Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • April 3, 1886
  • Page 4
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, April 3, 1886: Page 4

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, April 3, 1886
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article WHO IS FIRST? ← Page 3 of 3
    Article WHAT BRO. PIKE BELIEVED IN 1871 AND WHAT HE BELIEVES NOW. Page 1 of 3
    Article WHAT BRO. PIKE BELIEVED IN 1871 AND WHAT HE BELIEVES NOW. Page 1 of 3 →
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Who Is First?

appropriate ceremonies which the Officers must see to , and if they be conferred without confusion or omission all is well . When Master and members have reached this stage of

declension in their appreciation of Masonry ( that is , if they ever had any ) the whole system takes its place in their minds alongside of the host of modern orders , and the

inducement to uphold the dignity of the Masonic Institution is at an end , and Masonry in its sublime aspect is lost . To counteract this tendency , everywhere exhibited , towards an utterly inadequate and false conception of

what the Symbolic Lodge really is , all Grand and Worshipful Masters , as being first in responsibility , should make no delay in aiding to restore in the minds of the brethren the knowledge and understanding of the things nnntftinfid in thft decreesboth severallv and collectivelv .

, —— -- o j •/ . r But this is not to be done either by patience or perseverance in the perusal of Masonic orations or the discursive effusions which reiterate the stereotyped eulogies on Masonry , its antiquity and grandeur , however forcible and

eloquent , or appropriate to the occasion which may have called them forth . The Craft have always been abundantly supplied , if not snowed under with this kind of literature , and all the time have learned nothing to the

point . The reasons are two : Jnrst , nothing can be put m print , even if the author knew what to put there , except such matters as may be a guide to those who will study Masonry where it is to be found ; and , second , no attempt

is made to show anything by any sort of proof or demonstration which can properly be written . The writings commonly published make no attempt even at this . They continue repeating in varied phrase what has been uttered

through generations , each writer relying with child-like simplicity on the authority of the one who last preceded him , and he on his predecessor , and so on back , while all

the time nothing is shown . Imagine an advocate appearing before a court to " show cause " for or against a rule or decision of any sort , who should indulge in a long eulogy of his client and a diatribe of an hour on the

timeworn subjects of justice , liberty and the glories of the Fourth of July and the battle of New Orleans , until choked off by the court . Could anybody learn from this , though repeated every day for a year , whether his client should have a rule or not ? Such is the case with Masonic utterances not intended to show anything of the true lore

of the Lodge , but only to compose excellent sentences into agreeable discourse , with more or less force and beauty , concerning Masonic sentiments and the principal objects of the Craft . Now , without laying aside the countless treasures of thought which are to be found in the literature above

mentioned , the Master or Grand Master who may desire to restore Masonic light to the craftsmen whom he represents , must pat himself to study , not from books , except as to a few particulars , but from the things contained in the Lodge —the proper and only storehouse of esoteric Masonic knowledge . He need not be afraid that he will exhaust

the subjects which will successively spring up in his pathway of exploration , or that Masonry will fail to demonstrate itself in the fulness of its admirable order , if it be sought out with the same astuteness and perseverance which the students of science exercise in bringing to li ght the secrets of the natural universe . —Voice of Masonry .

What Bro. Pike Believed In 1871 And What He Believes Now.

WHAT BRO . PIKE BELIEVED IN 1871 AND WHAT HE BELIEVES NOW .

Bv BEO . JACOB NORTON . IN Bro . Pike ' s " Masonic Origins , " he admitted , as I shall show hereafter , that the degrees of the Tork

Rite and of the Scottish Rite were alike modern . But in 1871 Bro . Pike issued a pamphlet , in which he denied the truth of the traditions of the so-called Tork Rite , but still clung to the notion that the Scottish Rite was ancient .

By way of a preface , I must inform the reader that in 1867 Bro . Geo . Frank Gouley edited a paper in St . Louis , called The Freemason , and that he was at the time Grand

Secretary of the Grand Lodge , and also Grand Master of the Missouri Templars . Bro . Gouley was then a firm believer in the traditions of the York or American Rite , consisting of

three Blue degrees , four Royal Arch degrees , three Templar degrees , and two or three of Royal Select degrees . About

What Bro. Pike Believed In 1871 And What He Believes Now.

the same time , Bro . Gouley received thirty-two degrees of the A . and A . Rite , when , to his horror , he discovered that in certain degrees of the Scottish Rite , the secrets of the Royal Arch and of the Knights Templars were

revealed . This brought on a discussion between the Missouri K . T . and the S . G . C . of tho Southern Jurisdiction of the A . and A . Rite , and a number of papers and pamphlets were issued bv the combatants . From Rebold

and Folger Bro . Gouley learned that the Charleston Frederick the Great Charter was a forgery , that the A . and A . Rite was a new concern ; and he charged the A . and A . Riters with having stolen tho Templar degree from the Tork Rite , and even went so far as to get the

Missouri Grand Comandry to "boycot" the A . and A . Riters . In 1871 Bro . Pike collected the articles , letters , & c , relating to the said controversy , and combined them in a pamphlet , headed " Vindication of the Ancient and Accepted Rite against certain libels . " The first part consists of an address by Bro . Pike to a body of A . and A .

Riters , in which he said : — " Tou are the chiefs of Exalted Masonry . Tour powers are real and substantial . If you do not duly estimate them , it is impossible that you should well perform the

corresponding duties . The highest of these accompany only the highest powers . . . Tou style yourselves Sovereign Grand Inspectors General , Grand Elect Knights of the Holy House of the Temple . Tou are so , if you

know the Royal secret , and understand the Holy doctrine . Tou claim to hold the powers of the first and last Grand Masters of the Temple within this jurisdiction ; and that

claim is valid , there is ample internal evidence in the degrees to those who understand them . The Kadosh are the only Soldiery of the Temple . "

Now all the above utterance is mere buncomb . Bro . Pike ought to know that power can only be exercised when aided by a well-equipped army , a navy , an organised police , or sufficient cash to buy up majorities of members

in our State Legislatures or of our Houses of Congress . That the assumption of high-sounding titles confer no power may be proved from the fact that a rival A . and A . concern has existed in Louisiana since 1813 , in defiance of

Bro . Pike ' s authority . Several A . and A . concerns exist in the Northern jurisdiction , in spite of S . G . C . Palmer ' s authority , and even the Grand Lodge of Massachusetts , since it declared itself protector of certain high degree concerns ,

found itself powerless to enforce its laws and penalties against those who chose to take its forbidden Rites and Degrees . Nor is the Kadosh any more the real soldiery

of the Temple than the Knights of Odd Fellows , and a dozen other so-called Knights including the " Knights of Labour . " Bro . Pike further says : —

When Masonry appeared in Europe in the Middle Ages , it had its mission that exposed it to persecution ; and that accounts for the solemnity of the obligations of the lesser mysteries . If it had been only what Blue Masonry is now in

England and America , its obligations being out of all proportion to its objects . The objects to which the Order owed its existence were abandoned in England about the time when it cressed the Atlantic . ... It [ they ]

became the ally and supporter of the English Government and Church . . . confining - '' - ' teachings within the domain of morality alone . But Scottish Masonry and the Ancient and Accepted Rite have not changed nor

denaturalised or perverted the meaning of their symbols . Now , as in the days of Dante , its mission is to aid humanity , setting its foot on despotism , and treading under foot tyranny and intolerance . The Cap of Liberty is the symbol of sovereignty of the people . "

All this is mere fiction ; for in the Middle Ages there existed no other kind of Masons but the building guilds , who knew nothing of either lesser or higher mysteries ; its mission was neither to establish the rights of the people

or to promote religious toleration , but for the purpose of monopolising the building trade and get as much wages for their labour as they could , just the same as the trade unions and knights of labour are trying to do to-day . The so-called

Masonic persecution in the Middle Ages was confined to England only ; that is , laws were enacted for specifying the rate of wages to all kinds of labourers , servants , and artizaus , including masons and carpenters , during the reigns

of Edward III ., Richard II ., and Henry VI . The carpenters and masons , however , managed to extort higher wages than the law allowed , hence they were threatened with punishment ; but I do not know whether any of them were ever punished . Nor was their Masonic O . B . out of

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1886-04-03, Page 4” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 12 Aug. 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_03041886/page/4/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
GRAND LODGE OF PENNSYLVANIA . Article 1
WHO IS FIRST? Article 2
WHAT BRO. PIKE BELIEVED IN 1871 AND WHAT HE BELIEVES NOW. Article 4
REVIEWS. Article 6
THE THEATRES, &c. Article 7
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 7
"MASONIC RECORDS." Article 7
THE COMING FESTIVAL OF THE GIRLS' SCHOOL. Article 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Article 9
A PANACEA FOR "THE UNEMPLOYED." Article 9
THE THIRD CITY MASONIC BENEVOLENT ASSOCIATION. Article 9
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 10
Untitled Ad 10
ROYAL ARCH. Article 10
NEW SOUTH WALES. Article 10
TO UNDERSTAND THE TRUTHS OF FREEMASONRY. Article 11
DOES IT PAY TO BE A MASON. Article 11
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 12
WHAT IS TO BE DONE ? Article 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
THE THEATRES, AMUSEMENTS, &c. Article 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

5 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

8 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

5 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

4 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

5 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

14 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

11 Articles
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Who Is First?

appropriate ceremonies which the Officers must see to , and if they be conferred without confusion or omission all is well . When Master and members have reached this stage of

declension in their appreciation of Masonry ( that is , if they ever had any ) the whole system takes its place in their minds alongside of the host of modern orders , and the

inducement to uphold the dignity of the Masonic Institution is at an end , and Masonry in its sublime aspect is lost . To counteract this tendency , everywhere exhibited , towards an utterly inadequate and false conception of

what the Symbolic Lodge really is , all Grand and Worshipful Masters , as being first in responsibility , should make no delay in aiding to restore in the minds of the brethren the knowledge and understanding of the things nnntftinfid in thft decreesboth severallv and collectivelv .

, —— -- o j •/ . r But this is not to be done either by patience or perseverance in the perusal of Masonic orations or the discursive effusions which reiterate the stereotyped eulogies on Masonry , its antiquity and grandeur , however forcible and

eloquent , or appropriate to the occasion which may have called them forth . The Craft have always been abundantly supplied , if not snowed under with this kind of literature , and all the time have learned nothing to the

point . The reasons are two : Jnrst , nothing can be put m print , even if the author knew what to put there , except such matters as may be a guide to those who will study Masonry where it is to be found ; and , second , no attempt

is made to show anything by any sort of proof or demonstration which can properly be written . The writings commonly published make no attempt even at this . They continue repeating in varied phrase what has been uttered

through generations , each writer relying with child-like simplicity on the authority of the one who last preceded him , and he on his predecessor , and so on back , while all

the time nothing is shown . Imagine an advocate appearing before a court to " show cause " for or against a rule or decision of any sort , who should indulge in a long eulogy of his client and a diatribe of an hour on the

timeworn subjects of justice , liberty and the glories of the Fourth of July and the battle of New Orleans , until choked off by the court . Could anybody learn from this , though repeated every day for a year , whether his client should have a rule or not ? Such is the case with Masonic utterances not intended to show anything of the true lore

of the Lodge , but only to compose excellent sentences into agreeable discourse , with more or less force and beauty , concerning Masonic sentiments and the principal objects of the Craft . Now , without laying aside the countless treasures of thought which are to be found in the literature above

mentioned , the Master or Grand Master who may desire to restore Masonic light to the craftsmen whom he represents , must pat himself to study , not from books , except as to a few particulars , but from the things contained in the Lodge —the proper and only storehouse of esoteric Masonic knowledge . He need not be afraid that he will exhaust

the subjects which will successively spring up in his pathway of exploration , or that Masonry will fail to demonstrate itself in the fulness of its admirable order , if it be sought out with the same astuteness and perseverance which the students of science exercise in bringing to li ght the secrets of the natural universe . —Voice of Masonry .

What Bro. Pike Believed In 1871 And What He Believes Now.

WHAT BRO . PIKE BELIEVED IN 1871 AND WHAT HE BELIEVES NOW .

Bv BEO . JACOB NORTON . IN Bro . Pike ' s " Masonic Origins , " he admitted , as I shall show hereafter , that the degrees of the Tork

Rite and of the Scottish Rite were alike modern . But in 1871 Bro . Pike issued a pamphlet , in which he denied the truth of the traditions of the so-called Tork Rite , but still clung to the notion that the Scottish Rite was ancient .

By way of a preface , I must inform the reader that in 1867 Bro . Geo . Frank Gouley edited a paper in St . Louis , called The Freemason , and that he was at the time Grand

Secretary of the Grand Lodge , and also Grand Master of the Missouri Templars . Bro . Gouley was then a firm believer in the traditions of the York or American Rite , consisting of

three Blue degrees , four Royal Arch degrees , three Templar degrees , and two or three of Royal Select degrees . About

What Bro. Pike Believed In 1871 And What He Believes Now.

the same time , Bro . Gouley received thirty-two degrees of the A . and A . Rite , when , to his horror , he discovered that in certain degrees of the Scottish Rite , the secrets of the Royal Arch and of the Knights Templars were

revealed . This brought on a discussion between the Missouri K . T . and the S . G . C . of tho Southern Jurisdiction of the A . and A . Rite , and a number of papers and pamphlets were issued bv the combatants . From Rebold

and Folger Bro . Gouley learned that the Charleston Frederick the Great Charter was a forgery , that the A . and A . Rite was a new concern ; and he charged the A . and A . Riters with having stolen tho Templar degree from the Tork Rite , and even went so far as to get the

Missouri Grand Comandry to "boycot" the A . and A . Riters . In 1871 Bro . Pike collected the articles , letters , & c , relating to the said controversy , and combined them in a pamphlet , headed " Vindication of the Ancient and Accepted Rite against certain libels . " The first part consists of an address by Bro . Pike to a body of A . and A .

Riters , in which he said : — " Tou are the chiefs of Exalted Masonry . Tour powers are real and substantial . If you do not duly estimate them , it is impossible that you should well perform the

corresponding duties . The highest of these accompany only the highest powers . . . Tou style yourselves Sovereign Grand Inspectors General , Grand Elect Knights of the Holy House of the Temple . Tou are so , if you

know the Royal secret , and understand the Holy doctrine . Tou claim to hold the powers of the first and last Grand Masters of the Temple within this jurisdiction ; and that

claim is valid , there is ample internal evidence in the degrees to those who understand them . The Kadosh are the only Soldiery of the Temple . "

Now all the above utterance is mere buncomb . Bro . Pike ought to know that power can only be exercised when aided by a well-equipped army , a navy , an organised police , or sufficient cash to buy up majorities of members

in our State Legislatures or of our Houses of Congress . That the assumption of high-sounding titles confer no power may be proved from the fact that a rival A . and A . concern has existed in Louisiana since 1813 , in defiance of

Bro . Pike ' s authority . Several A . and A . concerns exist in the Northern jurisdiction , in spite of S . G . C . Palmer ' s authority , and even the Grand Lodge of Massachusetts , since it declared itself protector of certain high degree concerns ,

found itself powerless to enforce its laws and penalties against those who chose to take its forbidden Rites and Degrees . Nor is the Kadosh any more the real soldiery

of the Temple than the Knights of Odd Fellows , and a dozen other so-called Knights including the " Knights of Labour . " Bro . Pike further says : —

When Masonry appeared in Europe in the Middle Ages , it had its mission that exposed it to persecution ; and that accounts for the solemnity of the obligations of the lesser mysteries . If it had been only what Blue Masonry is now in

England and America , its obligations being out of all proportion to its objects . The objects to which the Order owed its existence were abandoned in England about the time when it cressed the Atlantic . ... It [ they ]

became the ally and supporter of the English Government and Church . . . confining - '' - ' teachings within the domain of morality alone . But Scottish Masonry and the Ancient and Accepted Rite have not changed nor

denaturalised or perverted the meaning of their symbols . Now , as in the days of Dante , its mission is to aid humanity , setting its foot on despotism , and treading under foot tyranny and intolerance . The Cap of Liberty is the symbol of sovereignty of the people . "

All this is mere fiction ; for in the Middle Ages there existed no other kind of Masons but the building guilds , who knew nothing of either lesser or higher mysteries ; its mission was neither to establish the rights of the people

or to promote religious toleration , but for the purpose of monopolising the building trade and get as much wages for their labour as they could , just the same as the trade unions and knights of labour are trying to do to-day . The so-called

Masonic persecution in the Middle Ages was confined to England only ; that is , laws were enacted for specifying the rate of wages to all kinds of labourers , servants , and artizaus , including masons and carpenters , during the reigns

of Edward III ., Richard II ., and Henry VI . The carpenters and masons , however , managed to extort higher wages than the law allowed , hence they were threatened with punishment ; but I do not know whether any of them were ever punished . Nor was their Masonic O . B . out of

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 3
  • You're on page4
  • 5
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy