Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • May 8, 1875
  • Page 7
  • WHAT THE PRESS SAY OF FREEMASONRY.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, May 8, 1875: Page 7

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, May 8, 1875
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE MAGAZINES OF THE MONTH. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. Page 1 of 1
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. Page 1 of 1
    Article WHAT THE PRESS SAY OF FREEMASONRY. Page 1 of 1
    Article ANSWERS TO CORRESPONDENTS. Page 1 of 1
Page 7

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Magazines Of The Month.

solve , and those who have not worked out any solution of their own , will find much benefit if they consult the answer in these pages . " How I dressed my daughters , " in these days , when every one is judged by their appearances , quite against the old Roman Maxim , " Nimium ne crede Colori , " is worth discussing , and we may add , is here worthily discussed . Mr . A . G . Payne , whose views ou the art oi

dining , are marked by great common sense , and whose suggestions are invariably appropriate , tells us "How to make Dishes look nice . " " Our Paris Correspondent" furnishes much valuable " Chitchat on Dress ; " and there is a capital paper on the question " How to get to Sleep at Night , " in which the writer suggests remedial measures for insomnia . Ordinarily , we think a man who works hard and takes plenty of exercise , and eats moderately but well , will expe .

rienco no difficulty in sleeping . Besides these domestic papers are several others , all more or less interesting , and especially a Biography of the late Sir W . Sterndale Bennett , an article on Vagabonds , and Mr . J . E . Taylor ' s paper on " Earthquakes , and how they aro caused . " The two serials progress , the interest in each being fully sustained . There are two or three neat sets of verses , and generally the illustrations are of a higher quality than usual . Each fresh number of this Magazine confirms our regard for it .

About the most readable article in Temple Bar is " A French Doctor Johnson , " one Gilles Menage who , from the account here given , appears to have possessed many of tho attributes of our great lexicographer , and certainly to have been somewhat more vivacious . Md . iage lived during the 17 th century , and seems to have had a good memory , great scholarship , and great conversational powers , but he

was as tender-hearted , as religious , as sympathetic with misfortune and suffering as Johnson . He was born in 1613 , and early developed a great aptitude for saying caustic things to that extent that we read of a young lady of Angers—his birth-place , who did " nofc know how to define la mMisance ; metis le medisant , e ' est le Menage . " His Mercuriale or Wednesday reunions were held regularly for over thirty

years , and it is chiefl y by what his friends have handed down to us of those Wednesday conversations that we are enabled to appreciate Menage . Among theso Mdnagiana , are included many smart sayings and several witty repartees recorded of other celebrities . Thus , of two Benedictine and Bemardian Monks who met at table , the latter pronounced grace before meat in the words Benedictus Benedicat , and

the former returns the compliment after meat by uttering the prayer Bernardus Bemardat . Again , of the Duke d'Elbcenf , who was ordered by the priest to give satisfaction to an injured servant before receiving the last sacrament . " I was not aware , " said the duke , " that salvation depends on reconciling oneself with a valet . " Of Fuetiero we are told that "just before his death he asked for an account of

disbursements . ' I have paid , ' said the Abbe , ' so much for the Porte Dien , so much for tho men , so much for the two priests . ' ' Abbe Abbe ! ' groaned the dying man . ' Yon have ruined me in sacraments ! ' " We have , further , an illustration of the ruling passion as illustrated by a dying usurer , on whose lips the priest presses a silver crucifix . Opening his eyes , and gazing upon it , the usurer

murmurs , "I can ' t lend much upon that / and then breathed his last . This is not all in Temple Bar that is of interest to tho reader . The further instalment of " Leah : a Womau of Fashion , " the conclusion of '' Ralph Wilton ' s Weird , " and the papers on " Tho Flying Post , " " William Charles Macready , " and " Tho Follies of tho Wise , " are worth readitiir .

Bailey contains , of course , an admirable biographical sketch of the late Sir Joseph Hawley , whoso death occurred so recently , and of a great Cricketer of the olden clays , "Mr . E . H . Budd . " * A further chapter of " Frank Raleigh of Watercombo , " " A Few Casts with a Fly-Rod , " an anticipatory sketch of "Yachting and Rowing" during tho approachiug season , aud " Our Van , " well laden with all kinds of news , anecdotes , and smart sayings make up , with other matter , a goodly number .

As usual , London Society is well illustrated , and contains a variety of matter for tho most part lightly and genially written . Mr . Peyton Wrey continues his notes on "Popular Dramatists . " Mr . Sidney Blanchard contributes " Jenkins Over tho Water , " and there is

Part III . of Sarcelle ' s " Gasfcronornical Rambles . " Tho " West End Notes , " by " The Man in tho Mask , " are pleasant and chattily written . The one drawback is tho continued presence of " Open ! Sesame ! " which is a heavy weight to be tacked onto so much agreeable light literature .

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

All Letters tintsf bear the name and address of the Writer , not necessarily for publication , but as a guarantee of good faith . We cannot undertake to return rejected communications . We do not hold ourselves responsible for the opinions of our Correspondents .

THE EARL OF CARNARVON ON FREEMASONRY

To the Editor of THE FREKMASON ' CHRONICLE . DEAK Sin AND BiioritF . R , —The great Masonic event which took place upon the 28 th nit ., and which is so ably described in your columns , viz ., the Installation of H . R . H . the Princo of Wales as Grand Master , is one which under tho circumstances will , no doubt

prove a landmark iu the history of the Order . The Prince bavinbeen dul y robed and chaired as the Grand Master of the English freemasons , was thereafter addressed or admonished by tho ° Pro brand Master , tho Earl of Carnarvon , in a most admirable speech , which might have been faultless had the Right Honourable speaker not marred it by unnecessarily introducing certain pseudo-historical

Correspondence.

remarks based , as it appears to me , nofc upon fact , bnfc upon fiction * The words which I object to are in the latter portion of the remark " Freemasonry possesses many titles to respect , even in the eyes of the outer world . It has , first of all , a great antiquity , an antiquity ascending into the sphere , I may say , of immemorial tradition . " And , further on , where the speaker says , " Formerly , through the dim

periods of the middle ages , it carved its records npon the public buildings of Europe , upon the tracery of the Cathedral windows , and the ornamentation of palaces . " Now , as a student of the history of Freemasonry , I beg to say thafc according to the records which I have perused , our Freemasonry is not of " great antiquity , " for no evidence has been produced of its existence even so recently as two

hundred years ago ; consequently , to talk of it " carving its records upon cathedrals and palaces " in the middle ages , " is simply absurd . If , however , our Right Honourable Brother is possessed of private evidence supporting his assertion , as yet unknown to other students of the history of Freemasonry , I shall be both ready and willing to withdraw and apologise for the foregoing criticisms so soon as I have

seen and duly weighed this new evidence . In concluding this letter I would beg leave to say that it is written in no captious spirit , but from a pure desire to support or know the truth . I am very glad , indeed , that the void left by the retrogression of the Marquis of Ripon has been more than filled up by tho Princo of Wales , who , 1 trust , will long bo spared to show that he is really worthy of the high position he has been bora heir to .

I am , yours fraternally , W . P . BUCHAN . Glasgow , 1 st May 1875 .

What The Press Say Of Freemasonry.

WHAT THE PRESS SAY OF FREEMASONRY .

To the Editor of THE FREEMASON S CHRONICLE . DEAR SIR AND BROTHER , —I am one of the fortunate ten thousand who were privileged to witness the installation of our Most Worshipful Grand Master on Wednesday last , and since then I have been highly entertained by a diligent perusal of the leading articles upon the ceremony which have appeared in the daily and weekly press ! .

In some of the papers , the comments of tho writers are characterised by harmless , nofc to say good-humonred badinage , in others these degenerate into , vulgar chaff , while in all , as might have beon expected , there is apparent the grossest ignorance . of Masonry and its principles . There is one writer , however , among these in whoso article there

aro displayed such superior vulgarity of expression , such offensive pretence of knowledge , aud such scandalous misrepresentations of the brotherhood of Freemasonry that he deserves to bo singled out from the others for conspicuous obloquy . The paper in which this remarkable specimen of impudouco appeared is called the Weekly Dispatch .

I believe it is a paper that in the world of jonrnahsm occupies a position somewhere between Reynold's Newspaper a , wi tho Englishman , and it has achieved the notoriety it enjoys from its loudly bellowed scorn of tho Sabbath , its derision of tho bench of bishops , and its undisguised contempt for monarchs , princes and lords . Naturally enough , tho election of the Heir Apparent to tho head of an

influential organisation such as ours , has excited the bilo of theso preachers of veiled treason , and tho full volume of their wrath is consequently poured forth upon Freemasons . The scribe of tho occasion depicts us as organised gluttons and wino bibbers , and thero failing in epithetical resource recurs for a further supply to tho obfuscated utterances of Carlyle . That Charlatan of phrases describes our

Order as " Bog-meteor of phosphorated hydrogen , conspicuous in the murk of things . Bog-meteor foolish , putrescent Will o' tho Wisp . ( Forsooth a great Tantologician . ) Harmless fire , but too fatuous ( the fat's in tho fire ) , mere flame circles , cub in the air for infants , wo know how . " The writer who can deliberately quote upon the subject of Masonry

the opinions of such a man as Carlyle , a secluded bookworm who looks upon everything with spectacles for eyes , and literally " through a glass darkly , " is hardly worthy of notice , and I should not have troubled you with this letter but for tho curious piece of braggadocio which terminates this farrago of milk and water malice . " We will venture to say , " asserts this coxscomb of journalism ,

" that we could give as good an account of what went on in the Albert Hall , on Thursday last ( sic ) as if we had been present . " Now , as tho proceedings at tho Albert Hall , on Thursday last , mainly consisted of clearing away the barriers deemed necessary for tho largo influx of visitors on tho previous day , I should think that any student of tho crazy phrase-maker of Chelsea might bo trusted to ovolvo an account of such work from his inner consciousness without

any refereuce to facts . Is this then a species of sport with lies intended to gull the unwary , or is it a genuine slip of tho writer ' s pen ? I shall not attempt to decide the question , but I mast say that pretentious ignorance which characterises tho article from the begining to end engenders in my mind a strong suspicion of the writer ' s candour and good faith . I am , & c . A MASTER MASON . 1 st May 1875 .

Answers To Correspondents.

ANSWERS TO CORRESPONDENTS .

IGNORAMUS . —Bro . Sadler is the Grand Secretary ' s Messmger , and , we believe , acts as Preceptor to the Emulation Lodge of Improvement .

TRAVELLER . —We shall find space for your contribution in an earl y number . T . T . — -It is a case of custom or tho " unwritten law , " Wo know of DO " written law" ou the subject .

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1875-05-08, Page 7” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 2 Aug. 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_08051875/page/7/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE SATURDAY REVIEW ON THE INSTALLATION. Article 1
OUR GRAND OFFICERS. Article 2
COMMERCIAL INTEGRITY. Article 2
THE PRESS AND THE INSTALLATION. Article 3
FRENCH VIEWS OF FREEMASONRY. Article 5
BRO. CONSTABLE'S DRAWING. Article 5
Untitled Article 5
REVIEWS. Article 6
THE MAGAZINES OF THE MONTH. Article 6
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 7
WHAT THE PRESS SAY OF FREEMASONRY. Article 7
ANSWERS TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 7
THE THEATRES, &c. Article 8
Untitled Article 8
Untitled Article 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
SUMMARY OF THE WEEK'S NEWS. Article 8
GRAND CHAPTER—INSTALLATION OF H.R.H. THE PRINCE OF WALES. Article 11
MASONIC GATHERINGS ON THE EVENING OF THE FESTIVAL. Article 11
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 12
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 12
CONSECRATION OF THE PRIORY CHAPTER, No. 1000, SOUTHEND. Article 14
MONEY MARKET AND CITY NEWS. Article 14
THE DRAMA. Article 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

4 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

5 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

3 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

5 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

8 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

4 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

5 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

22 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

14 Articles
Page 7

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Magazines Of The Month.

solve , and those who have not worked out any solution of their own , will find much benefit if they consult the answer in these pages . " How I dressed my daughters , " in these days , when every one is judged by their appearances , quite against the old Roman Maxim , " Nimium ne crede Colori , " is worth discussing , and we may add , is here worthily discussed . Mr . A . G . Payne , whose views ou the art oi

dining , are marked by great common sense , and whose suggestions are invariably appropriate , tells us "How to make Dishes look nice . " " Our Paris Correspondent" furnishes much valuable " Chitchat on Dress ; " and there is a capital paper on the question " How to get to Sleep at Night , " in which the writer suggests remedial measures for insomnia . Ordinarily , we think a man who works hard and takes plenty of exercise , and eats moderately but well , will expe .

rienco no difficulty in sleeping . Besides these domestic papers are several others , all more or less interesting , and especially a Biography of the late Sir W . Sterndale Bennett , an article on Vagabonds , and Mr . J . E . Taylor ' s paper on " Earthquakes , and how they aro caused . " The two serials progress , the interest in each being fully sustained . There are two or three neat sets of verses , and generally the illustrations are of a higher quality than usual . Each fresh number of this Magazine confirms our regard for it .

About the most readable article in Temple Bar is " A French Doctor Johnson , " one Gilles Menage who , from the account here given , appears to have possessed many of tho attributes of our great lexicographer , and certainly to have been somewhat more vivacious . Md . iage lived during the 17 th century , and seems to have had a good memory , great scholarship , and great conversational powers , but he

was as tender-hearted , as religious , as sympathetic with misfortune and suffering as Johnson . He was born in 1613 , and early developed a great aptitude for saying caustic things to that extent that we read of a young lady of Angers—his birth-place , who did " nofc know how to define la mMisance ; metis le medisant , e ' est le Menage . " His Mercuriale or Wednesday reunions were held regularly for over thirty

years , and it is chiefl y by what his friends have handed down to us of those Wednesday conversations that we are enabled to appreciate Menage . Among theso Mdnagiana , are included many smart sayings and several witty repartees recorded of other celebrities . Thus , of two Benedictine and Bemardian Monks who met at table , the latter pronounced grace before meat in the words Benedictus Benedicat , and

the former returns the compliment after meat by uttering the prayer Bernardus Bemardat . Again , of the Duke d'Elbcenf , who was ordered by the priest to give satisfaction to an injured servant before receiving the last sacrament . " I was not aware , " said the duke , " that salvation depends on reconciling oneself with a valet . " Of Fuetiero we are told that "just before his death he asked for an account of

disbursements . ' I have paid , ' said the Abbe , ' so much for the Porte Dien , so much for tho men , so much for the two priests . ' ' Abbe Abbe ! ' groaned the dying man . ' Yon have ruined me in sacraments ! ' " We have , further , an illustration of the ruling passion as illustrated by a dying usurer , on whose lips the priest presses a silver crucifix . Opening his eyes , and gazing upon it , the usurer

murmurs , "I can ' t lend much upon that / and then breathed his last . This is not all in Temple Bar that is of interest to tho reader . The further instalment of " Leah : a Womau of Fashion , " the conclusion of '' Ralph Wilton ' s Weird , " and the papers on " Tho Flying Post , " " William Charles Macready , " and " Tho Follies of tho Wise , " are worth readitiir .

Bailey contains , of course , an admirable biographical sketch of the late Sir Joseph Hawley , whoso death occurred so recently , and of a great Cricketer of the olden clays , "Mr . E . H . Budd . " * A further chapter of " Frank Raleigh of Watercombo , " " A Few Casts with a Fly-Rod , " an anticipatory sketch of "Yachting and Rowing" during tho approachiug season , aud " Our Van , " well laden with all kinds of news , anecdotes , and smart sayings make up , with other matter , a goodly number .

As usual , London Society is well illustrated , and contains a variety of matter for tho most part lightly and genially written . Mr . Peyton Wrey continues his notes on "Popular Dramatists . " Mr . Sidney Blanchard contributes " Jenkins Over tho Water , " and there is

Part III . of Sarcelle ' s " Gasfcronornical Rambles . " Tho " West End Notes , " by " The Man in tho Mask , " are pleasant and chattily written . The one drawback is tho continued presence of " Open ! Sesame ! " which is a heavy weight to be tacked onto so much agreeable light literature .

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

All Letters tintsf bear the name and address of the Writer , not necessarily for publication , but as a guarantee of good faith . We cannot undertake to return rejected communications . We do not hold ourselves responsible for the opinions of our Correspondents .

THE EARL OF CARNARVON ON FREEMASONRY

To the Editor of THE FREKMASON ' CHRONICLE . DEAK Sin AND BiioritF . R , —The great Masonic event which took place upon the 28 th nit ., and which is so ably described in your columns , viz ., the Installation of H . R . H . the Princo of Wales as Grand Master , is one which under tho circumstances will , no doubt

prove a landmark iu the history of the Order . The Prince bavinbeen dul y robed and chaired as the Grand Master of the English freemasons , was thereafter addressed or admonished by tho ° Pro brand Master , tho Earl of Carnarvon , in a most admirable speech , which might have been faultless had the Right Honourable speaker not marred it by unnecessarily introducing certain pseudo-historical

Correspondence.

remarks based , as it appears to me , nofc upon fact , bnfc upon fiction * The words which I object to are in the latter portion of the remark " Freemasonry possesses many titles to respect , even in the eyes of the outer world . It has , first of all , a great antiquity , an antiquity ascending into the sphere , I may say , of immemorial tradition . " And , further on , where the speaker says , " Formerly , through the dim

periods of the middle ages , it carved its records npon the public buildings of Europe , upon the tracery of the Cathedral windows , and the ornamentation of palaces . " Now , as a student of the history of Freemasonry , I beg to say thafc according to the records which I have perused , our Freemasonry is not of " great antiquity , " for no evidence has been produced of its existence even so recently as two

hundred years ago ; consequently , to talk of it " carving its records upon cathedrals and palaces " in the middle ages , " is simply absurd . If , however , our Right Honourable Brother is possessed of private evidence supporting his assertion , as yet unknown to other students of the history of Freemasonry , I shall be both ready and willing to withdraw and apologise for the foregoing criticisms so soon as I have

seen and duly weighed this new evidence . In concluding this letter I would beg leave to say that it is written in no captious spirit , but from a pure desire to support or know the truth . I am very glad , indeed , that the void left by the retrogression of the Marquis of Ripon has been more than filled up by tho Princo of Wales , who , 1 trust , will long bo spared to show that he is really worthy of the high position he has been bora heir to .

I am , yours fraternally , W . P . BUCHAN . Glasgow , 1 st May 1875 .

What The Press Say Of Freemasonry.

WHAT THE PRESS SAY OF FREEMASONRY .

To the Editor of THE FREEMASON S CHRONICLE . DEAR SIR AND BROTHER , —I am one of the fortunate ten thousand who were privileged to witness the installation of our Most Worshipful Grand Master on Wednesday last , and since then I have been highly entertained by a diligent perusal of the leading articles upon the ceremony which have appeared in the daily and weekly press ! .

In some of the papers , the comments of tho writers are characterised by harmless , nofc to say good-humonred badinage , in others these degenerate into , vulgar chaff , while in all , as might have beon expected , there is apparent the grossest ignorance . of Masonry and its principles . There is one writer , however , among these in whoso article there

aro displayed such superior vulgarity of expression , such offensive pretence of knowledge , aud such scandalous misrepresentations of the brotherhood of Freemasonry that he deserves to bo singled out from the others for conspicuous obloquy . The paper in which this remarkable specimen of impudouco appeared is called the Weekly Dispatch .

I believe it is a paper that in the world of jonrnahsm occupies a position somewhere between Reynold's Newspaper a , wi tho Englishman , and it has achieved the notoriety it enjoys from its loudly bellowed scorn of tho Sabbath , its derision of tho bench of bishops , and its undisguised contempt for monarchs , princes and lords . Naturally enough , tho election of the Heir Apparent to tho head of an

influential organisation such as ours , has excited the bilo of theso preachers of veiled treason , and tho full volume of their wrath is consequently poured forth upon Freemasons . The scribe of tho occasion depicts us as organised gluttons and wino bibbers , and thero failing in epithetical resource recurs for a further supply to tho obfuscated utterances of Carlyle . That Charlatan of phrases describes our

Order as " Bog-meteor of phosphorated hydrogen , conspicuous in the murk of things . Bog-meteor foolish , putrescent Will o' tho Wisp . ( Forsooth a great Tantologician . ) Harmless fire , but too fatuous ( the fat's in tho fire ) , mere flame circles , cub in the air for infants , wo know how . " The writer who can deliberately quote upon the subject of Masonry

the opinions of such a man as Carlyle , a secluded bookworm who looks upon everything with spectacles for eyes , and literally " through a glass darkly , " is hardly worthy of notice , and I should not have troubled you with this letter but for tho curious piece of braggadocio which terminates this farrago of milk and water malice . " We will venture to say , " asserts this coxscomb of journalism ,

" that we could give as good an account of what went on in the Albert Hall , on Thursday last ( sic ) as if we had been present . " Now , as tho proceedings at tho Albert Hall , on Thursday last , mainly consisted of clearing away the barriers deemed necessary for tho largo influx of visitors on tho previous day , I should think that any student of tho crazy phrase-maker of Chelsea might bo trusted to ovolvo an account of such work from his inner consciousness without

any refereuce to facts . Is this then a species of sport with lies intended to gull the unwary , or is it a genuine slip of tho writer ' s pen ? I shall not attempt to decide the question , but I mast say that pretentious ignorance which characterises tho article from the begining to end engenders in my mind a strong suspicion of the writer ' s candour and good faith . I am , & c . A MASTER MASON . 1 st May 1875 .

Answers To Correspondents.

ANSWERS TO CORRESPONDENTS .

IGNORAMUS . —Bro . Sadler is the Grand Secretary ' s Messmger , and , we believe , acts as Preceptor to the Emulation Lodge of Improvement .

TRAVELLER . —We shall find space for your contribution in an earl y number . T . T . — -It is a case of custom or tho " unwritten law , " Wo know of DO " written law" ou the subject .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 6
  • You're on page7
  • 8
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy