murder , and that the clothes it was dressed in , which were the clothes of the supposed victim of Jewish

fanaticism , had been put on it in the design to blind justice . The natural inclination is to deny the murder of Morgan , and to assume tha t he was simply hidden away . If , however , Masons had removed him they would have brought him back to screen their Order from the storm of odium . An easy solution is to adopt the theory of his murder . But then there is the difficulty of the olothes , which had

been apparently worn by a man who survived him . Had Thurlow Weed insinuated that Mrs . Timothy Munroe was in league with the Masons , and falsely feigned to recognize clothes of which she had received a description from accomplices , despair at the dilemma might have tempted to acquiescence . Thurlow Weed ventures upon no such insinuation against Mrs . Munroe's good faith . The result is

an unsolved and insoluble puzzle . AH whioh is apparent is , that Morgan vanished after being subjected , as alleged , to violence from Freemasons , that for several years all the politics of New York State hinged upon his disappearance , and that this was greatly to the advantage of the juryman Thurlow Weed . Weed describes his first attack on the Masons as most moderate . This is from a man who

could never understand how the people whom he libelled in his scandalous prints felt aggrieved , and who forbore , probably with some reason , from taking any proceedings against the Daily Advertiser when it reported that he had pulled out dead Timothy Mnnroe ' s whiskers to identify the face with the shaven cheeks of William Morgan . His accusation , couched in whatever terms , was in itself

an outrage upon Masons . They retorted—perhaps with undue vehemence ; in its earlier stages at least snch a charge is often best snuffed out by silence . Weedstood at bay , and created anti-Masonry . The party of tho anti-Masons revolutionised New York politics ; and elevated Thurlow Weed into a potent political manager . He had always been friendly with Masons . His first political chief

Governor Clinton , was the New York Grand Master . He boasts that his personal relations with a prominent person among the accused , Colonel Jewett , were scarcely disturbed dnring the bitterest days of the controversy . He wrote to John Whitney , one , as he affects to believe , of tbe direct murderers , who had been actually convicted of the abduction , as his " dear old friend . " But his were the counsels

which guided the campaign against Freemasonry . Although he confesses that his efforts failed to render secret societies in general unpopular , he succeeded for a time in raising up a mighty combination against Freemasonry . He did more . On anti-Masonry he founded a political organisation , which fought for John Quincy Adams against General Jackson , clouded the prospects of Mr . Clay ,

who was himself a Mason , and was felt in every public relation of the State until the purposes of its existence were exhausted , and it merged in 1833 in Thurlow Weed ' s Whig party . Thus the accusation " paid" very well for a time , although it entitles its author or main advocate to lasting infamy . He was not ultimately prosperous , even from a material point of view . —Jeivish Chronicle .

Bro . Seymour Smith's annual benefit concert at the South-place Institute , Moorgate-street , on Saturday last , was a great success . The programme was both lengthy and varied , and the number and quality of the artistes were above the average . Amid such a host of talent it is

difficult to do justice , especially when all did so well . We could say a good word for every item in the programme , but as our space is limited , we can only indulge in two or three references to performances that struck us as being particularly pleasing . The " Drummer Boy ' s Song , " by Miss

Heath , was one of these ; another was " In cellar cool , ' by Mr . Albert Hubbard ; a third was "Dorothy ' s Diary , " by Miss Maud Cameron ; and still another , the " Sands o' Dee , " by Mr . Arthur Thompson , was particularly fascinating . Of course , the beneficiaire contributed to the pleasure of the

audience , and the talent who assisted him , in addition to the names already given , were , vocalists—Miss Meta Russell and Madame Raymond , Messrs . Lester , James , Lord , G . T . Carter , F . H . Cozens , C . A . White , and Chaplin Henry . Instrumentalists—Madame Brett , Miss

Evelyn Seymour Smith , Miss Dunbar Perkins , Messrs . Michael Watson , W . Morrow , Richard Blagrove , and F . A . Jewson . Most , if not all , of the male performers are members of the Craft , and their services were highly appreciated by a numerous and appreciative audience .

HOILOWAT ' DIMMEST AITD FILIS . —Rheumatism and Gont . —These purifying and soothing remedies demand the earnest attention of all persons liable to gout , sciatica , or other painful affections of the muscles , nerves , or joints . The Ointment should be applied after the affected parts have been patiently fomented with warm water , when the unguent should be diligently rubbed

upon the adjacent tkin , unless the friction should cause pain . Holloway s Pills should be simultaneously taken to reduce inflammation and to purify the blood . This treatment abates the violence , and lessens the frequency of gout , rheumatism , and all spasmodic diseases , which spring from hereditary predisposition , or from any accidental weakness of constitution . This Ointment checks the local remedy . Tho Pills restore tne vital powers .

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1883-10-27, Page 3” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 25 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_27101883/page/3/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
POOR CANDIDATES AND THE VOTING SYSTEM. Article 1
THE GRAND TREASURERSHIP. Article 2
HIGH DEGREES. Article 2
AN ANTI-MASONIC AGITATION. Article 3
MARK MASONRY. Article 4
CONSECRATION OF A MARK LODGE IN DOUGLAS. Article 4
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 5
PROVINCE OF WE&T YORKSHIRE. Article 6
MADAME WORRELL'S ANNUAL CONCERT. Article 6
THE HOLBORN RESTAURANT. Article 7
"MASONIC WORLD" AND MEMPHIS RITE. Article 7
NEW MUSIC. Article 7
THE LODGE HOME OF MASONS. Article 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
RANDOM NOTES AND REFLECTIONS. Article 8
INSTALLATION MEETINGS, &c. Article 9
ELEANOR CROSS LODGE, No. 1764. Article 9
BLACKHEATH LODGE, No. 1320. Article 10
ST GEORGE'S LODGE, No 1723. Article 10
Untitled Ad 11
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 12
THE PURIFICATION OF SEWAGE. Article 13
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR. Article 13
THE FIFTEEN SECTIONS Article 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

4 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

5 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

10 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

4 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

4 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

6 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

5 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

12 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

16 Articles
Page 3

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

High Degrees.

posed io each other , assume to confer the same high degrees . Then , when onepartyexcommunicates theother , and exposes all of its naughtiness , and the other retorts and exposes the naughtiness of the first , Brethren of Solomonic wisdom smile , and congratulate themselves upon the fact that ,

after all , they themselves possess the much coveted and truly genuine "highest and last degree , " about which there can be no contention as to its regularity or antiquity . Brethren should manifest their appreciation of tho only ancient and universally accepted degrees , including as they

do the highest of all , by diligent attendance at the meetings of the respective Masonic bodies in which they are conferred . Always do full justice , first to your Lodge and Chapter ; and afterwards devote what time you may to other bodies . The former are entitled to your loyal and

cordial allegiance . They made you , Masonically , what you are ; they include in their membership the entire Masonic family ; they are elevated , dignified , and enlightened ; and search where you will , go where you may , you can find outside of them no higher degree . —Keystone . ¦

An Anti-Masonic Agitation.

AN ANTI-MASONIC AGITATION .

fTIHAT unscrupulous party . manager , wire puller and corrupter of -i- popular constituencies , Thurlow Weed , who had more actions for libel brought against him than any editor in America , gives an account in his autobiograph y , recently published at Boston , of an anti . Masonio movement in New York State whioh has , as a Times reviewer remarks , a curious resemblance to the anti Semitic agitation in Hungary . A mysterious disapperance , due to suicideto accident

, , absconding , or ordinary crime , was turned to shameful but most profitable account for political purposes , and in fact created the po . litical reputation of the aroh-apostle of the movement , Thurlow Weed . In his autobiography , Weed naturally adheres to the lie whioh he propagated , but the friendshi p which he boasts of maintaining to the end with those whom he accused , and still posthumously accuses , of the murder , is utterly inconsistent with a genuine belief in the

horrors whioh he relates . As individual and popular force become to an increasing extent repressed by the strong arm of the law , the at . tempt to misdirect that arm itself by false accusations , carefully prepared and placed in a credible li ght by all kinds of lying reports spread abroad in the press , will become more frequent , since whether the charge succeeds or not in the courts , its effect upon the populace is pretty sure to be useful to the party whioh forges the slanderous tale .

The Freemasons were the victims in 1826 in America , as the Jews were recently in Hungary ; and the history of the anti-Masonic feud is full of instruction to ourselves . Weed ' s account of it is warped and coloured to palliate his own disgraceful share in spreading the scandal and obscuring the truth . But practically it is the confession of a Thug . After naively recounting his exploits in bribing the rural

electors of New York with 8 , 000 dollars sent to him one Sunday morning in a large bandana handkerchief , he tells ua that he was at Rochester , New York , editing a paper , when he was asked to print a revelation of the first three degrees in Freemasonry , which a Captain William Morgan had been writing out . The request was refused , on the ground that a partner in the paper was a Freemason .

In the following September intelligence reached Rochester that Captain Morgan , who had removed to Batavia , New York , with his wife , had been spirited away , and that the printed sheets of a book describing the secrets of Freemasonry had also disappeared . Morgan , it seemed , by the interposition of Masons , had been released from temporary detention at Canandaigua . The wife of his gaoler

deposed that she saw and heard him struggling with men who , on his leaving the gaol , forced him into a carriage . About the same time a body of men , supposed to be young Freemasons , attacked and tried to burn the office at which Morgan ' s book was being printed . Many respectable Freemasons , accused of having assisted in the abduction , were brought to trial , in five different counties . Convictions

of John Whitney and others were obtained . The opinion still was that Morgan had only been carried off . In October 1827 , two residents of Carleton , Orleans county , discovered a dead body much decayed on the beach at a point at which the Oak Orchard Creek enters Lake Ontario . An inquest was held , and elicited nothing . When an account of tbe body was received at Rochester , Morgan ' s

acquaintances were convinced the body was his . It was exhumed , and many persons , including Mrs . Morgan , identified it . A jury , among whom was Thurlow Weed , agreed unanimously that it was the body of William Morgan . Almost immediately afterwards information was received that a Canadian , Timothy Munroe , had been drowned in the Niagara River in September 1827 . Masons and

their friends declared the body was his . Once more it was exhumed , in the presence of a crowd of Masons and anti-Masons , and Mrs . Timoth y Munroe was there . The clothes had been preserved , and she was asked to describe those her husband wore . Her description tallied minutely , to a darn , with the clothes of the drowned corpse . But her recollections of her husband ' s body differed . Her husband had been four inches taller , and the colour of his hair was dissimilar .

As Thurlow Weed himself puts it , "The question , as far as it had heen settled testimony , seemed to involve the contradiction , if not the absurdity , of proving that Mnnroe's clothes were found upon the body either of Morgan , or of some unknown person . " The clothes had been worn by Munroe a year after the presumed drowning of a man upon whose body they were found . Thurlow Weed , writing in 1869 , professed , as persuaded in 1829 , that he had actually looked at Carleton on the murdered body of Morgan , He knew how the crime

An Anti-Masonic Agitation.

was committed . He had heard from tho lips of John Whitney , in the presence and with the assent of Colonel Jewett , another Mason , who had been tried for his share in the abduction , that Whitney and others drowned Morgan in Lake Ontario b y direction of the highest Masonio authority , given one evening after those engaged had been " called from labour to refreshment . "

In the Morgan mystery the attempt was to prove that the drowned body was the subject of a murder , and had been clothed in some inexplicable way in another man ' s clothes . In the Tiaza-Eszlar prosecution the allegation was that the bod y discovered in the Theiss was the subject of no murder , and that the clothes it was dressed in , which were the clothes of the supposed victim of Jewish

fanaticism , had been put on it in the design to blind justice . The natural inclination is to deny the murder of Morgan , and to assume tha t he was simply hidden away . If , however , Masons had removed him they would have brought him back to screen their Order from the storm of odium . An easy solution is to adopt the theory of his murder . But then there is the difficulty of the olothes , which had

been apparently worn by a man who survived him . Had Thurlow Weed insinuated that Mrs . Timothy Munroe was in league with the Masons , and falsely feigned to recognize clothes of which she had received a description from accomplices , despair at the dilemma might have tempted to acquiescence . Thurlow Weed ventures upon no such insinuation against Mrs . Munroe's good faith . The result is

an unsolved and insoluble puzzle . AH whioh is apparent is , that Morgan vanished after being subjected , as alleged , to violence from Freemasons , that for several years all the politics of New York State hinged upon his disappearance , and that this was greatly to the advantage of the juryman Thurlow Weed . Weed describes his first attack on the Masons as most moderate . This is from a man who

could never understand how the people whom he libelled in his scandalous prints felt aggrieved , and who forbore , probably with some reason , from taking any proceedings against the Daily Advertiser when it reported that he had pulled out dead Timothy Mnnroe ' s whiskers to identify the face with the shaven cheeks of William Morgan . His accusation , couched in whatever terms , was in itself

an outrage upon Masons . They retorted—perhaps with undue vehemence ; in its earlier stages at least snch a charge is often best snuffed out by silence . Weedstood at bay , and created anti-Masonry . The party of tho anti-Masons revolutionised New York politics ; and elevated Thurlow Weed into a potent political manager . He had always been friendly with Masons . His first political chief

Governor Clinton , was the New York Grand Master . He boasts that his personal relations with a prominent person among the accused , Colonel Jewett , were scarcely disturbed dnring the bitterest days of the controversy . He wrote to John Whitney , one , as he affects to believe , of tbe direct murderers , who had been actually convicted of the abduction , as his " dear old friend . " But his were the counsels

which guided the campaign against Freemasonry . Although he confesses that his efforts failed to render secret societies in general unpopular , he succeeded for a time in raising up a mighty combination against Freemasonry . He did more . On anti-Masonry he founded a political organisation , which fought for John Quincy Adams against General Jackson , clouded the prospects of Mr . Clay ,

who was himself a Mason , and was felt in every public relation of the State until the purposes of its existence were exhausted , and it merged in 1833 in Thurlow Weed ' s Whig party . Thus the accusation " paid" very well for a time , although it entitles its author or main advocate to lasting infamy . He was not ultimately prosperous , even from a material point of view . —Jeivish Chronicle .

Bro . Seymour Smith's annual benefit concert at the South-place Institute , Moorgate-street , on Saturday last , was a great success . The programme was both lengthy and varied , and the number and quality of the artistes were above the average . Amid such a host of talent it is

difficult to do justice , especially when all did so well . We could say a good word for every item in the programme , but as our space is limited , we can only indulge in two or three references to performances that struck us as being particularly pleasing . The " Drummer Boy ' s Song , " by Miss

Heath , was one of these ; another was " In cellar cool , ' by Mr . Albert Hubbard ; a third was "Dorothy ' s Diary , " by Miss Maud Cameron ; and still another , the " Sands o' Dee , " by Mr . Arthur Thompson , was particularly fascinating . Of course , the beneficiaire contributed to the pleasure of the

audience , and the talent who assisted him , in addition to the names already given , were , vocalists—Miss Meta Russell and Madame Raymond , Messrs . Lester , James , Lord , G . T . Carter , F . H . Cozens , C . A . White , and Chaplin Henry . Instrumentalists—Madame Brett , Miss

Evelyn Seymour Smith , Miss Dunbar Perkins , Messrs . Michael Watson , W . Morrow , Richard Blagrove , and F . A . Jewson . Most , if not all , of the male performers are members of the Craft , and their services were highly appreciated by a numerous and appreciative audience .

HOILOWAT ' DIMMEST AITD FILIS . —Rheumatism and Gont . —These purifying and soothing remedies demand the earnest attention of all persons liable to gout , sciatica , or other painful affections of the muscles , nerves , or joints . The Ointment should be applied after the affected parts have been patiently fomented with warm water , when the unguent should be diligently rubbed

upon the adjacent tkin , unless the friction should cause pain . Holloway s Pills should be simultaneously taken to reduce inflammation and to purify the blood . This treatment abates the violence , and lessens the frequency of gout , rheumatism , and all spasmodic diseases , which spring from hereditary predisposition , or from any accidental weakness of constitution . This Ointment checks the local remedy . Tho Pills restore tne vital powers .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 2
  • You're on page3
  • 4
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy