Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Aug. 8, 1896
  • Page 9
  • IS "MASONIC DEATH" PERPETUAL?
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Aug. 8, 1896: Page 9

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Aug. 8, 1896
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article EUROPEAN LODGES. Page 1 of 1
    Article IS "MASONIC DEATH" PERPETUAL? Page 1 of 1
    Article IS "MASONIC DEATH" PERPETUAL? Page 1 of 1
    Article WEAK OR WANING LODGES. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

European Lodges.

EUROPEAN LODGES .

FROM a highly interesting account given by Bro . George C . Cannor Grand Secretary of Tennessee , of his European trip and visit to Masonio Lodges in Great Britain , and on tho Continent , the following extracts are taken , as showing the difference in the interior of Lodges in Europe . The article is illustrated by diagrams showing the position of Officers and appointments in the various Lodges visited , but what is here given will prove of

interest to the general Masonic reader . Alluding , to the diagram of tho Italian Lodge , Bro . Cannor says : — " It will be observed that an altar , like as in America , is used in Italy . Indeed the arrangements are quite like the American . " There are slight variations in the arrangements of other Lodge rooms visited , but these may be accepted as the standard . The rooms

are all small , few capable of seating more than fifty Brethren . In England , hotels generally build Lodge rooms in their upper stories and several Lodges assemble therein without the payment of rental . The hotels are compensated by the Brethren dining after the conclusion of business , and this dining in full evening dress , and in Masonic clothing and jewels , may be set down as

the universal custom of English Freemasonry . In Germany , the hotel custom does not prevail to any great extent , and Lodges either own , or lease , their rooms . Dinner or luncheon is also served as in England , and chiefly in halls attached to the Lodge rooms . In Italy the hotel custom does not prevail at all , chiefly because of the Papal opposition . Lodge rooms are leased , as a

rule , and dining without Masonic clothing occurs at the restaurant . Intelligent American Masons find no difficulty in making themselves known in Europe . But no attempt should be made to visit a Lodge without first receiving an invitation to do so , from the Secretary . The American way of going to the reception-room and sending in your card to be answered by an

Examination Committee is unknown in Europe . Several Americans , known to the writer , failed to observe this formality , and hence failed to visit the Lodges into whose reception rooms they entered . English and Continental Masons own their own aprons and carry the same along with them when visiting I No aprons are supplied by the Lodges except to its Officers . The

Lodges elect their Masters , Treasurers , and Tylers . The remaining Officers are appointed by the Worshipful Master-elect . The American law as to the powers of Wardens does not prevail in Europe . The retiring Past Master instals his successor , and then presents the remaining Officers for investment by the Master . The Installation ceremony is secret , and is vastly superior

to the ceremony we use in America . The Tyler always proposes the last toasfc at a Masonic Dinner . From a special paper on " American and Foreign Freemasonry , " we make the following excerpts : —The rituals of the Continent of Europe and of the British Isles are different from each other and from those of the United States . The rituals of England , of Scotland , and of

Ireland , differ from each other , the latter more nearly approaching those of the United States . No rituals beyond the seas use D . G . 's in any of the Degrees . These are a purely American invention . The means of recognition are about the same in the rituals of the British Isles , bub differ somewhat on the Continent . Nor is the M . M . W—d exactly the same . The first is

the second , and the second is the first on the Continent . England and United States are alike . The S—s of the first and second are the same all over Europe , the American first is the same as the European , hut the American D . G . of the second is the S of the European . The S of the Third on the Continent is the same as the American , with a

slight addition . The Third in England has five S—s , and a S of D . Only one of these is in the American rituals . The ceremonies are much briefer , especially of the third . Many dramatic features are wanting . While this

brevity detracts from the pageant , it really adds to the solemnity of the work . We candidly believe that many features of the English work could be profitably introduced into the American , after some meaningless things in the American were eliminated . — " American Tyler . "

Is "Masonic Death" Perpetual?

IS " MASONIC DEATH" PERPETUAL ?

IjlXPULSION Freemasonry is usually termed " Masonic death , " - ¦—^ and only follows when , after due trial for some crime , either against the laws of the land or the obligations of Freemasonry , one has been proven guilty . In our estimation there is no redemption from such a judgment save that the fact of innocence or some irregularity in his trial has been

subsequently established . Then , and only then , can his restoration to Freemasonry take place . Illustrious Bro . Sohultz , of Maryland , seems to take a more liberal view of expulsion than this , and says : " We hold that an expelled Brother is still a Mason , for should the sentence of expulsion be

removed , that is , a pardon be granted to him—by no means an unusual occurrence—no re-making is required , therefore he was a Mason all the time , but one to whom , during the continuance of the sentence , all the rights and privileges of the Fraternity were denied . "

Now , there is something to us very illogical in the presumption that when a man has been forced to submit to the unspeakable indignity of expulsion from all the rights , privileges , and benefits of Freemasonry , and debarred from any further association with his Brethren throughout the world , and branded with the " living death " of an expelled Mason , he

should still consider himself under any obligation to hold inviolate thc secrets aud mysteries of Freemasonry . In shorfc , still consider himself a Mason . He has suffered all the indignity possible at the hands of the Institution , in thus throwing him out to a mocking world under a ban second only to that inflicted from a Roman altar by bell , book , and candle . Of course we expect

Is "Masonic Death" Perpetual?

that man to still remain faithful to his obligations , but by what authority or power by his Brethren possessed can ho be made to so observe and preserve ? Freemasonry has done all possible to him in the punishment of expulsionwhich virtually stigmatises him as being a worthless character , unworthy of the confidence , esteem , or respect of , not only Freemasons universal , but

also of all his fellow-men . Now , why should we not expect from such a man retaliation ? What worse in character could he be to imitate Morgan , Dr . Richardson , Blanchard , or other enemies of Freemasonry ? We have said to him , in substance : " You are a scoundrel , sunk so low as to be beyond our contempt , and we therefore throw you in the rubbish heap . Don't ever dare to come near a Freemason ' s Lodge or converse upon Masonry with any

of us , but keep all your obligations and remember your vows . You were once a Mason , and will remain so for life , although we have expelled you as worthless . So off with you , and don't you dare to consider yourself released from your Masonic obligations , or we will consider you still worse than even our expulsion brands you . " What , from a human standpoint , might be supposed would be the reply of this expelled Mason ?

Now , in this connection Bro . Philip G . Malcolm Grand Master of Oregon says , in one of his decisions : " A man who has been regularly made a Mason remains a Mason for ever , unless expelled from the Order by proper authority , after due trial and conviction . " Now here again the question arises what is he " after due trial and conviction ? " The inference , according to Bro .

Malcolm , would be that after expulsion he ceases to be a Mason . Our view of this question is that there is no possible time in which the man ceases to be a Mason , and no power on earth can take away from a man his Masonry when once received . He may be disciplined to the extreme of Masonic law and technically

deprived of all rights and benefits accruing to him from the Institution , but the fact does not " kill , " but simply banishes him from fraternal association with his fellow-Masons . Therefore , this so-called " Masonic death" is not perpetual any more than would expulsion from church membership remove a man froin personal experience in the benefits of religion . Nothing can

remove the impression of Masonry first made in the heart and finished in the Lodge . To sum up , we look upon the term " expulsion" as an illogical misnomer which should be changed to some such expression as " banished " or " outlawed . " No man can be expelled from Masonry , although he may

be placed under the ban of non-association with his former Brethren , but he still remains a Mason . There is no such thing as expulsion from Freemasonry . You may discharge your bookkeeper , but he still has the combination of your safe . That you can change , but Freemasonry cannot change its combination . — "American Tyler . "

Weak Or Waning Lodges.

WEAK OR WANING LODGES .

WHEN Lodges run down so that , attendances become smaller and smaller , the hour of meeting is delayed , or things become so bad that periods of recess are decided upon . This is a matter for very general regret . To trace all the causes for such circumstances is perhaps not an easy task , and yet in tho majority of instances the fault lies wifch the Worshipful

Master . As soon as any Lodge exhibits signs of weakness or decay , it is the duty of the Worshipful Master to examine himself and see if the cause can be traced to his own neglect or incapacity . It will too frequently be found that it is there if the examination be an honest one . But the individual brethren

of a lodge are each responsible for having assisted to place him in the position . In one case will be found one who murders the Queen's English in wholesale fashion , addresses half a dozen Candidates as if they were but one man , scatters his aspirates around like rice at a wedding send off , or reduces the supply where they are most wanted , until " he " is turned into " ee " and

" home " into " ome . " If the brethren be asked how it is that such an uncultured brother has been raised to the chair , they admit his deficiencies , but tell you that he was S . W . and it was " his turn to go on . " Their duty to their Lodge and the Craft has been allowed to make way for their sentiments and weakness . Another Worshipful Master , from want of tact and firmness ,

has all the members sadly "by the ears , " and blundering stupidly , puts the Lodge at a disadvantage amongst its compeers , and perhaps when called upon to respond to a toast he makes some faux pas , which brings him into ridicule

whilst he is posing as the Exalted Ruler and representative of King Solomon , so that visitors who otherwise would adorn its meetings absent themselves , and then its own members lose heart and interest and feel ashamed because it so evidently lacks the attractiveness which others possess .

The cure is not far to seek , as has frequently been pointed out in these columns . Firm discrimination is requisite in the election of Officers , and the Worshipful Master and the Lodge who fail in exercising that palpable duty are false to themselves and to tho Craft in general , because an injury is in that way done to every member of the Lodge as well as to the credit of the

entire Draft in the territory . Only recently we heard a Freemason who had been an active and useful member , deplore the fact " that men of such low mental calibre and attainments were to be found ruling Lodges , and that the present condition was very much lower than ifc was ten years ago . " Whilst we cannot endorse this assertion in full , we can point out ; too many instances

in which the lack of education , refinement of manners , and total absence of tact , characterise thc mon who are the choice of the Lodges for the highest office in them , and , as a consequence , the withdrawal or indifference of many

men of education , intelligence and power for good . In too many of theso instances the brethren were fully aware that this would be thc result before the election , but allowed sentiment to prevail over right and manifest duty . Their argument being it is "his turn , " without using a counter argument

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1896-08-08, Page 9” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 21 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_08081896/page/9/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
OUR SECRECY ASSAILED. Article 1
PROPOSED HALL AT COLCHESTER. Article 1
SHROPSHIRE. Article 1
NORTH AND EAST YORKSHIRE. Article 1
CENTENARY AT HASLINGDEN. Article 2
ROYAL ARCH. Article 2
KENT. Article 3
"A SPRIG OF ACACIA." Article 3
RITUAL TINKERS. Article 4
THE FREEMASON BOGEY. Article 4
AFFILIATION FEES. Article 4
INTERNATIONAL FREEMASONRY. Article 5
SCRAPS FOR SPARE MOMENTS. Article 5
Untitled Ad 5
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Article 7
R.M.I. BOYS. Article 7
REPORTS OF MEETINGS. Article 8
EUROPEAN LODGES. Article 9
IS "MASONIC DEATH" PERPETUAL? Article 9
WEAK OR WANING LODGES. Article 9
MASONRY'S OBJECTS AND ENDS. Article 10
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
NEXT WEEK. Article 12
AIDS TO ENJOYMENT. Article 12
HERTFORD COUNTY COLLEGE. Article 12
The Theatres, &c. Article 12
Untitled Ad 12
Page 1

Page 1

5 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

4 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

4 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

4 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

8 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

7 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

2 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

4 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

7 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

7 Articles
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

European Lodges.

EUROPEAN LODGES .

FROM a highly interesting account given by Bro . George C . Cannor Grand Secretary of Tennessee , of his European trip and visit to Masonio Lodges in Great Britain , and on tho Continent , the following extracts are taken , as showing the difference in the interior of Lodges in Europe . The article is illustrated by diagrams showing the position of Officers and appointments in the various Lodges visited , but what is here given will prove of

interest to the general Masonic reader . Alluding , to the diagram of tho Italian Lodge , Bro . Cannor says : — " It will be observed that an altar , like as in America , is used in Italy . Indeed the arrangements are quite like the American . " There are slight variations in the arrangements of other Lodge rooms visited , but these may be accepted as the standard . The rooms

are all small , few capable of seating more than fifty Brethren . In England , hotels generally build Lodge rooms in their upper stories and several Lodges assemble therein without the payment of rental . The hotels are compensated by the Brethren dining after the conclusion of business , and this dining in full evening dress , and in Masonic clothing and jewels , may be set down as

the universal custom of English Freemasonry . In Germany , the hotel custom does not prevail to any great extent , and Lodges either own , or lease , their rooms . Dinner or luncheon is also served as in England , and chiefly in halls attached to the Lodge rooms . In Italy the hotel custom does not prevail at all , chiefly because of the Papal opposition . Lodge rooms are leased , as a

rule , and dining without Masonic clothing occurs at the restaurant . Intelligent American Masons find no difficulty in making themselves known in Europe . But no attempt should be made to visit a Lodge without first receiving an invitation to do so , from the Secretary . The American way of going to the reception-room and sending in your card to be answered by an

Examination Committee is unknown in Europe . Several Americans , known to the writer , failed to observe this formality , and hence failed to visit the Lodges into whose reception rooms they entered . English and Continental Masons own their own aprons and carry the same along with them when visiting I No aprons are supplied by the Lodges except to its Officers . The

Lodges elect their Masters , Treasurers , and Tylers . The remaining Officers are appointed by the Worshipful Master-elect . The American law as to the powers of Wardens does not prevail in Europe . The retiring Past Master instals his successor , and then presents the remaining Officers for investment by the Master . The Installation ceremony is secret , and is vastly superior

to the ceremony we use in America . The Tyler always proposes the last toasfc at a Masonic Dinner . From a special paper on " American and Foreign Freemasonry , " we make the following excerpts : —The rituals of the Continent of Europe and of the British Isles are different from each other and from those of the United States . The rituals of England , of Scotland , and of

Ireland , differ from each other , the latter more nearly approaching those of the United States . No rituals beyond the seas use D . G . 's in any of the Degrees . These are a purely American invention . The means of recognition are about the same in the rituals of the British Isles , bub differ somewhat on the Continent . Nor is the M . M . W—d exactly the same . The first is

the second , and the second is the first on the Continent . England and United States are alike . The S—s of the first and second are the same all over Europe , the American first is the same as the European , hut the American D . G . of the second is the S of the European . The S of the Third on the Continent is the same as the American , with a

slight addition . The Third in England has five S—s , and a S of D . Only one of these is in the American rituals . The ceremonies are much briefer , especially of the third . Many dramatic features are wanting . While this

brevity detracts from the pageant , it really adds to the solemnity of the work . We candidly believe that many features of the English work could be profitably introduced into the American , after some meaningless things in the American were eliminated . — " American Tyler . "

Is "Masonic Death" Perpetual?

IS " MASONIC DEATH" PERPETUAL ?

IjlXPULSION Freemasonry is usually termed " Masonic death , " - ¦—^ and only follows when , after due trial for some crime , either against the laws of the land or the obligations of Freemasonry , one has been proven guilty . In our estimation there is no redemption from such a judgment save that the fact of innocence or some irregularity in his trial has been

subsequently established . Then , and only then , can his restoration to Freemasonry take place . Illustrious Bro . Sohultz , of Maryland , seems to take a more liberal view of expulsion than this , and says : " We hold that an expelled Brother is still a Mason , for should the sentence of expulsion be

removed , that is , a pardon be granted to him—by no means an unusual occurrence—no re-making is required , therefore he was a Mason all the time , but one to whom , during the continuance of the sentence , all the rights and privileges of the Fraternity were denied . "

Now , there is something to us very illogical in the presumption that when a man has been forced to submit to the unspeakable indignity of expulsion from all the rights , privileges , and benefits of Freemasonry , and debarred from any further association with his Brethren throughout the world , and branded with the " living death " of an expelled Mason , he

should still consider himself under any obligation to hold inviolate thc secrets aud mysteries of Freemasonry . In shorfc , still consider himself a Mason . He has suffered all the indignity possible at the hands of the Institution , in thus throwing him out to a mocking world under a ban second only to that inflicted from a Roman altar by bell , book , and candle . Of course we expect

Is "Masonic Death" Perpetual?

that man to still remain faithful to his obligations , but by what authority or power by his Brethren possessed can ho be made to so observe and preserve ? Freemasonry has done all possible to him in the punishment of expulsionwhich virtually stigmatises him as being a worthless character , unworthy of the confidence , esteem , or respect of , not only Freemasons universal , but

also of all his fellow-men . Now , why should we not expect from such a man retaliation ? What worse in character could he be to imitate Morgan , Dr . Richardson , Blanchard , or other enemies of Freemasonry ? We have said to him , in substance : " You are a scoundrel , sunk so low as to be beyond our contempt , and we therefore throw you in the rubbish heap . Don't ever dare to come near a Freemason ' s Lodge or converse upon Masonry with any

of us , but keep all your obligations and remember your vows . You were once a Mason , and will remain so for life , although we have expelled you as worthless . So off with you , and don't you dare to consider yourself released from your Masonic obligations , or we will consider you still worse than even our expulsion brands you . " What , from a human standpoint , might be supposed would be the reply of this expelled Mason ?

Now , in this connection Bro . Philip G . Malcolm Grand Master of Oregon says , in one of his decisions : " A man who has been regularly made a Mason remains a Mason for ever , unless expelled from the Order by proper authority , after due trial and conviction . " Now here again the question arises what is he " after due trial and conviction ? " The inference , according to Bro .

Malcolm , would be that after expulsion he ceases to be a Mason . Our view of this question is that there is no possible time in which the man ceases to be a Mason , and no power on earth can take away from a man his Masonry when once received . He may be disciplined to the extreme of Masonic law and technically

deprived of all rights and benefits accruing to him from the Institution , but the fact does not " kill , " but simply banishes him from fraternal association with his fellow-Masons . Therefore , this so-called " Masonic death" is not perpetual any more than would expulsion from church membership remove a man froin personal experience in the benefits of religion . Nothing can

remove the impression of Masonry first made in the heart and finished in the Lodge . To sum up , we look upon the term " expulsion" as an illogical misnomer which should be changed to some such expression as " banished " or " outlawed . " No man can be expelled from Masonry , although he may

be placed under the ban of non-association with his former Brethren , but he still remains a Mason . There is no such thing as expulsion from Freemasonry . You may discharge your bookkeeper , but he still has the combination of your safe . That you can change , but Freemasonry cannot change its combination . — "American Tyler . "

Weak Or Waning Lodges.

WEAK OR WANING LODGES .

WHEN Lodges run down so that , attendances become smaller and smaller , the hour of meeting is delayed , or things become so bad that periods of recess are decided upon . This is a matter for very general regret . To trace all the causes for such circumstances is perhaps not an easy task , and yet in tho majority of instances the fault lies wifch the Worshipful

Master . As soon as any Lodge exhibits signs of weakness or decay , it is the duty of the Worshipful Master to examine himself and see if the cause can be traced to his own neglect or incapacity . It will too frequently be found that it is there if the examination be an honest one . But the individual brethren

of a lodge are each responsible for having assisted to place him in the position . In one case will be found one who murders the Queen's English in wholesale fashion , addresses half a dozen Candidates as if they were but one man , scatters his aspirates around like rice at a wedding send off , or reduces the supply where they are most wanted , until " he " is turned into " ee " and

" home " into " ome . " If the brethren be asked how it is that such an uncultured brother has been raised to the chair , they admit his deficiencies , but tell you that he was S . W . and it was " his turn to go on . " Their duty to their Lodge and the Craft has been allowed to make way for their sentiments and weakness . Another Worshipful Master , from want of tact and firmness ,

has all the members sadly "by the ears , " and blundering stupidly , puts the Lodge at a disadvantage amongst its compeers , and perhaps when called upon to respond to a toast he makes some faux pas , which brings him into ridicule

whilst he is posing as the Exalted Ruler and representative of King Solomon , so that visitors who otherwise would adorn its meetings absent themselves , and then its own members lose heart and interest and feel ashamed because it so evidently lacks the attractiveness which others possess .

The cure is not far to seek , as has frequently been pointed out in these columns . Firm discrimination is requisite in the election of Officers , and the Worshipful Master and the Lodge who fail in exercising that palpable duty are false to themselves and to tho Craft in general , because an injury is in that way done to every member of the Lodge as well as to the credit of the

entire Draft in the territory . Only recently we heard a Freemason who had been an active and useful member , deplore the fact " that men of such low mental calibre and attainments were to be found ruling Lodges , and that the present condition was very much lower than ifc was ten years ago . " Whilst we cannot endorse this assertion in full , we can point out ; too many instances

in which the lack of education , refinement of manners , and total absence of tact , characterise thc mon who are the choice of the Lodges for the highest office in them , and , as a consequence , the withdrawal or indifference of many

men of education , intelligence and power for good . In too many of theso instances the brethren were fully aware that this would be thc result before the election , but allowed sentiment to prevail over right and manifest duty . Their argument being it is "his turn , " without using a counter argument

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 8
  • You're on page9
  • 10
  • 12
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy