Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Sept. 9, 1899
  • Page 4
  • MASONIC IMPOSTORS.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Sept. 9, 1899: Page 4

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Sept. 9, 1899
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article MASONIC IMPOSTORS. ← Page 2 of 3
    Article MASONIC IMPOSTORS. Page 2 of 3 →
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Impostors.

to the Craft generally . Charity is , I take it , the chief watchword of the Fraternity , and as the Brethren give their money freely , it follows that they have a right to expect their Charity Committees or Almoners should see to it that the money thus subscribed should be wisely and judiciously expended . With

the operations of the Charity Committee of Prov . G . Lodge I must admit I have no very great knowledge , but of the many difficulties and pitfalls which lie in the way of an Almoner who is actuated by a desire to effectually and efficiently discharge the functions of his very unpleasant office , I do

claim to speak with some degree of authority . There are of course , Almoners and Almoners . There are those of the class I have just indicated , and there are those who , in consequence of not having the time to devote to the work they have undertaken , will give any and every applicant a

couple of shillings or so to get rid of him , providing he can prove himself possessed of some little knowledge of our ritual . In the course of my two years' experience as Almoner for the six Lodges in the borough of Huddersfield , I have found it the rule that the applicant cannot produce

his Grand Lodge Certificate . He has either lost it , it has been accidently destroyed , a kind friend is taking care of it for him , anything or any sort of an excuse is good enough to throw to the confiding , easily-duped Almoner , who is expected to swallow the most astounding and unlikely statements , the

verification of which is often a matter of great difficulty . I have often asked myself the question , how many of these applicants are really Masons ? I have it on excellent authority that there are at least 200 of these impostors up and down the country , making a comfortable living out of us ,

and the worst of it is the fault is entirely our own . We have no system , and without a system no institution can flourish , and no fund can be properly administered . It is an astounding statement , and I make it in all seriousness , that a very large precentage of those people who are living by systematic

fraud upon the Almoners' funds throughout the length and breadth of the country , they have never been initiated into Masonry at all . They are sharp enough to understand the value of the little information they are able to pick up from some unworthy Brother , or from some text book , of which

there are sadly too many . It is quite refreshing to receive a visit from an applicant with his certificate in his pocket , and a suspiciously looking document it is too , suggestive of microbes and many other disagreeable things . He produces it with such a triumphant flourish , as if he would say , " There

now , what more do you want ? " Well , I make a practice of requiring a great deal more . My procedure is generally this : Whilst asking for his name and address I carelessly finger this little memorandum book , which is a pocket index , and will tell me in an instant if the applicant has previously

visited Huddersfield . Many times whilst my visitor is protesting that he has never been in Yorkshire before , that he is a poor benighted stranger in a strange land , I know perfectly well that he is not speaking the truth , and I am on my guard . He is then asked to prove himself , which lie

proceeds to do after the most elaborate precautions against eavesdroppers . I may say at once that I attach little importance to this part of the business , but long before he is through I have made up my mind whether I have got a pebble or a real stone , even if it is off colour . The real

article is prolific to the extreme ; in fact , he is anxious to demonstrate too much , and although I have not had the honour of sitting in the chair of King Solomon , it is entirely m } r own fault that I am not in possession of all the secrets appertaining to that exalted degree . Having checked the

volubility of m } ' friend , I ask for information as to the cause of his reverse of fortune , and this statement I carefully commit to writing . Should it be a second visit , I turn up to what he told me last time , and see how the two statements agree . I then decide either to assist , as the case requires , or

refuse any help . If I help at all I do not give less than two shillings , and in some cases meet the requirements regardless of a limit . I will illustrate this . A man comes , whom I am convinced is unworthy , but he is sixty-five , perhaps seventy years of age , obviously ill and half-starved .

He has seen better days ; I know he is unworthy , but I give him a couple of shillings : he gets a square meal and a night in bed . His misery is relieved for the time . A second man comes . He has been foreman over a number of men employed on the railway since his return from the army ( he

had belonged to a Military Lodge ) , his health had broken down , he had spent his substance whilst ill , and is slowly and painfully making his way across country to a distant town , where his married daughter will care for him and nurse him , but is herself too poor to send the railway fare .

Masonic Impostors.

His Grand Lodge Certificate is produced , and everything is in order . I enquire by telephone to the police of the town to which he is going . They ascertain his story to be true in every particular . What is the good of giving that man 2 / - ? I do what the first Almoner he applied to should have done .

I feed and lodge him , get him a ticket , and see him off rejoicing . This is an expensive case , but I contend is a cheaper one than the other . Turning now to the swindlers , whose name is legion . My friend , Bro . Pownall , of Ashtonunder-Ljme , whom I am glad is present ; Bro . J . V . Thomas ,

of Retford ; Bro . Walmsley , of Preston ( the last two of whom I have not had the pleasure of meeting ) and myself , seem to have formed the nucleus of an Almoners' League . We are in regular correspondence with each other . If one meets with a swindler he . at once cautions the others , and we are ready

for him . But of what avail is this ? I know perfectly well if I refuse an applicant whom I have found a fraud , he will simply push on to the next town and get help there . I will not weary you , Brethren , by relating the cases of imposture which I have detected , some with five or six names , and who

pretend to belong to five or six Lodges . I will not recount how I have been deceived by men of education and brilliant accomplishments , who have laid their snares and achieved their end with a consummate skill that has indeed proved them masters in their craft . But respecting one case in particular , I must ask

your indulgence , as I verily believe the man to be the most colossal Masonic impostor in the country . The man ' s name is Charles Rennie , though he gave his name as William . I detected him in May last , and had the satisfaction of having him sent to prison for three months with hard labour . After

the most diligent research , I am satisfied that Rennie has lived on Freemasonry for thirty years , and he is not even a Mason . He has actually attended Masonic gatherings , and it is established beyond all doubt that when things were getting too hot for him , he has periodically retired to the

cool shades of the Strand Union Workhouse . The man can accurately prove himself in the three established Degrees ; he has a most plausible manner , and benevolent appearance . When I expressed some doubts of his bona fides , he was simply horrified at the bare suggestion . Rennie has boasted

of the success which has attended his efforts , and I grieve to say proudly proclaims that he has succeeded in swindling thirty-six chief constables . I think I had the honour of being the thirty-sixth , but probably he will recal our deal with less pleasure than will attend the memory of the other thirty-five .

The audacity of the man was such , that on being sentenced he actually said to the Magistrates , "I cannot complain of being bowled out ; I have had a very fair innings . " Not content with swindling the Fraternity , he positively commenced a series of articles entitled " Confession of an

Impostor in Freemasonry , " and offered them to a weekly newspaper of a certain class . I have a copy of the first article , the original manuscript of which is in the possession of Bro . J . H . Roach P . M ., Master Strand Union Workhouse . Brother Morton , continuing , said : Rennie appears to

have penned this extraordinary document just before setting out on one of his " provincial tours , " as he calls them . It seems rather a pity that he misjudged the moment for committing his experience to paper . The narrative would have been better rounded off had it concluded with the story

of his visit to Huddersfield , and his detection and punishment . I have been working for such a meeting as we are now holding for the last two years . We have now made a move and something has got to be done , and the Province of West Yorkshire is going to be in its proper place in this undertaking , and our proper place is in the van .

But now , what can be done ? Individual efforts , even the efforts of one Province , can do but little to check this enormity . What we must have is some united action , and my idea is this : Let it be a sine qua 11011 that every applicant for relief from the Sojourners' Fund must produce his Grand

Lodge Certificate , and the Almoner must endorse thereon the particulars of the relief extended . This , I take it , can only be done by a Rule or series of Resolutions of the Grand Lodge of England . Let us invite this Provincial Grand Lodge of West Yorkshire to take prompt steps to bring this important matter before Grand Lodge .

Brother Morton concluded by moving : — "That this Conference of Almoners respectfully calls upon the Provincial Grand Lodge of West Yorkshire to consider the subject of itinerant Masonic Impostors , and urges upon them to make a representation to the Grand Lodge of England that it is desirable to formulate a code of instructions to Almoners throughout England , so that a united stand may be made against an evil which menaces the interests of Freemasonry . "

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1899-09-09, Page 4” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 25 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_09091899/page/4/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
MASONIC IMPOSTORS. Article 1
BESTOWAL OF PROVINCIAL HONOURS. Article 1
FAMILIAR FIGURES IN NEWCASTLE. Article 2
"A SPRIG OF ACACIA." Article 2
MASONIC IMPOSTORS. Article 3
Untitled Ad 5
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Article 7
UNITED GRAND LODGE. Article 7
MARK GRAND LODGE. Article 7
LODGE MEETINGS NEXT WEEK. Article 8
REPORTS OF MEETINGS. Article 8
CRAFT: PROVINCIAL. Article 8
Untitled Article 9
Untitled Ad 9
YE MASONIC KICKER. Article 9
INVESTIGATION. Article 9
IS FREEMASONRY A LUXURY? Article 10
HOW TO SPEAK. Article 10
SUSPENSIONS. Article 10
THE CANDIDATE. Article 10
MASONIC APHORISMS. Article 10
PROPHETS AND FANATICS. Article 11
THE CARLTON HOTEL. Article 11
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
The Theatres, &c. Article 12
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

8 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

10 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

6 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

4 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

7 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

8 Articles
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Impostors.

to the Craft generally . Charity is , I take it , the chief watchword of the Fraternity , and as the Brethren give their money freely , it follows that they have a right to expect their Charity Committees or Almoners should see to it that the money thus subscribed should be wisely and judiciously expended . With

the operations of the Charity Committee of Prov . G . Lodge I must admit I have no very great knowledge , but of the many difficulties and pitfalls which lie in the way of an Almoner who is actuated by a desire to effectually and efficiently discharge the functions of his very unpleasant office , I do

claim to speak with some degree of authority . There are of course , Almoners and Almoners . There are those of the class I have just indicated , and there are those who , in consequence of not having the time to devote to the work they have undertaken , will give any and every applicant a

couple of shillings or so to get rid of him , providing he can prove himself possessed of some little knowledge of our ritual . In the course of my two years' experience as Almoner for the six Lodges in the borough of Huddersfield , I have found it the rule that the applicant cannot produce

his Grand Lodge Certificate . He has either lost it , it has been accidently destroyed , a kind friend is taking care of it for him , anything or any sort of an excuse is good enough to throw to the confiding , easily-duped Almoner , who is expected to swallow the most astounding and unlikely statements , the

verification of which is often a matter of great difficulty . I have often asked myself the question , how many of these applicants are really Masons ? I have it on excellent authority that there are at least 200 of these impostors up and down the country , making a comfortable living out of us ,

and the worst of it is the fault is entirely our own . We have no system , and without a system no institution can flourish , and no fund can be properly administered . It is an astounding statement , and I make it in all seriousness , that a very large precentage of those people who are living by systematic

fraud upon the Almoners' funds throughout the length and breadth of the country , they have never been initiated into Masonry at all . They are sharp enough to understand the value of the little information they are able to pick up from some unworthy Brother , or from some text book , of which

there are sadly too many . It is quite refreshing to receive a visit from an applicant with his certificate in his pocket , and a suspiciously looking document it is too , suggestive of microbes and many other disagreeable things . He produces it with such a triumphant flourish , as if he would say , " There

now , what more do you want ? " Well , I make a practice of requiring a great deal more . My procedure is generally this : Whilst asking for his name and address I carelessly finger this little memorandum book , which is a pocket index , and will tell me in an instant if the applicant has previously

visited Huddersfield . Many times whilst my visitor is protesting that he has never been in Yorkshire before , that he is a poor benighted stranger in a strange land , I know perfectly well that he is not speaking the truth , and I am on my guard . He is then asked to prove himself , which lie

proceeds to do after the most elaborate precautions against eavesdroppers . I may say at once that I attach little importance to this part of the business , but long before he is through I have made up my mind whether I have got a pebble or a real stone , even if it is off colour . The real

article is prolific to the extreme ; in fact , he is anxious to demonstrate too much , and although I have not had the honour of sitting in the chair of King Solomon , it is entirely m } r own fault that I am not in possession of all the secrets appertaining to that exalted degree . Having checked the

volubility of m } ' friend , I ask for information as to the cause of his reverse of fortune , and this statement I carefully commit to writing . Should it be a second visit , I turn up to what he told me last time , and see how the two statements agree . I then decide either to assist , as the case requires , or

refuse any help . If I help at all I do not give less than two shillings , and in some cases meet the requirements regardless of a limit . I will illustrate this . A man comes , whom I am convinced is unworthy , but he is sixty-five , perhaps seventy years of age , obviously ill and half-starved .

He has seen better days ; I know he is unworthy , but I give him a couple of shillings : he gets a square meal and a night in bed . His misery is relieved for the time . A second man comes . He has been foreman over a number of men employed on the railway since his return from the army ( he

had belonged to a Military Lodge ) , his health had broken down , he had spent his substance whilst ill , and is slowly and painfully making his way across country to a distant town , where his married daughter will care for him and nurse him , but is herself too poor to send the railway fare .

Masonic Impostors.

His Grand Lodge Certificate is produced , and everything is in order . I enquire by telephone to the police of the town to which he is going . They ascertain his story to be true in every particular . What is the good of giving that man 2 / - ? I do what the first Almoner he applied to should have done .

I feed and lodge him , get him a ticket , and see him off rejoicing . This is an expensive case , but I contend is a cheaper one than the other . Turning now to the swindlers , whose name is legion . My friend , Bro . Pownall , of Ashtonunder-Ljme , whom I am glad is present ; Bro . J . V . Thomas ,

of Retford ; Bro . Walmsley , of Preston ( the last two of whom I have not had the pleasure of meeting ) and myself , seem to have formed the nucleus of an Almoners' League . We are in regular correspondence with each other . If one meets with a swindler he . at once cautions the others , and we are ready

for him . But of what avail is this ? I know perfectly well if I refuse an applicant whom I have found a fraud , he will simply push on to the next town and get help there . I will not weary you , Brethren , by relating the cases of imposture which I have detected , some with five or six names , and who

pretend to belong to five or six Lodges . I will not recount how I have been deceived by men of education and brilliant accomplishments , who have laid their snares and achieved their end with a consummate skill that has indeed proved them masters in their craft . But respecting one case in particular , I must ask

your indulgence , as I verily believe the man to be the most colossal Masonic impostor in the country . The man ' s name is Charles Rennie , though he gave his name as William . I detected him in May last , and had the satisfaction of having him sent to prison for three months with hard labour . After

the most diligent research , I am satisfied that Rennie has lived on Freemasonry for thirty years , and he is not even a Mason . He has actually attended Masonic gatherings , and it is established beyond all doubt that when things were getting too hot for him , he has periodically retired to the

cool shades of the Strand Union Workhouse . The man can accurately prove himself in the three established Degrees ; he has a most plausible manner , and benevolent appearance . When I expressed some doubts of his bona fides , he was simply horrified at the bare suggestion . Rennie has boasted

of the success which has attended his efforts , and I grieve to say proudly proclaims that he has succeeded in swindling thirty-six chief constables . I think I had the honour of being the thirty-sixth , but probably he will recal our deal with less pleasure than will attend the memory of the other thirty-five .

The audacity of the man was such , that on being sentenced he actually said to the Magistrates , "I cannot complain of being bowled out ; I have had a very fair innings . " Not content with swindling the Fraternity , he positively commenced a series of articles entitled " Confession of an

Impostor in Freemasonry , " and offered them to a weekly newspaper of a certain class . I have a copy of the first article , the original manuscript of which is in the possession of Bro . J . H . Roach P . M ., Master Strand Union Workhouse . Brother Morton , continuing , said : Rennie appears to

have penned this extraordinary document just before setting out on one of his " provincial tours , " as he calls them . It seems rather a pity that he misjudged the moment for committing his experience to paper . The narrative would have been better rounded off had it concluded with the story

of his visit to Huddersfield , and his detection and punishment . I have been working for such a meeting as we are now holding for the last two years . We have now made a move and something has got to be done , and the Province of West Yorkshire is going to be in its proper place in this undertaking , and our proper place is in the van .

But now , what can be done ? Individual efforts , even the efforts of one Province , can do but little to check this enormity . What we must have is some united action , and my idea is this : Let it be a sine qua 11011 that every applicant for relief from the Sojourners' Fund must produce his Grand

Lodge Certificate , and the Almoner must endorse thereon the particulars of the relief extended . This , I take it , can only be done by a Rule or series of Resolutions of the Grand Lodge of England . Let us invite this Provincial Grand Lodge of West Yorkshire to take prompt steps to bring this important matter before Grand Lodge .

Brother Morton concluded by moving : — "That this Conference of Almoners respectfully calls upon the Provincial Grand Lodge of West Yorkshire to consider the subject of itinerant Masonic Impostors , and urges upon them to make a representation to the Grand Lodge of England that it is desirable to formulate a code of instructions to Almoners throughout England , so that a united stand may be made against an evil which menaces the interests of Freemasonry . "

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 3
  • You're on page4
  • 5
  • 12
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy