Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Sept. 16, 1882
  • Page 9
  • MASSACHUSETTS AND THE RITE OF MEMPHIS.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Sept. 16, 1882: Page 9

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Sept. 16, 1882
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article MASSACHUSETTS AND THE RITE OF MEMPHIS. ← Page 2 of 3
    Article MASSACHUSETTS AND THE RITE OF MEMPHIS. Page 2 of 3 →
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Massachusetts And The Rite Of Memphis.

United States , and the Councils under their jurisdiction , tho Grand Encampment of the United States , the Grand Commanderies of the geveral States and Territories of the United States , and the Commanderies under their jurisdiction , the Supreme Councils of the

Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite for the Northern and Southern Jurisdictions of the United States , of which Henry L . Palmer and Albert Pike are M . P . Sov . Grand Commanders , respectively , and the various bodies under their jurisdiction ;

Now , therefore , ifc is hereby declared that any Mason who is hereafter admitted in this jurisdiction , into any other Orders , as Masonio , whether called the Rite of Memphis or by any other name , is acting nn-Masonically ; and for such conduct shall be liable to be expelled from all the rights and privileges of Masonry , and shall be ineligible to membership or office in this Grand Lodge .

Sect . 25 . —Any Mason in this jurisdiction who shall hawk and sell any of the degrees , so-called , hereinbefore forbidden , calling them degrees in Masonry , may be expelled from all the rights and privileges of Masonry .

Prior to taking the vote , remarks were made by a number of eminent brethren , and the following letters were read from distin . gnished Masons of other jurisdictions . These letters are interesting in themselves , and contain information worthy of permanently being placed on record : —

Letter of Brother E . T . Carson . I thank you for calling my attention to the proposed amendment to the Constitution of the Grand Lodge of Massachusetts in relation to spurious Masonic systems , grades , & c . Your Grand Master puts the case in most elegant and forcible style , and I hope you may

succeed in adopting the proposed rule , though I anticipate thafc you will encounter stubborn opposition . Our Grand Lodge adopted a resolution , more than thirty years ago , against the conferring of side degrees in Ohio , and that resolntion has kept ont of Ohio all those Masonio charlatans who peddle the

" Eastern Star , " Heroine of Jericho , " " Master Mason ' s Daughter , " & o . & c . Then our Grand Commandery has substantially such a law as the one proposed , and it has done ns a " power of good . " It is the dnty of the ] Grand Bodies to protect the less-informed brethren from

being preyed upon by those Masonio buzzards , who are continually on the alert to turn an " honest penny " by selling so-called Masonio degrees . If Massachusetts adopts this rule it will give the idea a start , and a standing that will ultimately result in much good to genuine , honest Masonry . Truly and fraternally yours , E . T . Carson .

Letter from J . P . C . Cottrill , Past Grand Master of Wisconsin . Tho first difficulty we had in Wisconsin concerning these outside Bodies , claiming to be Masonic and yet ont of the pale , was in 1870 . Then certain Knights Templar concluded to unite with the Rite of Memphis . It is , of course , a perfectly spurious concern , nofc Masonic or known to Masonry . I was offered their rituals free several vears

ago by Harry J . Seymour , of New York , he understanding thafc I was a 32 ° Mason . I declined his offer . Tho action of our Grand Commandery abont it is found on page 46 , Proceedings of 1870 . Further action was had . See Grand Commandery Proceedings , 1872 , pages 53 and 56 ; 1873 , page 12 . This squelched the Rite of Memphis bnsiness .

In 1875 the Eastern Star bnsiness broke onfc here while I was Grand Master . I effectually broke that up . See my Address to the Grand Lodge , in its Proceedings for 1875 , page 11 . You will observe that I reported that your Grand Lodge , iu 1871 , took similar action , aud my decision was based in part upon that action . I hope you will suppress all these spurious concerns , and that your

constitutional amendment may be adopted . A Masonic Grand Lodge has in my opinion , the clear right to prevent , by discipline , if necessary the uniting by Masons with spurious Masonic Bodies , or Bodies calling themselves Masonic without authority , and to declare and determine just what are , and just what are not regularly constituted Masonic Bodies . Yours fraternally , J . P . C . Cottrill .

Letter from Bro . R . F . G Gould , author of " The Pour Olcl Lodges . " Here in England , we , i . e ., the Grand Lodge , affect not to know anything about degrees outside the Royal Arch . No Mason can wear any insignia in Lodge or Chapter beyond that of Royal Arch . . Of late years the influence of " high degree" Brethren has

increased , owing chiefly no doubt to the Prince of Wales being one ° f that class , but althongh our Craft rulers aro nearly all ( i . e ., in tho leading positions ) members of what is termed tbe A . and A . ¦"' ite , the avoidance of public displays , processions , & c , in this country results in no clashing occurring , " or my own part , thongh opposed very strongly on principle to

oi !? ' ' ; ension of tho Masonic system , I must admit that our leading « 3 men are most earnest and devoted Masons . « , M urray Lyon gives some facts respecting the introduction of the "high degrees" into Scotland . See his invaluable "History of ™ o Lodge of Edinburgh ( Mary ' s Chapel ) , No . 1 . " # In Ireland I believe , the Grand Master is always the head of all

* H ) ds of degrees . ¦ for my own part I have been ever of opinion thafc if we can adopt tl ?^ . ckildren , so equally can we adopt Masonic ancestors , and if ie thirt y-third degree by any process of reasoning can be termed asonic , so in similar fashion can the Ancient Mysteries . According to my view the so-called " high degrees " are pernici .

Massachusetts And The Rite Of Memphis.

ous . Still , many people think otherwise , and oura like yours is a free country ! In great baste , Yours truly and fraternally , R . F . Gould .

Letter from Brother J . G . Findel , author of the "History of Freemasonry . " Your friendly communications and the amendments to your Grand Lodge Constitutions I have received , and was very muoh rejoiced . It is a step in the right way . Under the present circumstances I must also approve the moderate , prudent and careful mode in which

the Grand Lodge is moving . Relating to your questions , I can inform you thafc there is no Grand Lodge in Germany , except the Grand Country Lodge of Germany ( Swedish Rite ) , at Berlin , whioh haa as suca any control over higher degrees . The Grand Lodgo of the Sun at Bayreuth ( Bavaria ) , thafc of Concord afc Darmstadt , the Eclectic Union of

Frankfort , that of Saxony , of Hamburg and Royal York afc Berlin , i . e ., six Grand Lodges of Germany , do not acknowledge at all any higher degree or practice any . They are only Symbolic Grand Lodges , and their subordinate Lodges work only in the three blue , or ancient degrees , in which , to our conviction , Masonry is contained and finished . There is no step higher than to be a Master Mason .

The Grand Lodge of the three Globes at Berlin , has , besides the Grand Lodge , a Scottish Directory , with some so-called Scottish degrees . But these higher degrees , separated from Grand Lodge , have not the significance of higher degrees , but serve only as a mode of information and instrnction . Many subordinate Lodges of the Grand Lodge of the Three Globes do not cultivate these Scottish

degrees . The essence of the Swedish Rite ( Grand Country Lodge of Germany ) , with nine degrees , yon may find described in my " History of Freemasonry . " Till now it was the only Rite practised in Sweden , Denmark , and Berlin , bufc at present there is a movement going on in Norway to put it aside , and to come back to pure ancient

Masonry , with its three degrees . The Grand Lodge of the three Globes , which has some instructing Scottish degrees , has , nevertheless , concerning the so-called Grand Constitntions of the Scottish Rite of thirty . three degrees , declared that they are " the grand lie of the Fraternity . " I suppose you have in your Library the English edition of my

" History of Freemasonry . " There you may find all you want . No higher degree of any name can prove its usefulness , or any legitimate historical source from which it has sprung . All higher degrees are a pious fraud and humbug . Your Grand Lodge will do a great service to the Craft when it stops the movement for higher degrees .

The Grand Lodge of Switzerland , "Alpina , has also none of these degrees , and works" only in the three degrees , also the Grand Lodge of Hungary . Hoping that these notes may be in some way useful to you , I send you , for your Grand Lodge , the best wishes , and I am , Most fraternally yours , J . G . Findel .

Letter from Bro . William James Hughan , Past Senior G . Deacon of the Grand Lodge of England . I see that your Grand Lodge is to consider the question of the " higher degrees , " as they are sometimes called , on fche 14 th prox . ; so I send you a brief account of the laws and customs in relation thereto , prevalent in England , Ireland , and Scotland .

1 . The Grand Lodge of England , established in 1717 , recognised no degrees beyond the " Master Mason " until December 1813 , when , for the sake of harmony aud tinion , ifc agreed to adopt the " Royal Arch , " as the concluding part of the third degree ( nofc as a fourth ) , which was so warmly adopted by the seceders or " Ancients , " from their origin , about 1750 , and , as you know , united them with the

latter Body . Thereafter we have had but the one Grand Lodge in this country , the York Grand Lodge , and its offshoot in London , having previously expired . The "Articles of Union" provided : "II . Ifc is declared and pronounced thafc pare Ancient Masonry consists of three degrees , and no more , namely , these of the Entered Apprentice

the Fellow Craffc , and the Master Mason , including the Supreme Order of fche Holy Royal Arch . But this article is not intended to prevent any Lodge or Chapter from holding a meeting in any of the degrees of the Orders of Chivalry , according to the Constitutions of the said Orders . " ( Hnghan's Masonio Register 1878 , P 15 ) .

The first part of this declaration is to be found in the present " Book of Constitutions " ( 1873 ) , as introductory to the first of the Rules . The second portion it is not easy now exactly to understand , and I must say it is rather feeely explained to mean all the degrees termed Masonic , other than the first three and the Royal Arch , which were working in A . D . 1813 .

Taking the example set by onr chief brethren , or at least very many of them , there are virtually four Masonic organisations quasi recognised by the Grand Lodge , but not actually so , and nothing is allowed to be worn in the Grand Lodge , or any subordinate Lodgo which appertains to degrees , other than those allowed by the Grand

Lodge , viz ., the three degrees , including the Royal Arch . I mnch lament the puerile rage after useless pseudo-Masonic decorations . ( a ) Grand Lodge Mark Master Masons , * of whom the Lord Henniker is the Grand Master , and of its Past Grand Masters may be named the Earl of Carnarvon Pro G . M . of England , the Earl of Lathom Dep . G . M . of England , and several Provincial Grand Masters , the

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1882-09-16, Page 9” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 23 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_16091882/page/9/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
RETURNING- TO WORK. Article 1
ROYAL COLLEGE OF MUSIC. Article 2
MASONIC LITERATURE. Article 2
ROYAL ARCH. Article 3
Untitled Ad 3
LODGE HISTORIES. Article 4
Untitled Article 4
REVIEWS. Article 5
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 5
LODGE OF LOYALTY, No. 1607. Article 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
THE THEATRES, &c. Article 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
MASSACHUSETTS AND THE RITE OF MEMPHIS. Article 8
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 10
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 11
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

4 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

6 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

12 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

8 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

14 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

14 Articles
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Massachusetts And The Rite Of Memphis.

United States , and the Councils under their jurisdiction , tho Grand Encampment of the United States , the Grand Commanderies of the geveral States and Territories of the United States , and the Commanderies under their jurisdiction , the Supreme Councils of the

Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite for the Northern and Southern Jurisdictions of the United States , of which Henry L . Palmer and Albert Pike are M . P . Sov . Grand Commanders , respectively , and the various bodies under their jurisdiction ;

Now , therefore , ifc is hereby declared that any Mason who is hereafter admitted in this jurisdiction , into any other Orders , as Masonio , whether called the Rite of Memphis or by any other name , is acting nn-Masonically ; and for such conduct shall be liable to be expelled from all the rights and privileges of Masonry , and shall be ineligible to membership or office in this Grand Lodge .

Sect . 25 . —Any Mason in this jurisdiction who shall hawk and sell any of the degrees , so-called , hereinbefore forbidden , calling them degrees in Masonry , may be expelled from all the rights and privileges of Masonry .

Prior to taking the vote , remarks were made by a number of eminent brethren , and the following letters were read from distin . gnished Masons of other jurisdictions . These letters are interesting in themselves , and contain information worthy of permanently being placed on record : —

Letter of Brother E . T . Carson . I thank you for calling my attention to the proposed amendment to the Constitution of the Grand Lodge of Massachusetts in relation to spurious Masonic systems , grades , & c . Your Grand Master puts the case in most elegant and forcible style , and I hope you may

succeed in adopting the proposed rule , though I anticipate thafc you will encounter stubborn opposition . Our Grand Lodge adopted a resolution , more than thirty years ago , against the conferring of side degrees in Ohio , and that resolntion has kept ont of Ohio all those Masonio charlatans who peddle the

" Eastern Star , " Heroine of Jericho , " " Master Mason ' s Daughter , " & o . & c . Then our Grand Commandery has substantially such a law as the one proposed , and it has done ns a " power of good . " It is the dnty of the ] Grand Bodies to protect the less-informed brethren from

being preyed upon by those Masonio buzzards , who are continually on the alert to turn an " honest penny " by selling so-called Masonio degrees . If Massachusetts adopts this rule it will give the idea a start , and a standing that will ultimately result in much good to genuine , honest Masonry . Truly and fraternally yours , E . T . Carson .

Letter from J . P . C . Cottrill , Past Grand Master of Wisconsin . Tho first difficulty we had in Wisconsin concerning these outside Bodies , claiming to be Masonic and yet ont of the pale , was in 1870 . Then certain Knights Templar concluded to unite with the Rite of Memphis . It is , of course , a perfectly spurious concern , nofc Masonic or known to Masonry . I was offered their rituals free several vears

ago by Harry J . Seymour , of New York , he understanding thafc I was a 32 ° Mason . I declined his offer . Tho action of our Grand Commandery abont it is found on page 46 , Proceedings of 1870 . Further action was had . See Grand Commandery Proceedings , 1872 , pages 53 and 56 ; 1873 , page 12 . This squelched the Rite of Memphis bnsiness .

In 1875 the Eastern Star bnsiness broke onfc here while I was Grand Master . I effectually broke that up . See my Address to the Grand Lodge , in its Proceedings for 1875 , page 11 . You will observe that I reported that your Grand Lodge , iu 1871 , took similar action , aud my decision was based in part upon that action . I hope you will suppress all these spurious concerns , and that your

constitutional amendment may be adopted . A Masonic Grand Lodge has in my opinion , the clear right to prevent , by discipline , if necessary the uniting by Masons with spurious Masonic Bodies , or Bodies calling themselves Masonic without authority , and to declare and determine just what are , and just what are not regularly constituted Masonic Bodies . Yours fraternally , J . P . C . Cottrill .

Letter from Bro . R . F . G Gould , author of " The Pour Olcl Lodges . " Here in England , we , i . e ., the Grand Lodge , affect not to know anything about degrees outside the Royal Arch . No Mason can wear any insignia in Lodge or Chapter beyond that of Royal Arch . . Of late years the influence of " high degree" Brethren has

increased , owing chiefly no doubt to the Prince of Wales being one ° f that class , but althongh our Craft rulers aro nearly all ( i . e ., in tho leading positions ) members of what is termed tbe A . and A . ¦"' ite , the avoidance of public displays , processions , & c , in this country results in no clashing occurring , " or my own part , thongh opposed very strongly on principle to

oi !? ' ' ; ension of tho Masonic system , I must admit that our leading « 3 men are most earnest and devoted Masons . « , M urray Lyon gives some facts respecting the introduction of the "high degrees" into Scotland . See his invaluable "History of ™ o Lodge of Edinburgh ( Mary ' s Chapel ) , No . 1 . " # In Ireland I believe , the Grand Master is always the head of all

* H ) ds of degrees . ¦ for my own part I have been ever of opinion thafc if we can adopt tl ?^ . ckildren , so equally can we adopt Masonic ancestors , and if ie thirt y-third degree by any process of reasoning can be termed asonic , so in similar fashion can the Ancient Mysteries . According to my view the so-called " high degrees " are pernici .

Massachusetts And The Rite Of Memphis.

ous . Still , many people think otherwise , and oura like yours is a free country ! In great baste , Yours truly and fraternally , R . F . Gould .

Letter from Brother J . G . Findel , author of the "History of Freemasonry . " Your friendly communications and the amendments to your Grand Lodge Constitutions I have received , and was very muoh rejoiced . It is a step in the right way . Under the present circumstances I must also approve the moderate , prudent and careful mode in which

the Grand Lodge is moving . Relating to your questions , I can inform you thafc there is no Grand Lodge in Germany , except the Grand Country Lodge of Germany ( Swedish Rite ) , at Berlin , whioh haa as suca any control over higher degrees . The Grand Lodgo of the Sun at Bayreuth ( Bavaria ) , thafc of Concord afc Darmstadt , the Eclectic Union of

Frankfort , that of Saxony , of Hamburg and Royal York afc Berlin , i . e ., six Grand Lodges of Germany , do not acknowledge at all any higher degree or practice any . They are only Symbolic Grand Lodges , and their subordinate Lodges work only in the three blue , or ancient degrees , in which , to our conviction , Masonry is contained and finished . There is no step higher than to be a Master Mason .

The Grand Lodge of the three Globes at Berlin , has , besides the Grand Lodge , a Scottish Directory , with some so-called Scottish degrees . But these higher degrees , separated from Grand Lodge , have not the significance of higher degrees , but serve only as a mode of information and instrnction . Many subordinate Lodges of the Grand Lodge of the Three Globes do not cultivate these Scottish

degrees . The essence of the Swedish Rite ( Grand Country Lodge of Germany ) , with nine degrees , yon may find described in my " History of Freemasonry . " Till now it was the only Rite practised in Sweden , Denmark , and Berlin , bufc at present there is a movement going on in Norway to put it aside , and to come back to pure ancient

Masonry , with its three degrees . The Grand Lodge of the three Globes , which has some instructing Scottish degrees , has , nevertheless , concerning the so-called Grand Constitntions of the Scottish Rite of thirty . three degrees , declared that they are " the grand lie of the Fraternity . " I suppose you have in your Library the English edition of my

" History of Freemasonry . " There you may find all you want . No higher degree of any name can prove its usefulness , or any legitimate historical source from which it has sprung . All higher degrees are a pious fraud and humbug . Your Grand Lodge will do a great service to the Craft when it stops the movement for higher degrees .

The Grand Lodge of Switzerland , "Alpina , has also none of these degrees , and works" only in the three degrees , also the Grand Lodge of Hungary . Hoping that these notes may be in some way useful to you , I send you , for your Grand Lodge , the best wishes , and I am , Most fraternally yours , J . G . Findel .

Letter from Bro . William James Hughan , Past Senior G . Deacon of the Grand Lodge of England . I see that your Grand Lodge is to consider the question of the " higher degrees , " as they are sometimes called , on fche 14 th prox . ; so I send you a brief account of the laws and customs in relation thereto , prevalent in England , Ireland , and Scotland .

1 . The Grand Lodge of England , established in 1717 , recognised no degrees beyond the " Master Mason " until December 1813 , when , for the sake of harmony aud tinion , ifc agreed to adopt the " Royal Arch , " as the concluding part of the third degree ( nofc as a fourth ) , which was so warmly adopted by the seceders or " Ancients , " from their origin , about 1750 , and , as you know , united them with the

latter Body . Thereafter we have had but the one Grand Lodge in this country , the York Grand Lodge , and its offshoot in London , having previously expired . The "Articles of Union" provided : "II . Ifc is declared and pronounced thafc pare Ancient Masonry consists of three degrees , and no more , namely , these of the Entered Apprentice

the Fellow Craffc , and the Master Mason , including the Supreme Order of fche Holy Royal Arch . But this article is not intended to prevent any Lodge or Chapter from holding a meeting in any of the degrees of the Orders of Chivalry , according to the Constitutions of the said Orders . " ( Hnghan's Masonio Register 1878 , P 15 ) .

The first part of this declaration is to be found in the present " Book of Constitutions " ( 1873 ) , as introductory to the first of the Rules . The second portion it is not easy now exactly to understand , and I must say it is rather feeely explained to mean all the degrees termed Masonic , other than the first three and the Royal Arch , which were working in A . D . 1813 .

Taking the example set by onr chief brethren , or at least very many of them , there are virtually four Masonic organisations quasi recognised by the Grand Lodge , but not actually so , and nothing is allowed to be worn in the Grand Lodge , or any subordinate Lodgo which appertains to degrees , other than those allowed by the Grand

Lodge , viz ., the three degrees , including the Royal Arch . I mnch lament the puerile rage after useless pseudo-Masonic decorations . ( a ) Grand Lodge Mark Master Masons , * of whom the Lord Henniker is the Grand Master , and of its Past Grand Masters may be named the Earl of Carnarvon Pro G . M . of England , the Earl of Lathom Dep . G . M . of England , and several Provincial Grand Masters , the

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 8
  • You're on page9
  • 10
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy