Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Nov. 10, 1877
  • Page 2
  • THE GRAND LODGE OF IRELAND AND THE GRAND ORIENT OF FRANCE.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Nov. 10, 1877: Page 2

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Nov. 10, 1877
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE GRAND LODGE OF IRELAND AND THE GRAND ORIENT OF FRANCE. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article LODGES OF INSTRUCTION. Page 1 of 1
    Article LODGES OF INSTRUCTION. Page 1 of 1
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Grand Lodge Of Ireland And The Grand Orient Of France.

jurisdiction . " This resolution is of a very sweeping character , and doubtless our Irish brethren , if it bo possible , will find somo means of relaxing its stringency in favour of the vciy numerous aud respectable section of French Masons who still , in their heart of heart , stand

firmly by the old and venerated landmarks of the Craft . But , considering that tho Grand Lodge of Ireland interchanged representatives with the Grand Oii ' enfc of France , we do not see how it was possible , albeit tho duty must havo been an exceedingly painful one , for the former to

have pursued any other course . It is indisputable that the Grand Orient , under its amended Constitutions , is not a body of Freemasonry at all , for it denies absolutely , as we havo already shown , one of tho fundamental bases of our Fraternity . Tho spirit of intolerance has no abiding place

among English , Scotch , or Irish Masons . The tolerance we pride ourselves upon is that which recognises all kinds of relig ious and moral virtue ; all else than this we set ourselves sternly against , just as we abhor and remove dirt ,

which has beeu properly defined to bo " matter in tho wrong place . " However , tho whole subject is of such importance that we shall make a point of returning to it again next week .

Lodges Of Instruction.

LODGES OF INSTRUCTION .

WE have more than once offered remarks on the extreme importance of Lodges of Instruction . Their work is done quietly and unostentatiously , but it invariably has the merit of being done satisfactorily , and the results of their labours are always in the very highest degree beneficial . It is indeed well nigh impossible to

determine even approximately the extent of service which a well conducted Lodge of this character is capable of rendering in the cause of Freemasonry . Our Lodges as a rule meet on only a limited number of evenings in tho

course of the year , and unless a brother has a tolerably wide circle of acquaintances in the brotherhood his prospects of acquiring the requisite knowledge of his duties are but few and far between . Indeed one who confined himself to

attending tho regular duties of his Lodge and no other might be a member of the Masonic body for many years and yet acquire but a very slight knowledge of the Craft . Hence the value of Lodges of Instruction , which meeting weekly for a considerable portion of tho year , enable brethren to

acquire in a few months a pretty intimate acquaintance with the ceremonies and lectures . Under these circumstances it will be apparent that ifc is impossible too much can be done to strengthen and confirm their position . At present , as our readers are aware , they are

held cither " under the sanction of a regular warranted Lodge , or by the special licence and authority of the Grand Master . " This afc first sight would seem to be a very proper arrangement , and so far as regards the latter alternative there could not be the slightest possible objection to

it . Even a regular Lodge can derive its existence from no higher authority , and therefore nothing can be more complete or satisfactory than the licence under which a Lodge of Instruction thus authorised fulfils its appointed duties . But it seems to us that something more is needed in the

case of those which derive their being from regularly warranted Lodges . It is true they trace their origin mediately to the Grand Master , but this strikes us as being a somewhat lame arrangement ; at all events , it is one which , in our humble -judgment , is capable of some

improvement , and as all are anxiously striving to better their knowledge of Masonic working , we see no just cause or impediment why Lodges of Instruction should not in all cases be established on a more solid basis . We do not say this for the purpose of offering a suggestion and nothing

more . We have spoken of their great value , and on general grounds we think ifc advisable there should be something further done in order to attach a greater degree of importance to what , after all said and done , arc absolutely indispensable to the welfare of the Craft . It is not , however ,

enough that we should urge a question of this kind on general grounds only . It is far better we should advance some special reasons , and these it is in our power to do .

Let us , in the first place , point out that the existing law would bo absolutel } -, or at all events as nearly as possible , perfect , if every Lodge of Instruction were specially attached to the regular warranted Lodge from which ifc

Lodges Of Instruction.

derives its authority . This , of course , is the case afc present , but only to a very limited extent . Wo mean this . If tho Lodgo of Instruction were composed wholly or in greater part of members of the parent Lodgo , there would then be a most intimate—we may almost describe ifc

as a complete connection between tho two . But our readers know that Lodges of Instruction in London aro composed of members gathered together from all tho four quarters of the metropolis , and what is still moro to our purpose , that tho members of the parent Lodge in many

cases form , as regards mere numbers , but a very feeble minority . It is inevitable , of course , under these circumstances , that the interest which tho Lodgo takes in the working of its Lodge of Instruction is of a feeble and intermittent nature . There is no close tie existing between

them , save and except that of the authorisation granted by tho former to tho latter , an authorisation which may bo withdrawn after due notice given in accordance with the

law . There is , then , as matters now stand , but little interest in common between the two , but this interest would be intensified if the connecting link were appreciably strengthened . This is one of the two alternatives we have before

us ; the other is that all Lodges of Instruction should derive the authority under which they work from the Grand Master alone . Wo see no objection to their remaining , as now , nominally under the wing of what AVO have designated the parent Lodge ; but let them have a special

Warrant of their own , so that they may be directly , as they are now only indirectly , responsible to tho highest authority . Tho law makes the Lodge which issues its sanction and those to Avhom it is issued responsible for the proceedings , and likewise that the Avorking has

been formally recognised by the Grand Master . This is admirable in theory , but when it comes to a matter of practice , we feel bound to say there is but little at tho bottom of it . It strike us the parent Lodge seldom troubles itself about its Lodge of Instruction ; and as the majority of

those who belong to tho latter are not members of the former , any interference on its part , though perfectly legitimate , might lead to many unpleasantnesses . The chance of this happening would be prevented , if the Lodge of Instruction were in all material points independent

of all but the central authority . It must also be borne in mind that in the event of anything causing the dissolution of the parent Lodge , the blow falls likewise on the Lodge of Instruction . Even a less serious calamity than this might cause a disruption of the proceedings in a

Lodge of Instruction . A case occurred not long since , m Avhich a Lodge was suspended for a given period from its functions , and in consequence the Lodge of Instruction Avhich had been sanctioned by it Avas obliged to suspend its operations likewise . This would have caused no slight

inconvenience even in the most central district of London , though it would havo been open to duly qualified members to seek instruction elsewhere in the immediate neighbourhood ; but in the case we are alluding to , the Lodge Avas situate in the outskirts of the metropolis , where Lodges

are more widely scattered . Indeed the nearest Lodge of Instruction Avas distant several miles . This necessarily involved a considerable amount of hardship on brethren Avho had committed no fault , aud amounted , in fact , to the

infliction of punishment on innocent as well as guilty . Such a result can never have been contemplated by tho authorities , nor could it possibly happen Avere all Lodges of Instruction directly sanctioned by the Grand Master . Considering the amount of useful work these homes of

Masonic education are doing , we do not think they can be too carefully fostered by those in high places . There is one other plan by which the end we have in view might bo equally well secured . Let the Emulation Lodge of Improvement be directly sanctioned by the Grand Master Avith full

power to authorise all other Lodges of Instruction in the Metropolitan district . This would have the two-fold advantage of saving additional labour at Freemasons' Hall and of placing all Lodges of this kind under ono central

authority . As this only occurred to us at the moment of Avriting , Ave do not wish to lay particular stress upon it . One thing is certain : too much cannot be done to guard those Lodges from any interruption , especially of the character we have mentioned , in the course of their labours .

ERRATUM . —In onr footnote to pago 290 of last week ' s issue ( article Forewarned—Forearmed ) , Chapter 1 G 2 should bo 1 G 0 , i . e ., tho Temperance .

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1877-11-10, Page 2” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 4 Aug. 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_10111877/page/2/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE GRAND LODGE OF IRELAND AND THE GRAND ORIENT OF FRANCE. Article 1
LODGES OF INSTRUCTION. Article 2
FACTS DEDUCED FROM MASSACHUSETTS MASONIC MSS. Article 3
CENTENARY BANQUET OF THE YORK LODGE, No. 236. Article 3
PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF WILTSHIRE. Article 4
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 5
THE SPHINX CHAPTER, No. 1329. Article 6
GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND. Article 6
THE FIFTEEN SECTIONS. Article 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
OUR WEEKLY BUDGET. Article 8
PERIODICAL LITERATURE. Article 10
Old Warrants. Article 10
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 11
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 12
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
LIST OF RARE & VALUABLE WORKS ON FREEMASONRY, Article 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

4 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

6 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

4 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

11 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

18 Articles
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Grand Lodge Of Ireland And The Grand Orient Of France.

jurisdiction . " This resolution is of a very sweeping character , and doubtless our Irish brethren , if it bo possible , will find somo means of relaxing its stringency in favour of the vciy numerous aud respectable section of French Masons who still , in their heart of heart , stand

firmly by the old and venerated landmarks of the Craft . But , considering that tho Grand Lodge of Ireland interchanged representatives with the Grand Oii ' enfc of France , we do not see how it was possible , albeit tho duty must havo been an exceedingly painful one , for the former to

have pursued any other course . It is indisputable that the Grand Orient , under its amended Constitutions , is not a body of Freemasonry at all , for it denies absolutely , as we havo already shown , one of tho fundamental bases of our Fraternity . Tho spirit of intolerance has no abiding place

among English , Scotch , or Irish Masons . The tolerance we pride ourselves upon is that which recognises all kinds of relig ious and moral virtue ; all else than this we set ourselves sternly against , just as we abhor and remove dirt ,

which has beeu properly defined to bo " matter in tho wrong place . " However , tho whole subject is of such importance that we shall make a point of returning to it again next week .

Lodges Of Instruction.

LODGES OF INSTRUCTION .

WE have more than once offered remarks on the extreme importance of Lodges of Instruction . Their work is done quietly and unostentatiously , but it invariably has the merit of being done satisfactorily , and the results of their labours are always in the very highest degree beneficial . It is indeed well nigh impossible to

determine even approximately the extent of service which a well conducted Lodge of this character is capable of rendering in the cause of Freemasonry . Our Lodges as a rule meet on only a limited number of evenings in tho

course of the year , and unless a brother has a tolerably wide circle of acquaintances in the brotherhood his prospects of acquiring the requisite knowledge of his duties are but few and far between . Indeed one who confined himself to

attending tho regular duties of his Lodge and no other might be a member of the Masonic body for many years and yet acquire but a very slight knowledge of the Craft . Hence the value of Lodges of Instruction , which meeting weekly for a considerable portion of tho year , enable brethren to

acquire in a few months a pretty intimate acquaintance with the ceremonies and lectures . Under these circumstances it will be apparent that ifc is impossible too much can be done to strengthen and confirm their position . At present , as our readers are aware , they are

held cither " under the sanction of a regular warranted Lodge , or by the special licence and authority of the Grand Master . " This afc first sight would seem to be a very proper arrangement , and so far as regards the latter alternative there could not be the slightest possible objection to

it . Even a regular Lodge can derive its existence from no higher authority , and therefore nothing can be more complete or satisfactory than the licence under which a Lodge of Instruction thus authorised fulfils its appointed duties . But it seems to us that something more is needed in the

case of those which derive their being from regularly warranted Lodges . It is true they trace their origin mediately to the Grand Master , but this strikes us as being a somewhat lame arrangement ; at all events , it is one which , in our humble -judgment , is capable of some

improvement , and as all are anxiously striving to better their knowledge of Masonic working , we see no just cause or impediment why Lodges of Instruction should not in all cases be established on a more solid basis . We do not say this for the purpose of offering a suggestion and nothing

more . We have spoken of their great value , and on general grounds we think ifc advisable there should be something further done in order to attach a greater degree of importance to what , after all said and done , arc absolutely indispensable to the welfare of the Craft . It is not , however ,

enough that we should urge a question of this kind on general grounds only . It is far better we should advance some special reasons , and these it is in our power to do .

Let us , in the first place , point out that the existing law would bo absolutel } -, or at all events as nearly as possible , perfect , if every Lodge of Instruction were specially attached to the regular warranted Lodge from which ifc

Lodges Of Instruction.

derives its authority . This , of course , is the case afc present , but only to a very limited extent . Wo mean this . If tho Lodgo of Instruction were composed wholly or in greater part of members of the parent Lodgo , there would then be a most intimate—we may almost describe ifc

as a complete connection between tho two . But our readers know that Lodges of Instruction in London aro composed of members gathered together from all tho four quarters of the metropolis , and what is still moro to our purpose , that tho members of the parent Lodge in many

cases form , as regards mere numbers , but a very feeble minority . It is inevitable , of course , under these circumstances , that the interest which tho Lodgo takes in the working of its Lodge of Instruction is of a feeble and intermittent nature . There is no close tie existing between

them , save and except that of the authorisation granted by tho former to tho latter , an authorisation which may bo withdrawn after due notice given in accordance with the

law . There is , then , as matters now stand , but little interest in common between the two , but this interest would be intensified if the connecting link were appreciably strengthened . This is one of the two alternatives we have before

us ; the other is that all Lodges of Instruction should derive the authority under which they work from the Grand Master alone . Wo see no objection to their remaining , as now , nominally under the wing of what AVO have designated the parent Lodge ; but let them have a special

Warrant of their own , so that they may be directly , as they are now only indirectly , responsible to tho highest authority . Tho law makes the Lodge which issues its sanction and those to Avhom it is issued responsible for the proceedings , and likewise that the Avorking has

been formally recognised by the Grand Master . This is admirable in theory , but when it comes to a matter of practice , we feel bound to say there is but little at tho bottom of it . It strike us the parent Lodge seldom troubles itself about its Lodge of Instruction ; and as the majority of

those who belong to tho latter are not members of the former , any interference on its part , though perfectly legitimate , might lead to many unpleasantnesses . The chance of this happening would be prevented , if the Lodge of Instruction were in all material points independent

of all but the central authority . It must also be borne in mind that in the event of anything causing the dissolution of the parent Lodge , the blow falls likewise on the Lodge of Instruction . Even a less serious calamity than this might cause a disruption of the proceedings in a

Lodge of Instruction . A case occurred not long since , m Avhich a Lodge was suspended for a given period from its functions , and in consequence the Lodge of Instruction Avhich had been sanctioned by it Avas obliged to suspend its operations likewise . This would have caused no slight

inconvenience even in the most central district of London , though it would havo been open to duly qualified members to seek instruction elsewhere in the immediate neighbourhood ; but in the case we are alluding to , the Lodge Avas situate in the outskirts of the metropolis , where Lodges

are more widely scattered . Indeed the nearest Lodge of Instruction Avas distant several miles . This necessarily involved a considerable amount of hardship on brethren Avho had committed no fault , aud amounted , in fact , to the

infliction of punishment on innocent as well as guilty . Such a result can never have been contemplated by tho authorities , nor could it possibly happen Avere all Lodges of Instruction directly sanctioned by the Grand Master . Considering the amount of useful work these homes of

Masonic education are doing , we do not think they can be too carefully fostered by those in high places . There is one other plan by which the end we have in view might bo equally well secured . Let the Emulation Lodge of Improvement be directly sanctioned by the Grand Master Avith full

power to authorise all other Lodges of Instruction in the Metropolitan district . This would have the two-fold advantage of saving additional labour at Freemasons' Hall and of placing all Lodges of this kind under ono central

authority . As this only occurred to us at the moment of Avriting , Ave do not wish to lay particular stress upon it . One thing is certain : too much cannot be done to guard those Lodges from any interruption , especially of the character we have mentioned , in the course of their labours .

ERRATUM . —In onr footnote to pago 290 of last week ' s issue ( article Forewarned—Forearmed ) , Chapter 1 G 2 should bo 1 G 0 , i . e ., tho Temperance .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • You're on page2
  • 3
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy